1,000 Kyrgyz Prisoners Sew Mouths Shut

by Hibberd Kline
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

BISHKEK, Kyrgyzstan — More than 1,000 Kyrgyz inmates sewed their mouths shut as part of a coordinated, nationwide hunger-strike following a January 16 prison riot.

Inmates reportedly stitched their mouths shut in order to prevent prison authorities from force-feeding them (Photo courtesy of Al Jazeera).

Approximately 6,400 of Kyrgyzstan’s nearly 7,600 inmates participated in the 10 day hunger strike. Estimates put the number of inmates who sewed their lips shut between 1,175-1,300.

More than 400 of the striking inmates sewed their mouths shut using wire, staples and whatever other materials they could find after prison guards attempted to break the hunger strike by force-feeding them. The sewing tactic soon spread to other prisons through the use of smuggled cell phones in what the prisoners pronounced to be “an act of solidarity.”

Prisoners claim that the hunger-strike was aimed at securing improved living conditions including better mattresses, basic “liberties” and an end to abuses by prison guards. The hunger strikers also called for the resignation of the head of the national prison service and the director of the Bishkek Detention Center Number 1, where the protest began.

However, Kyrgyz authorities paint a very different picture. Kyrgyz officials accuse the prisoners of striking in coordination with Kyrgyzstan’s notorious crime syndicates, who have historically exercised a significant degree of influence in Kyrgyzstan’s prisons.

Sheishenbek Baizakov, head of the Kyrgyzstan State Penitentiary Service, told reporters that the strike began with calls to re-institute the policy of “common prison cells,” in which prisoners had previously been allowed to roam about the prison largely unrestricted by the guards at all times. Officials claim that the common cells reduced control by prison guards and allowed criminal gangs to more easily conduct smuggling and drug trafficking operations as well as to coerce and intimidate inmates.

Baizakov further told reporters that the prison staff itself had been heavily infiltrated by the syndicates. Baizakov explained that he had fired 80% of Kyrgyzstan’s prison directors for “creat[ing] corrupt schemes and forg[ing] alliances with the criminal underworld.”

Chairman Baizakov was appointed last year with a mandate from President Almazbek Atambayev to crackdown on organized crime in Kyrgyzstan’s penal system. The Administration sees the criminal syndicates’ powerful influence as a threat to Kyrgyzstan’s stability. Under Baizakov’s direction, prisons have begun to institute more stringent rules and several former prison directors now face criminal charges including drug trafficking.

The hunger strike followed on the heels of a prison riot that erupted in Detention Center Number 1 in Bishkek on January 16 leaving 30 prisoners and five guards injured. Additionally, reports indicate that at least one person was killed.

Authorities allege that the riot was sparked by the transfer of a crime boss to another facility as part of Baizakov’s crackdown on organized crime in the prison system. Special riot police raided the prison and used force to put down the riot.

The center’s director Mars Zhuzubekov told the press that during the raid authorities confiscated contraband items such as plasma televisions and refrigerators. Zhuzubekov did not mince his words when he laid out his vision of how a prison should be run; “This is not a hotel, this is not a holiday resort, they should serve their time.”

As the protest ended, Chairman Baizakov echoed Zhuzubekov’s sentiments stating that inmates would not be allowed to continue “to make fools of the guards.” Baizakov pronounced; “let them all sew their mouths shut.”

Inmates’ parents, who have been picketing the Kyrgyz Parliament since the January 16 riot, have called for Chairman Baizakov’s resignation.

According to deputy head of Kyrgyzstan’s prison services Kubanychbek Kenenbayey, the prisoners finally called off their protests on January 28. Kenenbayey informed the press that inmates at a women’s prison in Stepnoe village were the last to agree to break their fast. Tursunbek Akun, Kyrgyzstan’s human rights ombudsman, explained that the prisoners had ceased their protest after “being convinced that there would be no more excesses on the part of their guards.”

Prison spokeswoman Eleonora Sharshenaliayeva informed the press that as the protest drew to a close more than 200 prisoners appealed to medical services for help in removing stitches from their mouths.

In the aftermath of the protests, Kyrgyzstan’s authorities have continued to implement plans to tighten control over the country’s prison system. Proposed measures include the installation of new video surveillance systems and cell-phone jamming technology in Kyrgyzstan’s prisons and penal colonies. Chairman Baizakov announced that it would likely take the authorities 3 months to install the new systems, which have been estimated to cost 22 million soms (approximately $USD 470,000).

Current state penitentiary service policy allows inmates to make 8 phone calls per year using prison phone services. Blocking the use of cell phones in prison facilities is expected to reduce inmates’ ability to coordinate with outside criminal contacts or prisoners in other facilities.

Regardless of whether or not the protests were engineered by the crime syndicates, the situation has once again highlighted conditions in Kyrgyzstan’s penal system.

