Ivorian Soldiers Accused of Crimes Against the Population Face Military Trial

By Ryan Aliman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

YAMOUSSOUKRO, Cote d’Ivoire – The military trial against the Republican Forces of Côte d’Ivoire (FRCI) began last Thursday. 33 soldiers have been charged with committing crimes against the population, including premeditated murder, voluntary and involuntary homicide, and theft.

Republican Forces soldiers patrolling the town of Dabou last August. (Photo courtesy of Human Rights Watch/Getty Images)

All 33 soldiers are accused of abusing civilians during the post-election crisis from November 2010 to May 2011. In the span of six months, at least 3,000 people were reportedly killed. Some of the deaths were allegedly linked to former President Laurent Gbagbo’s refusal to concede despite international recognition of the results that proclaimed his opponent, Alassane Ouattara, the victor.

After the crisis, a national commission of inquiry created by President Ouattara, in cooperation with international and local human rights groups and a United Nations-mandated international commission of inquiry, have documented war crimes and crimes against humanity by both pro-Gbagbo forces and the FRCI during the crisis.

According to the military prosecutor’s office, the first trial on Thursday involved cases related to events that happened December last year in the central town of Vavoua. Reports say that a number of FRCI soldiers who are currently under trial opened fire on protesters, killing at least five people.

However, both international and local human rights groups are not too impressed with the trial.

“The opening of trials against soldiers from the Republican Forces is an important step forward in Côte d’Ivoire’s fight against impunity,” said Matt Wells, West Africa researcher at Human Rights Watch (HRW). “But Ivorian authorities need to also pursue the more sensitive cases involving the Republican Forces for which victims have seen no justice, particularly the grave crimes committed during the post-election crisis.”

Civil society organizations interviewed by HRW are worried that “ongoing impunity for one side of the conflict – the government forces – risks sowing the seeds for future violence.” According to them, this is because of the sensitive nature of the cases of abuse during the post-election period — cases that not only involve large scale atrocities, but also deal with serious political, ethnic, and religious issues.

“Prosecuting people for serious international crimes can be difficult, but the lack of justice can carry high costs,” Wells added. “Chronic impunity has appeared to feed the repeated episodes of violence in Côte d’Ivoire over the last decade, with civilians paying the greatest price.”

HRW urged Ivorian authorities to strengthen support for prosecuting those implicated in the war crimes and crimes against humanity during the post-election crisis. The human rights group also demanded the government to “investigate and prosecute any soldiers involved in the July 2012 attack on the Nahibly displaced persons camp, and in the cruel and inhuman treatment of detainees in August and September.”

 

For further information, please see:

Amnesty International – Annual Report 2012 –  11 April 2013

Human Rights Watch – Côte d’Ivoire: Soldiers on Trial for Abuses – 11 April 2013

istockAnalyst – HRW: Ivorian justice lacks balance – 11 April 2013

Tamil Guardian – Trial of soldiers accused of abuse begins in Côte d’Ivoire – 11 April 2013

Yahoo News – Report: Uneven justice could hurt stability in Ivory Coast – 5 April 2013

Syrian Network for Human Rights: Friday, 12 April 2013

Syrian network for human rights documented 114 victims , Friday  12/4/2013 all across Syria,  including 8 children, 3 ladies , 4 under torture , 41 free army
Damascus and countryside : 39 victims
Homs : 13 victims
Aleppo : 21 victims
Hama : 9 victims
Daraa : 10 victims
Idlib : 5 victims
Hasaka: 7 victims
Lattakia: 3 victims
Raqqa : 7 victims

Syrian Revolution Digest: Friday, 12 April 2013

United in Suffering, Divided in Purpose!

With more and more Kurdish-majority areas about to become fully embroiled in the conflict, the fragmentation and destruction of Syria is getting near total, with only few towns in the south and along the coast still spared, for now. But at least more and more of us are now united in suffering. This is probably the only thing that could unite us at this stage. Will a history of joint suffering be sufficient for the formation of a new sense of identity, even as our purposes clash? It remains to be seen.

 This Friday’s Slogan: “Syria is Stronger than Those Who Divide It”

Death Toll: 119 martyrs, including 6 women, 5 children and 10 martyrs under torture: 47 in Damascus and suburbs; 21 in Aleppo; 16 in Homs; 12 in Daraa; 9 in Raqqa; 9 in Hama; and 5 in Idlib (LCC).

