Catalonia Cannot Become Independent, Says Spain

By Ben Kopp
Impunity Watch Reporter, Europe Desk

MADRID, Spain – Amidst calls for separatist action, Madrid turned down a request for Catalonia to hold a referendum.

Spain’s parliament rejected the request for Catalonia to hold a referendum on independence, voting 299 to 47. (Photo courtesy of Deutsche Welle)

On 08 April 2014, Madrid refused permission for Catalonia to hold a Scottish-style independence referendum. The landslide vote settled at 299 to 47. Nevertheless, the President of Catalonia vowed to push ahead with plans to hold the referendum for the region just hours after Spain’s parliament overwhelmingly rejected the petition.

Earlier in the day Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy had closed the door on the referendum insisting that it was not allowed under Spain’s constitution, following last month’s ruling by Spain’s Constitutional Court that a region like Catalonia could not “unilaterally” call a referendum on its sovereignty. He also warned that Catalonia’s independence would be economically disastrous for both the region and Spain.

“Together we all win and separate we all lose,” Rajoy told parliament. “This isn’t just a question of law, but of sentiment … I can’t imagine Spain without Catalonia, or Catalonia out of Europe.”

Rajoy warned that Catalonia’s isolation from Spain and the European Union would turn it into “the closest thing imaginable to the island of Robinson Crusoe.”

In response to Rajoy’s comment, Alfred Bosch, spokesman of the Catalan left-wing separatist party ERC said: “We are not Robinson Crusoe. Right now we are Friday, the servant, who can’t even choose his own name.”

“They are afraid of the vote of the Catalan people,” Artur Mas, President of the northeastern region said. “Some would like to present this as an end to the matter. But as the President of Catalonia, I have to tell them this is not the end. It is simply a new paragraph. Catalan Institutions will search through the legal frameworks to find away to continue with this consultation.”

Since the beginning of the economic crisis, separatist sentiment has soared, with growing resentment over “unfair” redistribution taxes from the wealthy region across the rest of Spain. Many believe that Catalonia’s distinct language and culture would fare better on its own. Mas has planned a referendum for 09 November 2014.

Of the region’s 7.5 million people, the latest polls have shown that about 80% in the region want the right to hold a referendum on independence and roughly half of Catalans voters would vote ‘yes’ to breakaway state.

During the debate Mr Rajoy also rejected comparisons with Scotland which will hold its own referendum on independence in September.

“Don’t talk to me about Scotland,” the Spanish premier said. “Because it responds to a very different constitutional and historic situation. If they had half the devolved powers (of Catalonia) they wouldn’t have taken the trouble they have.”

For further information, please see:

Euronews – Spain Rejects Catalonia Bid for Independence Referendum – April 09, 2014

Reuters – Catalan Leader Says Parliament Rejection Won’t Halt Referendum – April 09, 2014

Telegraph – Catalonia Vows to Continue Independence Fight after Referendum Snub – April 09, 2014

Deutsche Welle – Spanish Parliament Rejects Catalonia Independence Referendum – April 08, 2014

Congress Investigates Secret “Cuban Twitter”

by Michael Yoakum
Impunity Watch Reporter, North America

WASHINGTON, D.C., United States – The Senate Foreign Relations Committee request records from the US Agency for International Development (USAID)’s Cuban operations Thursday.  This request came after evidence emerged that the US government funded ZunZuneo, dubbed the “Cuban Twitter” by reports.

Sen. Robert Menendez, chairman of the Foreign Relationship Committee, defended the program during hearings. (Photo courtesy of BBC News)

The Associated Press reported early last week that the Twitter-like program, administered by USAID, provided social media service to Cuban citizens from 2009 to 2012 when federal grant money ran out.  The purpose of this “Cuban Twitter” was to promulgate information to undermine the communist government and gather demographic information on dissidents in Cuban.

The US government reportedly hid its involvement in ZunZuneo by creating a shell corporation in Spain to finance the operation.

Members of the Senates and House of Representative expressed concern about the program’s administration through USAID rather than an intelligence agency. “Why would we put that mission in USAID?” Republican Senator Mike Johanns asked, adding “Why wouldn’t you look at some other part of the federal government to place that mission? To me, it seems crazy.”

Documents obtained by AP show that the site’s early messages poked fun at the Castro government and were created by a satirist working for the social media project.  This conflicted with earlier statements by the Obama administration that the messages were not political in nature.

Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, who is Cuban-born, defended the pro-democracy operations carried out by USAID, saying the program was “so important to offer the other side of the story, the side that promotes American values: God-given values like freedom, justice or liberty.”

Other lawmakers were uncomfortable with the idea of USAID, an organization known for providing humanitarian aid without involving itself in political situations, conducting covert operations.

Sen. Patrick Leahy, chair of the Senate panel, said he had no prior knowledge of the Twitter-like operation, contradicting claims by SAID Administrator Rajiv Shah that Congress was properly informed.

Leahy later clarified that he was notified generally of the program, but not of the program’s risks, its political nature or the extensive efforts to conceal Washington’s involvement.