In response to the protests, Matteo Mecacci, the chair of the human rights committee for the parliamentary assembly of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, called for conditions to be eased in Kyrgyzstan’s detention facilities.

Kyrgyzstan’s prisons have long been notoriously overcrowded and prone to pestilence. There are currently 7,600 inmates incarcerated in Kyrgyzstan’s 11 penal colonies and 6 detention centers. An additional 7,000 people who have been convicted of  lesser crimes are required to check in daily with the police and are confined to their home regions.

For more information, please see:

Kyrghiz Telegraph Agency — 22 Million Soms to the Purchase of Equipment to Jam Cellular Communications in the Colonies and the Jail-GSIN — 02 February 2012

Al Jazeera — Kyrgyz Prisoners End Self-mutilation Protest — 28 January 2012

The Associated Press — Kyrgyz Prisoners Sew Lips Shut; Is Mafia to Blame? — 28 January 2012

The Korea Herald — Kyrgyz Inmates Sew Mouths Shut — 27 January 2012

Reuters — Hunger-striking Kyrgyz Prisoners Stitch Mouths Shut — 27 January 2012

Voice of America — 1,000 Kyrgyz Inmates Sew Lips in Protest — 27 January 2012

BBC News — Kyrgyzstan Prison Protest: Inmates Sew Lips Together — 25 January 2012

South Korean Indicted Over Twitter Posts

By Greg Donaldson
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

SEOUL, South Korea – Twenty-three year old Park Jung-geun was indicted last Tuesday on charges that he violated South Korea’s controversial National Security Law. The National Security Law broadly bans “acts that benefit the enemy” referring to North Korea. However, the law does not explain what acts are violations of the law. If convicted, Park could receive up to seven years in prison.

North Korean poster than Mr. Park modified and posted to his Twitter account (Photo Courtesy of The New York Times)

Park is a well-known social media and freedom-of-speech activist and a member of the Socialist Party. Park, who runs a photo studio in Seoul where he specializes in taking pictures of babies, was arrested last month for re-tweeting messages posted on the Twitter account of North Korea’s Committee for the Peaceful Reunification of Korea.

Park reposted messages such as “Long live Kim Jong-Il” and “Dear General Kim Jong-Il is the genius of the military and the symbol of victory who the entire world looks up to and follows,” according to South Korea’s Yonhap news agency.

In his personal postings on Twitter, Park has compared himself to “The Young General ,” referring to Kim Jong—un, because he inherited his photo studio from his father. Park has also posted links to North Korean propaganda songs and a North Korean poster that he altered. Park transformed the soldier’s face to his own and replaced the soldier’s gun with a bottle of whiskey.

Park, whose Twitter profile picture shows him standing in front of a red-starred North Korean flag with a near-empty bottle of whiskey in his hand, says he re-tweeted posts from Pyongyang’s Twitter account that he thought were ridiculous. In an interview last December, Mr. Park said “it was humiliating and ludicrous to have to wear a straight face and explain all my jokes to the detectives.”

The South Korean government has taken Mr. Park’s actions very seriously. When investigators searched Park’s apartment they copied computer hard drives and confiscated books and photographs. After five interrogation sessions Mr. Park was arrested.

Sam Zarifi, Asia-Pacific director of Amnesty International, called the charges “ludicrous” and said they should be dropped immediately. She further explained, “This is not a national security case; it’s a sad case of the South Korean authorities’ complete failure to understand sarcasm.”

The United Nations Human Rights Commission and Amnesty International have called for the National Security Law to be diluted or repealed. Rajiv Narayan, a researcher for Amnesty International, has said the law has a “chilling effect on critics of the government’s North Korea policies. Proponents of the National Security Law defend it vigorously explaining that the law is a defense against North Korea and it is especially important as Kim Jong Un gains power.

For more information please see:      

Los Angeles Times – South Korean Security Law is used to Silence Dissent, Critics Say – 5 February 2012

CBC News – South Korean Charged for Re-Tweeting North Korean Posts – 2 February 2012

New York Times –South Korean Indicted Over Twitter Posts from North—2 February 2012

Washington Post – South Korean Indicted for Re-Tweeting Messages from North Korean Government – 2 February 2012

 

South Africa’s Ruling Party Upholds Suspension of Youth Leader

By Zach Waksman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

JOHANNESBURG, South Africa – The African National Congress (ANC), South Africa’s governing party, upheld the suspension issued to Julius Malema, president of the ANC’s Youth League (ANCYL), on Saturday.  The controversial firebrand was given a five-year suspension from involvement in the party in November 2011.  ANCYL deputy president Ronald Lamola, treasurer general Pule Mabe, secretary general Sindiso Magaqa, deputy secretary general Kenetswe Mosenogi; and spokesperson Floyd Shivambu were also given suspensions.

