Kyrgyzstan Post-Ethnic Revolution Reform

David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

BISHKEK, Kyrgyzstan – The efforts to achieve “inter-ethnic reconciliation and integration” following the violent events in Southern Kyrgyzstan last June, when over 435 people dead and nearly 2,500 others injured between the Kyrgyz and Uzbek communities during an inter-ethnic conflict, has been difficult.

People display a Kyrgyz national flag in front of the government building in Bishkek on Thursday. (EPA)
People display a Kyrgyz national flag in front of the government building in Bishkek on Thursday. (EPA)

The European Union has praised Kyrgyzstan’s reform agenda for stabilization and democratization, describing it as “ambitious”. Further reforms are critical to stability in southern Kyrgyzstan as the situation in the volatile region is “not optimistic,” chief of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) said Thursday.

OSCE Chairperson-in-Office and Lithuanian Foreign Minister Audronius Ažubalis vowed to help Kyrgyzstan bolster its stability, security and parliamentary system during his March 2-3 trip to Osh and Bishkek.

“It is essential to strengthen dialogue between the ethnic communities. The OSCE supports Kyrgyzstan in meeting these challenges, in particular ready to support a national consultative mechanism on police reform and criminal justice.”

“Kyrgyzstan’s efforts to restore stability after last year’s tragic events are commendable, I encourage the government to continue reforms, particularly ahead of the forthcoming presidential election,” he concluded.

“We must address acute security concerns, including threats to border security. But ensuring long-term security in the country also requires reform of the police and judiciary, policies to promote economic stability and respect for the rights of all members of society,” Azubalis said..

“The efforts of state-building in Kyrgyzstan and of bolstering its democracy and economy should draw on the citizenship of its people – and not simply their ethnicity,” said José Manuel Barroso, president of the European Commission.

The OSCE is also determined to continue co-operating with Kyrgyzstan in battling trans-national threats like terrorism, drug trafficking, organized crime and unsecure borders, by coordinating with international partners like the UN and European Union, said Ažubalis.

Kyrgyzstan President Roza Otunbayeva has played a key role in two revolutions.

Roza Otunbayeva inspired the protest movement; often considered a philosopher and diplomat, she took the helm of the country and guided it through a difficult and dangerous transition period, declaring war on corruption, the clan system, nationalism and religious extremism.

Her first vistory was ridding the country of its then leader, President Akayev in 2005. Five years later President Bakiyev‎ was removed by a similar popular revolution.

A year ago a number of opposition parties came together, united in aversion to Bakiyev‎‘s corrupt regime. Realizing then the need to move toward a parliamentary form of government.

“Recent events in North Africa allow us to see things in a different light. It’s clear that these types of people, who allegedly order mass killings, should be punished”, said Otunbayeva referring to Bakiyev and his family tree of corruption being the center of all atrocities that took place within the countries recent history.

“A society influenced by criminality has no future. So one needs a clear and strong plan of action. The people will always support authorities or leaders who really want to clean up the country,” said Otunbayeva.

For more information, please see:

XINHUA news – Reforms critical to Kyrgyzstan’s stability: OCSE chairman – 4 March 2011

Europolitics – EU Praises Kyrgyzstan Reform Agenda – 1 March 2011

Central Asia Online – OSCE to help Kyrgyz stability, security, parliament – 3 March 2011

Euro News – Kyrgyzstan: Politics post revolution – 4 March 2011

UNHCR: Pro-Regime Fighters Limit Libya-Tunisia Border Crossings

By Daniel M. Austin
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

Civilians crossing the Libya-Tunisia border. (Photo courtesy of Sky News).
Civilians crossing the Libya-Tunisia border. (Photo courtesy of Sky News).

GENEVA, Switzerland – According to the United Nation High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) the number of civilians crossing the border from Libya to Tunisia has dropped dramatically since Wednesday March 2. The UNHCR suspects that refugees trying to flee the violence in Libya are either being harassed or prevented entirely from crossing into Tunisia by heavily armed pro-government mercenaries loyal to Col. Moammar Gadhafi. In response to continuing violence in Libya, several nations have mobilized aircraft and naval assets to assist in evacuating refugees and to support a humanitarian mission in both Tunisia and Libya.

The UNHCR claims that on Wednesday, March 2 as many as 10,000 to 15,000 people were crossing the border between Egypt and Libya. However by Thursday, March 3, the number had dropped to 2,000 people. Civilians that have made it across the border claim mercenaries robbed them of their mobile phones, laptops, cameras and money. Along with their valuables being stolen, the UNHCR claims that those who did cross the border appeared frightened and did not want to speak with U.N. representatives. Additionally, there has been claims that government forces have been confiscating electronics equipment like cameras so images of the violent clashes between rebels and pro-government forces cannot reach the outside world.