 

News

West claims ‘hard evidence’ of Syria chemical weapons “There are several examples where we are quite sure that shells with chemicals have been used in a very sporadic way,” added the diplomat, speaking on condition of anonymity and without giving details of the evidence. A diplomat from a U.N. Security Council nation also said that “quite convincing” evidence had been sent to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to back accusations against Assad’s forces.

Syrian Rebels Break With Group Over Qaeda Wing Alliance “The relentless pursuit of power should not be one of our goals,” said a statement by the coalition, the Syrian Islamic Liberation Front, referring to the alliance between Syria’s Nusra Front and the Qaeda branch. “This is not the right time to declare states, or to unify a state with another state.” Expressing “surprise and dismay” at the development, the coalition statement said, “We don’t need imported charters or a new understanding of the nation’s religion.” And in a further criticism of Nusra’s loyalty to outsiders, the statement said, “We won’t be doing our population, and our nation, any service if we pledge our allegiance to those who don’t know a thing about our reality.”

Syrian Troops Battle Rebels near Lebanon Border The province of Homs and its capital of the same name were the scenes of some of the heaviest fighting during the first year of Syrian conflict. The violence has escalated there in recent weeks, with Syrian war planes hitting the city daily. On Friday, troops clashed with rebels on the edges of the province along the Lebanese border. The border area is strategically important to both sides fighting in Syria‘s civil war and battles there have been frequent in past weeks, particularly in and around the town of Qusair in Homs province. The area is considered vital to the Syrian regime because of its location along a road linking Damascus with the city of Homs, a strategic supply route for the military. The rebels also have been using the road to transport supplies and weapons from Sunni supporters in Lebanon.

 

Special Reports

Syrian rebel courts restore order to life in Aleppo Marriages, inheritances, commercial contracts … they are now all passing through courts manned by lawyers and judges who have abandoned the regime of President Bashar Assad and joined the rebellion against it. There are some 20 rebel brigades operating in Aleppo, and the court is run by the most important among them: two jihadi groups – the Al-Qaeda-linked Nusra Front and the Salafist Ahrar al-Sham – and Liwa al-Tawhid, which is linked to the broad-based opposition National Coalition. And while the commanders of these groups are primarily concerned with waging war against Assad’s troops, their presence is also felt behind the lines.

Syria: Proxy war heats up as endgame inches closer Over the past few months the Americans – without being obliged to announce any policy changes involving military commitments – have apparently tipped the wink to their regional allies, mainly Qatar, Turkey and Saudi Arabia, to step up the quantity and quality of arms supplies to the rebels. At the same time, the Americans are reported to be involved in helping train supposedly moderate Free Syrian Army (FSA) elements in Jordan and sending them across the border into southern Syria, where the rebels, enjoying better anti-air and anti-armour weapons than before, have begun to make gains that are being compared to their advances in the far north. With western support being made contingent on loyalty to the FSA and the opposition National Coalition, this has clearly put pressure on the Nusra Front and other jihadi groups.

The Revolution is Being Televised The story of six Syrian activists who risk their lives to capture the horrific daily realities of the conflict.

My new paper, prepared for a briefing in Washington, D.C. that took place on January 15, 2013, is now out and is titled “Syria 2013: Rise of the Warlords.” It should be read in conjunction with my previous briefing “The Shredded Tapestry,” and my recent essay “The Creation of an Unbridgeable Divide.

 

Video Highlights

Rebels in the neighborhood of Sheikh Maqsoud, Aleppo city, take a little dance break in between clashes, literally http://youtu.be/G27tjzVLynM

In the town of Talbisseh, Homs Province, rebels storm the little village of Um Sharshouh, a loyualsit strongholds http://youtu.be/fwwD7lHOXSI the storing comes after days of siege and pounding by rebel forceshttp://youtu.be/G7Om3RAIdQQ

As tensions in the town of Qamishly mount, after its designation as an official governorate by the Assad regime, rebels head there to liberate ithttp://youtu.be/TauEtu-bOxU It is not yet clear how Kurdish members of the local defense committees (YPGs) will react to this. But the YPGs and Islamist rebels have been working together in Aleppo City for the last couple of weeks. As such, Kurdish and Islamist rebels could be working together here, at least for now. The initial target for the rebels is the military base at Tourtob, and the Qamishly Airport. Indeed, the pounding of the airport with home-made rockets began http://youtu.be/AmOfOnq_9yc , http://youtu.be/RLe8S9ywiyM Loyalist troops hit back and the outskirts of the city of Qamishly get hithttp://youtu.be/SfSULmKSLRc Helicopters begin surveying the scenehttp://youtu.be/dzzD9TsE-A4