After his appeal failed on Saturday, rivals of suspended ANCYL President Julius Malema held a coffin aloft to symbolize the likely end of his political career in his hometown of Sheshego. (Photo courtesy of The Times (Johannesburg))

Malema, 30, had once been a key player in President Jacob Zuma’s ascent to power in 2007.  He said he would kill for Zuma.  But since then, he had changed his mind, throwing his support behind Thabo Mbeki, the president that Zuma unseated.  Comments like these were the basis for his November suspension, as he was found guilty of “sowing division within the ANC and of bringing the party into disrepute.”

This was not the first time Malema had drawn a suspension from the party.  At his first disciplinary hearing in 2010, he pleaded guilty to the same charge, drawing a two-year suspension; that sentence was suspended.  It will soon begin and run concurrently with the five-year ban.  He will be stripped of his power and position and banished from the party.

The once powerful youth president made numerous provocative statements from his post.  A black nationalist, Malema called for many policies that drew criticism.  The ANC has a majority-black electorate, but his call for seizure of white-owned land for redistribution to poor blacks placed his party in conflict with both its constituents and the business community.  In July 2009, he recommended that South Africa seize control of its mining industry, ostensibly to end white domination of the economy.

“[W]hen the imperialist forces are accepting the failures of capitalism, we should ask whether the time has not arrived for the government to make sure that the state owns the mines and other means of production,” Malema said about the policy.

But the last straw for his continued service to the ANCYL came last July.  During a speech, he appeared to recommend that the neighboring country of Botswana change its government, which is democratically elected.  To some, he may have been advocating an invasion.

“Botswana is in full co-operation with imperialists,” he had said in reference to the country’s strong relationship with the United States.

The appeals panel that conducted the hearing believed it had no choice but to uphold the sentence.

“Discipline is one of the key pillars in the life of the ANC,” said Cyril Ramaphosa, a senior party official who led the panel.

Though the panel overturned a sentence for “barging” into an ANC meeting, it considered most of the ANCYL’s arguments to have little merit.

“The appellants’ argument that individual members [of the disciplinary committee] could exert pressure to bear on the NEC and the ANC itself to decide the issues of nationalization and expropriation of land in a particular way and that the exclusion of the appellant would facilitate this outcome is both naïve and absurd,” Ramaphosa said.

In about two weeks, Malema has the opportunity to argue for a reduction of his sentence.  The ANC will also be able to make an argument, only for an increase in punishment. He will remain in his capacity as President of the ANCYL until the mitigation hearings are complete.  Malema’s chances at obtaining a reduction are considered slim.

“The chances of a reduced sentence are zero[,]” wrote political analyst Eusebius McKaiser in an online article for Politicsweb.  “And all that (arguments in mitigation) will achieve is to keeping Malema politically on a life support system for a little while longer. It will not stave off the eventual outcome – political demise.”

The news of the appeal’s failure was cause for celebration in Malema’s hometown of Seshego, where youths viewed him as a dictator.  Residents set fire to a Malema t-shirt and car horns resonated across the town.

“I have many responsibilities[;] I don’t care what happened to him… I have my own problems. I want to go back to school and I don’t have money, if I cry for him what will I get?” asked a local resident who did not consider the matter worthy of concern.  “They [the ANCYL] talk about economic freedom and nationalization but we [are still] struggling…”

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera — S. Africa’s ANC Denies Appeal of Youth Leader — 06 February 2012

Cape Times — Malema Hangs on by Thin Thread — 06 February 2012

Mail & Guardian — A League of His Own: ANC Grants Juju a Stay of Execution — 06 February 2012

The Times (Johannesburg) — Malema’s Hometown Celebrates His Failed Appeal — 06 February 2012

BBC — Julius Malema: S. Africa’s ANC Youth Leader Loses Appeal — 04 February 2012

Mail & Guardian — Malema’s Appeal Denied by Disciplinary Committee — 04 February 2012

New York Times — A.N.C. Keeps Suspension of a Leader — 04 February 2012

The Times (Johannesburg) — Guilty! — 04 February 2012

BBC — South Africa’s Julius Malema in His Own Words — 10 November 2011

‘Homs Offensive’ Claims More Lives in Syria, As International Community Continually Debates Resolution

By Adom M. Cooper
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

HOMS, Syria–One day after a UN Security Council resolution aimed at ending the bloodshed in Syria was vetoed by China and Russia, the Syrian army has increased its attacks on opposition fighters in Homs. The Syrian Revolution General Commission, an opposition group, stated that 15 individuals were killed in Homs on Monday 06 February 2012 and at least three others were killed in Aleppo. Al-Jazeera received video from opposition activists that depicted apparent devastation caused by a military offensive in the Bab Amr neighborhood of Homs.