For more information, please see:

BBC News – Senate requests information on USAID internet projects – 10 April 2014

ABC News – Senator: Aid Agency Laudable for ‘Cuban Twitter’ – 9 April 2014

National Public Radio – Was ‘Cuban Twitter’ Program Political Or Not? – 9 April 2014

TIME – USAID Denies ‘Cuban Twitter’ Was Meant To Subvert – 8 April 2014

The Washington Post – U.S. secretly created ‘Cuban Twitter’ to stir unrest – 3 April 2014

King Abdullah Calls for Ban on Saudi Women’s Sports to be Removed

By Darrin Simmons
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia-After much support from Saudi Arabian King Abdullah calling for women’s rights social reforms, Saudi authorities have been asked to remove the school ban on girls’ sports.

Saudi women participating in a physical education class (photo courtesy of Al-Bawaba)

Saudi women, under strict interpretations of sharia law, are banned from driving and must obtain permission from a male relative to leave the country, start a job, or open a bank account.

Saudi Arabia has maintained an official ban on sports classes for girls in state schools due to pressure from religious conservatives.  King Abdullah, however, has implemented great change in women’s rights when he appointed thirty women to the 150-member chamber for the first time, just a year ago.

The Shura Council, which advises the Saudi Arabian government on policy, requested that the education ministry investigate into allowing girls to participate in state-run schools, assuming that they conform to sharia rules on dress and gender segregation.

The Council’s decisions are not binding, but influential in Saudi Arabia because it is the only official forum for the public to discuss new laws and government policy surrounding sensitive social issues.  A law removing the ban would not become official until it received ministry and cabinet approval.

In support of the decision, Council members relied on recent studies showing an increase in obesity related illnesses among Saudi Arabian women.  “The education affairs committee saw that ratifying this decision does not contradict Sharia law, pointing out that a previous fatwa (religious ruling) allowed for sports for women in general,” stated one council member.

Those in opposition argued that most schools are not equipped to allow girls’ sports, while also challenging the notion that physical education lessons has decreased obesity in boys.

Private schools have officially removed a ban on girls sports last year, following many private schools already providing girls physical education classes.

Saudi women were included in its Olympic team for the first time only two years ago, at the London 2012 Games.  The allowance garnered much support but also criticism of the two female athletes, a runner and a judoka, on social media.

Opposition, however, is great as many powerful clerics and their supporters fear the kingdom is losing its Islamic values in favor of western ideas.  Despite these challenges, King Abdullah has made major strides in making it easier for Saudi women to work and study alongside men, while promoting more tolerant views of other religions.

For more information, please see the following: 

Al Bawaba-Saudi girls will soon be able to play soccer, shoot hoops-10 April 2014

Al Jazeera-Saudi considers lifting ban on girls sports-10 April 2014

Guardian-Saudi Arabia may review ban on girls’ school sports-10 April 2014

Reuters-Saudi authorities asked to allow school sport for girls: agency-10 April 2014

Italian Government Seeks EU Help As 4,000 Migrants Reach Shores In 48 Hours

by Tony Iozzo
Impunity Watch Reporter, Europe

Pozzallo, ITALY – Approximately 4,000 immigrants have reached the shores of Italy over the last 48 hour, according to Italian officials, and Italy is calling on the European Union for help.

Migrants off the coast of Sicily in January, after a Naval rescue mission. (Photo courtesy of The Guardian)

The Italian government has stated that the latest influx of immigrants has been the highest mass immigration the country has seen since its launch of a naval operation to rescue immigrants at sea. The naval operation, referred to as “Mare Nostrum,” was launched in light of two shipwrecks in October of 2013 that claimed the lives of over 400 migrants from Eritrea and Syria.

The Italian government reported a roughly 60 percent increase in asylum claims in 2013. Most of these claims were from those fleeing Syria. Italy’s Interior Minister, Angelino Alfano, estimated that 15,000 migrants had been rescued so far this year in the Mediterranean Sea, and up to 600,000 migrants from Africa and the Middle East are still ready to launch from Libya. Alfano called on the international community to set up “refugee camps” in Libya and stated that the next six months would be “extremely difficult” because favorable weather conditions meant more migrants would cross the Mediterranean Sea.

“The landings are non-stop and the emergency is increasingly glaring,” stated Alfano. “Europe must take the situation in hand. It cannot say that, having given 80 million euros ($110 million) to [the EU’s border control agency], the problem has been resolved,” Alfano stated.

The Italian Navy stated that of the 4,000 recent arrivals, it had rescued approximately 2,500 of the migrants, and further migrants were being aided by coastguard ships and merchant ships. Alfano also stated that “the procedure for expelling those who do not have a right to stay in Italy should be sped up, but we should welcome those who have a right to asylum.”

The recent influx of migrants comes amidst the buzz of European Parliament elections next month. Lawmakers have disagreed on the migrant influx. MP’s Davide Caparini and Nicola Molteni have urged Alfano to quell the arrivals “by turning them back” and have claimed that asylum-seekers are getting better treatment “than any Italian citizen.” Senator Luigi Manconi, however, the head of the human rights committee in Parliament, stated that the problem was Italy’s to bear.