Scenes from the clashes in Jobar Neighborhood, Damascus Cityhttp://youtu.be/3GXcZTJHM_w , http://youtu.be/YjhGv1q6FZQ The nearbyZablatani neighborhood gets pounded http://youtu.be/2nyhbZs3jgUMeanwhile, fighter jets keep pounding rebel strongholds in the southern parts of the city http://youtu.be/O_K5TmHQdis

An ambush by Islamist rebels in Damascus Suburbs against loyalist militiamenhttp://youtu.be/E8G0iA51wC4

Mali Refugees Endure Deplorable Conditions at UN Camp in Mauritania

By Hannah Stewart
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

NOUAKCHOTT, Mauritania — Conflict in Mali has driven nearly 70,000 refugees to Mbera camp in the Mauritanian desert.  There the appalling living conditions and inadequate assistance are leading to severe malnutrition and deaths from preventable diseases, reports the international humanitarian organization, Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (“MSF”).

Houmou Ag Amamili lived in the Mbera camp for months without receiving a tent and had not received one as of March 11, 2013. (Photograph Courtesy of MSF and Nyani Quarmyne)

Since the start of the conflict in Mali in January 2012, hundreds of thousands of people have been internally displaced or have fled to neighboring countries.  The United Nations reported that more than 270,000 people have been displaced within Mali, and more than 170,000 refugees have fled to Burkina Faso, Mauritania and Niger.

Mauritania hosts the highest number of refugees, with some 68,000 people registered by the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (“UNHCR”) in camps in Mauritania.  In January conditions in the camp worsened following an influx of 15,000 refugees, an event following the joint military intervention by French and Malian forces in Mali.

The number of consultations in MSF’s clinics in the Mbera camp increased from 1,500 to 2,500 per week.  Moreover, the number of children admitted per week for severe malnutrition more than doubled, from 42 to 106, despite the fact very few children were malnourished when they arrived at the camp.

MSF recently published a report entitled “Stranded in the Desert,” which was based on testimony from more than 100 residents of the Mbera camp.  The report calls for urgent action by aid organizations to meet the refugees’ basic needs and rectify the deplorable living conditions.

For example, the report notes that in January 2013 there was only one latrine for every 3,000 refugees, and people were receiving just 11 liters of water per day, instead of a required 20 liters. Many people have been living under makeshift shelters made of scraps of cloth and sticks.

The UN considers the allegations to be serious, but questioned some of the report’s findings.  The UNHCR stated that some of the facts “seem to be out of date and do not reflect current realities.”  For example, the UNHCR clarified that 2,500 latrines exist in the camp, approximately one for every 30 refugees.

The refugee crisis seems unlikely to subside in the near future, given the nature of the conflict in Mali.  Henry Gray, emergency coordinator for MSF said, “Most of the refugees are from the Tuareg and Arab communities.  They fled preemptively, often for fear of violence due to their presumed links with Islamist or separatist groups.  Their home in northern Mali is still in the grip of fear and mistrust.”

For more information, please see:

BBC – Mali Refugees Endure ‘Appalling’ Mauritania Camp – 12 April 2013

CNN – Report: Mali Refugees Endure ‘Appalling’ Conditions at Mauritania Camp– 12 April 2013

Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières – Hunger Strikes Malian Refugees Stranded in Mauritanian Desert – 12 April 2013

Voices of America – Conditions Getting Worse for Mali Refugees – 12 April 2013

Syrian Revolution Digest: Thursday, 11 April 2013

Mysterious Politics!

By finally confirming the validity of the leaked video showing the killing of one of Syria’s top cleric, Syrian TV is also confirming the unreliability of regime reports on happenings all over the country. Did we really need that confirmation? No. Will it make any difference in how international media deal with official reports? Probably not. But we now have a new mystery to add to the growing list. Mysteries are multiplying as quickly as Jihadis and warlords in Syria. But it’s not a mystery how we got here (western dithering), and it’s not a mystery how we can get out: taking Assad’s toys (jets and scuds) away, even if you have to pry them out from his cold dead hands. Then and only then can politics become possible.