A wounded woman in Bab Amr with a bandage on her head.(Photo Courtesy of The Guardian)

Activists and witnesses said the army had been shelling the neighborhood “indiscriminately” since the morning of Sunday 05 February 2012. Abu Abdo Alhomsy, an activist of a revolutionary council in Homs, shared these words with Al-Jazeera on Monday 06 February 2012 concerning the attacks.

“It is horrible right here. Rockets are falling. There are massive explosions that shook buildings. We don’t know really what to do. It’s a massive attack-a new massacre is happening here. Nobody can go out, we don’t know how many homes have been hit or how many people died.”

Danny Abdul Dayem, a resident of Homs, shared these words with Al-Jazeera concerning the shelling in Bab Amr. Video images have surfaced showing people who have been shot and hit by shrapnel, including children sustaining fatal injuries.

“It has been terrible. There is non-stop bombing with rockets, mortar bombs, and tank shells. There were more than 50 people injured in Bab Amr today. I saw with my own eyes kids with no legs, and a kid who lost his whole bottom jaw. It is terrible.”

Dayem also indicated that only one field hospital with four doctors was still operating in the city and that it was virtually impossible to get additional medication for anything short of a gunshot wound.

The Syrian state television has denied that there had been any such bombardment in the country. It stated that residents were setting fire to piles of rubbish on the roofs of their homes in an attempt to trick the world into believing that there was an attack. The phrase “terrorist gangs” was used to describe whom was responsible for the blown up buildings in Homs. The government has come out and said that it is fighting foreign-backed armed groups

According to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights (SOHR), a London-based rights organization, army deserters in the northeast region of the country destroyed a military control post early on Monday 06 February 2012, killing three officers and capturing 19 soldiers. The fighting occurred in the village of Al Bara in the Edleb region and that none of the army deserters involved in the skirmish lost their lives.

The death toll in Syria rose to at least 88 people over the weekend, deemed one of the bloodiest since the demonstrations and protests against al-Assad’s regime began nearly 11 months ago. The chaos and turmoil in the country has claimed at least 6,000 lives total in Syria, according to various opposition groups.

The international community continues to react to the situation in Syria instead of taking a proactive approach. According to French authorities, The European Union (EU) is set to strengthen sanctions imposed on Syria in a bid to boost pressure on the government. Alain Juppe, the French foreign minister, shared these words with BFMTV television on Sunday 05 February 2012.

“Europe will again harden sanctions imposed on the Syrian regime. We will try to increase this international pressure and there will come a time when the regime will have to realize that it is completely isolated and cannot continue.”

The United States closed its embassy in Syria and pulled out its remaining staff on Monday 06 February 2012, citing serious security concerns as al-Assad’s regime increased its crackdown, causing more bloodshed. The State Department released a statement containing the following on the decision to close the Syrian embassy.

“The United States has suspended operations of our embassy in Damascus as of 06 February. Ambassador Robert Ford and all American personnel have now departed the country. The recent surge in violence, including bombings in Damascus on 23 December and 06 January, has raised serious concerns that our embassy is not sufficiently protested from armed attack.”

With all of the attacks and death occurring the around the nation, it can only be extremely disheartening to Syrian civilians to see nations such as China and Russia veto a UN Security Council resolution and the US close its embassy. Regardless of what the “big-time” actors are doing, people are still suffering and dying on the ground. These are the same people that are continually at the mercy of al-Assad’s regime. It would seem that the only way for these people’s voices to be heard and acted on is the permanent absence of al-Assad’s regime. Much like Hosni Mubarak of Egypt and Moammar Gaddafi of Libya, the permanent absence of a multi-decade dictator is the only way for the demonstrations and protests to actually mean something for change.

 

For more information, please see: 

Ahram – US Closes Syria Embassy, Pulls Out All Staff – 06 February 2012

http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/2/8/33861/World/Region/US-closes-Syria-embassy,-pulls-out-all-staff.aspx

Al-Jazeera – Syrian Army ‘Steps Up Homs Offensive’ – 06 February 2012

http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2012/02/20122614732355122.html

BBC – Syria Crisis: Army Steps Up Homs Shelling – 06 February 2012

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-16902819

CNN – US Closes Embassy As Fighting Rages In Syria – 06 February 2012

http://www.cnn.com/2012/02/06/world/meast/syria-unrest/index.html?hpt=imi_c1

The Guardian – Syrian Forces ‘Kill At Least 50’ In Homs Bombardment – 06 February 2012

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/feb/06/syrian-forces-homs-bombardment

Reuters – Syria Bombards Homs; West Scrambles For New Strategy – 06 February 2012

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/06/us-syria-idUSTRE80S08620120206