On Friday, the United Nations estimated that nearly 200,000 people have already fled the fighting in Libya. As the violence continues, several nations have committed airplanes and naval vessels to help evacuate stranded migrants and provide humanitarian supplies to the civilians massing at the Libya-Tunisia border. The United States has dispatched two planes to this border area to deliver humanitarian supplies such as water, blankets, and plastic sheets. A Pentagon spokesman claims that after the humanitarian supplies are delivered, the aircraft will be used to shuttle migrants from Tunisia to Egypt.

European nations are also taking an active role in helping to ferry migrants and deliver badly needed supplies. The French government has sent several planes to the Tunisian resort island of Djerba to pick up refugees and transport them to Egypt. Furthermore, the Italian government has sent aircraft and was planning to send a cargo ship full of supplies to the rebel controlled city of Benghazi.

According to United Nations spokesperson, Valorie Amos, food and supply lines are going to become more stressed as the conflict drags on. In particular, she claims that in rebel controlled regions food, medicine, and fuel supplies will begin run out in less than 15 days.

For more information, please see:

AFP — Pro-regime forces man Libyan-Tunisia border: UNHCR – 4 March 2011

Al Masry AlYoum —UNHCR fears civilians may be prevented from fleeing Libya – 4 March 2011

UN News Centre — UN refugee agency ‘very concerned’ civilians being prevented from fleeing Libya – 4 March 2011

Wall Street Journal – Libyan Evacuations Slow, Raising U.N. Fears—5March 2011

Battle Looms As Colombia’s High Court Considers Same-Sex Adoption

By Patrick Vanderpool
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

Colombias Constitutional Court is set to rule on adoption rights for same-sex couples (photo courtesy of colombiareports.com)
Colombia's Constitutional Court is set to rule on adoption rights for same-sex couples (photo courtesy of colombiareports.com)

BOGOTA, Colombia – Last week, Colombia’s Constitutional Court announced that it needs more time to rule on the legality of same-sex couples adopting children. The court was asked to analyze the case of a lesbian couple who want one partner to be recognized as the legal guardian of the other partner’s child. According to Juan Carlos Henao, President of the Constitutional Court, many of the magistrate judges have asked for more time to study this case.

According to media reports, the Colombian ambassador to the Vatican has voiced his opposition to the same-sex adoption issue. Ambassador Cesar Mauricio Velasquez has been quoted as saying that “the criteria of a family is man, woman and child.” Velasquez also said that allowing gays to adopt children would oblige a “change of the concept of family in Colombia.”

The Bishops’ Conference of Colombia has also come out publicly opposing same-sex adoption rights, calling on the Constitutional Court to reject the case. According to the Bishops’ Conference, “the rights of children should be placed above the affective and emotional needs of same-sex couples.”

The Bishops’ Conference claims that the purpose of adoption is to “replace what was lost, namely, the child’s biological mother and father, and the child is given a substitute mother and father so he can have a new home.” Although the bishops are affiliated with the Catholic church, they claim that faith has nothing to do with their stance against same-sex adoption rights. Rather, the bishops claim this is a matter of “natural law” and “anthropology.”

A recent poll carried out in Colombia showed that “82 percent of Colombians do not support the adoption of children by same-sex couples,” a statistic that the bishops have been quick to rely on. Bishop Juan Vicent Cordoba claims that children who are raised in same-sex households will face “great difficulties.” Although he does not provide proof of such difficulties, Cordoba says that these children are more likely to “grow up to become homosexuals, bisexuals or they will have identity problems that will affect their ability to sustain a relationship.”

For more information, please see:

Colombia Reports – Colombian Ambassador to Vatican Opposes Gay Adoption – 3 March 2011

Colombia Reports – Court Needs More Time for Gay Adoption Ruling – 2 March 2011

Catholic News Agency – Colombian Bishops Stress Protection of Adopted Children – 26 February 2011

Several Woman Killed During Attack on Ivory Coast Protest

by Laura Hirahara
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

Women Collect Sandals Left by Protesters Who Fled the Shooting (Photo courtesy of BBC)
Women Collect Sandals Left by Protesters Who Fled the Shooting (Photo courtesy of BBC)

Video of Attack on Ivory Coast Protesters- Warning: Content is graphic, viewer discretion is advised (Video courtesy of CNN)

ABIDJAN, Ivory Coast– In the midst of a protest held today by over 5,000 women in the Ivory Coast capital city of Abidjan in the southern district of Abobo, tanks entered the area and began shooting on the crowd, killing at least six women and injuring dozens more.  As the video from CNN shows, the women were engaging in a peaceful demonstration that included chants and singing and according to observers, they appeared to be unarmed.  The women gathered to protest the ongoing violence that has occurred since President Laurent Gbagbo lost the election in December and has refused to leave office.  Gbagbo has denied responsibility for the attacks and says his security and military forces were not in the area today, despite the fact that one tank was emblazoned with the word ‘Police’.