“We are not facing an invasion, absolutely not. We have to criticize ourselves for not putting in the necessary measures in time,” Manconi said.

The Italian Navy stated that it has undertaken health checks on board of the vessels on which the migrants were rescued and taken the migrants to the ports of Augusta and Pozzallo in Sicily.

On Wednesday, six large tents were assembled in Pozzallo for some migrants, while others have been transported across the country.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera – Italy Sounds Alarm as 4,000 Immigrants Land – 9 April 2014

Deutsche Welle – Italy Alarmed Over Boat Migrant Influx – 9 April 2014

The Guardian – 4,000 Immigrants Reach Italy By Boat In 48 Hours, As Minister Calls For EU Help – 9 April 2014

Reuters – Italy Rescues 4,000 Migrants In 48 Hours In Escalating Crisis – 9 April 2014

Self-Immolation Case Highlights the Desperation of Syrian Refugees

By Kathryn Maureen Ryan Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East BEIRUT, Lebanon – Mariam al-Khawli, a Syrian refugee who fled the conflict in her home country two years ago, self-immolation in front of the United Nations headquarters in Beirut Lebanon last Week. She doused herself with gasoline and lit herself on fire in protest of the devastating cuts to aid for refugees that have affected her ability to provide for her family. She came to Lebanon two years ago with her husband and four children after fleeing the violence in her home country. Like many refugees she depended on aid to provide for her family, including treatment for her children’s health conditions, which had stopped in August.

Roughly half of the more than one million Syrian refugees are living in Syria are children. the sudden influx in refugee population in Lebanon has left resources stretched thin and presented difficult challenges for the Untied Nations and other aid agencies; which face devastating cuts from donor states (Photo courtesy of Al Jazeera)

Mariam al-Khawli survived her protest and is now being hospitalized. According to her doctor, Gabriel al-Sabeh, said 70 percent of Mariam al-Khawli’s body is now covered in severe burns and if she survives she will be hospitalized for several months to treat her injuries. Mariam al-Khawli’s decision to protest the United Nations aid cuts in this fashion was driven by her family’s desperation. Her husband is unable to work due to a lung abscess and three of her four children have blood conditions that require treatment. She said of the UN’s action that “”they burned my heart before they burned my body. They burned my heart from the inside.” Mariam al-Khawli is one of more than one million refugee’s struggling to survive in Lebanon. On 3 April the one millionth refugee to enter Lebanon was officially registered. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has called this a “devastating milestone” for a small country whose resources have been stretched extremely thin as a result of the sudden and massive influx of civilian refugees into their population. It is now believed that about one quarter of the population on Lebanon is now made up of Syrian refuges. Ninette Kelley, regional representative for Lebanon at the Office of the United States High Commissioner for Refugees, said Khawli’s case was “a very sorrowful reflection of the enormous desperation and need of the refugee community and it is also a telling reminder of the consequences of the Syrian emergency and the unfolding crisis here in Lebanon”. According to UNHCR chief Antonio Guterres this “devastating milestone” has been worked by the rapid depletion of resources in Lebanon, the host country for more than one million refugees from Syria and previous conflicts in Palestine, which has left the country “stretched to breaking point.” He said, “Tiny Lebanon has now become the country with “the highest per capita concentration of refugees worldwide,” and is “struggling to keep pace.” According to Antonio Guterres “almost half of the Syrian population is displaced.” The United Nations has cut the size of food parcels providing to starving Syrian communities by a fifth because of a shortage of funding form donor states. The United Nations’ World Food Programme managed to get food to a record 4.21 million people inside Syria in March despite funding challenges. However, this was just fort of its target of reaching 4.2 million people. Donor states pledged $2.3 billion for aid agencies helping Syria at a conference in Kuwait in January. However, only $1.1 billion of the funds pledged has actually reached these agencies. The delay in donor states meeting their pledges for the Syrian people has led to a cut in the standard size of a food basket for a family of five people. Last month, Lebanon’s foreign minister said the crisis was “threatening the existence of Lebanon,” a country that is still recovering from its own bloody 15-year civil war that ended in 1990. According to Jan Egeland, the secretary-general of the Norwegian Refugee Council, an organization that has about 1,000 relief workers on the ground in and around Syria, Syrian refugees living in Lebanon could be significantly higher than the official numbers. He said not all Syrian refugees living in Lebanon had become officially registered with the United Nations, a process that often takes months. Egeland argued that the scope and breadth of the refugee crisis creating by the Syrian Civil War is not well understood and the international community may not be prepared to deal with the crises. He said, “his is not just another war, this is a generational challenge and we are not up to meeting that challenge.” For more information please see: Al Jazeera – Fund Crunch Forces UN to Cut Syria Food Aid – 09 April 2014 Al Jazeera – Syrian Refugees Hit Million Mark in Lebanon – 03 April 2014 Al Jazeera – Syrian Self-Immolation Case Reflects Tragedy – 03 April 2014 The Times of Malta – ‘They Burned My Heart Before My Body’ – 03 April 2014 The New York Times – Lebanon Hosts Over a Million Who Fled Syria, U.N. Reports – 03 April 2014