One of the protesters gave an account to BBC after the shooting, telling the reporter that she saw eight women killed during the attack, including a pregnant woman.  She said as she ran, another woman next to her was shot in the head.  “We have no idea why they shot at us. . . I don’t know how I managed to get away unharmed. . . .Only God knows how I escaped the killing.”  The street quickly cleared as clothes, bags and shoes were left, abandoned by the women trying to escape the gunfire.

The women had gathered to protest Laurent Gbagbo’s presidency, holding signs that called him an assassin and robber of power.  During the protest, many women blew on whistles, joining chants and singing as others danced.  The crowd became silent as the three tanks rolled into view.  With no warning, shots came from the tanks and the women starting fleeing.  Observers rushed to pull the bodies of the slain women from the street as the tanks continued to drive through the area.

Violence has been building in intensity in the capital and the country as a whole since the election results were announced in December of last year.  Gbagbo’s opponent, Alassane Ouattara, won just over 54% of the vote, a result verified by the UN and recognized by the international community.  However, Gbagbo has said that the results, especially from the polls in the north where Ouattara garners the most support, were falsified.  Specific religious and ethnic groups are being targeted due to political party divides in the Ivory Coast.  Gbagbo is the leader of the Christian party, located largely in the southern region and Ouattara is the leader of the Muslim party, located mainly in the north.  Security forces and military troops have been targeting those with Muslim last names as well as those who openly support Ouattara.

As Ouattara attempts to run his cabinet out of a hotel guarded by UN security forces, the African Union in charge of resolving the dispute have declared they are extending their deadline for the second time to March.  The UN has also stated that the escalating violence is making it difficult to continue providing humanitarian aid to people in the Ivory Coast.  Many are fearful that this violence will lead to a renewed civil war as plumes of black smoke from burning tires can be seen each day in the Abidjan skyline.  Even Gbagbo’s supporters are growing weary of the situation.  Said teacher Frank Agny, “I voted Gbagbo, but I don’t understand how a leader of this country can use tanks and break human rights like this. We don’t want war, but only Gbagbo will be to blame if it happens.”

For more information, please see;

BBCIvory Coast: Parts of Abidjan Resemble War Zone– 4 March, 2011

BBC Ivory Coast Eye Witness: Women ‘Slaughtered By Soldiers’– 4 March, 2011

CCNVideo Documents Carnage in Ivory Coast– 4 March, 2011

TIMEIvory Coast Massacre: Army Mows Down Female Protesters– 4 March, 2011

Executions Raise Concern about Human Rights in Iran

By Eric C. Sigmund
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

TEHRAN, Iran – As protests continue throughout the country, the international community has ratcheted up pressure on Iran due to its excessive use of the death penalty to punish crimes.  This comes after ten people were hanged Wednesday for trafficking narcotics.  Statements from Amnesty International and United Nations representatives condemned the executions, noting that international law reserves the use of the death penalty for only the most serious crimes.   Iran’s death penalty policy has received much scrutiny over the years but the government has yet to succumb to demands to reform the policy.   According to Amnesty International, Iran executed 388 people in 2009 alone and is second only to China in the total number of individuals put to death.

Recent unrest and uprisings in the country have led the government to crack down on opposition groups.  UN rights chief Navi Pillay reported that a wave of arrests of protesters and critics has occurred since the uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt over a month ago.  Supporters of the government have called for the execution of opposition leaders and anti-regime demonstrators. 

Some argue that these latest executions are being used as a political tool to frighten and deter the citizenry from protesting.  Drewery Dkye of Amnesty International contends that “[t]he Iranian authorities have used the implementation of the death penalty…to convey a message to opponents of the regime to get in line.”   The government denounced critics of its policy noting that it was necessary “to maintain law and order and is applied only after exhaustive judicial proceedings.”  One report finds that 89 individuals have been executed since the beginning of the year. 

Now Sweden and the United States are seeking to appoint a special investigator to look into human rights violations committed by Iran.  Iranian activists have applauded this move and have expressed their hope that the United Nations Human Rights Council embraces the proposal.  In addition to drug related crimes, the death penalty is considered a proper punishment in Iran for rape, armed theft and adultery.  While the proposal has received wide support, analysts predict that the resolution will fail under opposition from Russia and China who generally disfavor international quarries into other nation’s affairs.

For more information please see:

Reuters – U.S. and Sweden to Push U.N. Rights Body to Act on Iran – Mar. 4, 2011

Payvand Iran News – Iran Executions Under Scrutiny – Mar. 3, 2011

Agence France Presse – Iran Hangs 10 Drug Traffickers – Mar. 2, 2011

Agenzia Giornalistica Italia – Iran: 10 Drug Dealers Hanged – Mar. 2, 2011