Death Toll: 149 martyrs including 17 women, 18 children and 3 under torture: 41 in Homs, mostly in the Massacres of Tal Shor and Qusseir; 36 in Aleppo, mostly in Sukkari; 33 in Damascus and suburbs; 15 in Idlib; 10 in Hama; 7 in Daraa; 4 in Lattakia; and 3 in Deir Ezzor (LCC).

 

News

G8 ministers fail to agree on Syria; condemn North Korea

Syrian Troops Launch Counterattack on South

Syria calls on UN to recognise rebels’ al-Qaeda links: Al-Nusra has been dubbed a terrorist organisation by the US

Syria TV confirms video of cleric’s killing is real In an unprecedented act, the broadcaster said it “apologised” for denying the authenticity of a video distributed online this week, showing the moment of an explosion in a Damascus mosque that killed Syria’s best-known Sunni cleric.

Rebel Victory in Syria Might Not Stop Conflict, U.S. Officials SayThe top American intelligence official, James R. Clapper Jr., said that even if Mr. Assad’s government fell, sectarian fighting would most likely engulf the country for a year or more. The American ambassador to Syria, Robert S. Ford, warned that without a negotiated political transition, supporters of the Assad government, “fearing death, would fight to the death.”

Ranking Democrat, Republican press Obama administration on Syria Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), the committee’s chairman, prodded the White House during a hearing to begin providing arms to rebels seeking to topple Syrian President Bashar Assad, a step the administration has so far refused to take because it fears the weapons could someday be used against the United States or its allies. “Unless we change the dynamic and put our finger on the scales to change the tipping point, Assad will continue to believe he can hold on to power,” Menendez said. Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), the ranking minority member, complained that “we’ve been in reaction mode, and the administration’s response that we’ve seen is ad hoc.” Corker asked three administration officials who testified to shed more light on the administration’s intentions in Syria. Yet Corker stopped short of calling for a deeper U.S. military commitment, saying, “We really have no good options available to us in Syria.”

U.S. updates military options for Syria The first public discussion of the updated options could come soon as Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel and Gen. Martin Dempsey, the Joint Chiefs chairman, are scheduled to testify before the Senate Armed Services Committee next week. The military official emphasized the options are for planning and there is no indication President Barack Obama is about to order any military action. A senior administration official confirmed that the national security staff of the White House has been briefed on the updated planning, but emphasized that it does not differ from what already has been looked at by the administration. “We’ve been saying for quite some time now, we are constantly reviewing every possible option that could help end the violence and accelerate a political transition,” the administration official told CNN. Officials have declined to speak on the record because of the sensitivity of the situation.

Main rebel groups in Syria’s Aleppo The most important rebel groups in the city are the jihadist Al-Nusra Front and Ahrar al-Sham, as well as Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated Liwa al-Tawhid, which includes army deserters and anti-regime civilians.

Rights group accuses Syrian military of targeting civilians “These illegal airstrikes killed and injured many civilians and sowed a path of destruction, fear and displacement.” Human Rights Watch said bakeries and hospitals have been targeted, in violation of the laws of war.

Military in Syria Is Accused of Massacre The reported massacre, which could not be independently verified, took place in the town of Sanamayn, about halfway between Damascus and the southern city of Dara’a. The town sits astride a vital highway that rebel forces have been fighting to control in recent weeks. Brigades affiliated with the Free Syrian Army had seized a number of towns south of Sanamayn, and this month took control of a military base near Dara’a, where the uprising against President Bashar al-Assad began more than two years ago.

 

Special Reports

Dennis Ross, Senate Committee on Foreign Relations: U.S. Policy Toward Syria It is rare that idealists and realists find common ground and agree on threats. Ironically, Syria is a place where the idealists and realists should come together. There is a moral imperative to try to find a way to affect what is happening on the ground, but there is also a strong national security imperative at least to contain the conflict in Syria, ensure that its CW do not disappear, and prevent the neighborhood from being destabilized.

Northern Syria’s Kurds struggle to deal with influx Since the beginning of Syria’s uprising, the Kurds, who make up about 15 percent of the population, have tried to stay out of the fighting, stopping both rebel and regime forces from entering their neighborhoods. Last summer, Assad’s troops pulled out of majority-Kurdish areas and the Committees for the Protection of the Kurdish People (YPG), the armed wing of the Democratic Union Party (PYD), took over. The PYD is considered as the Syrian branch of Turkey’s PKK… In Sheikh Maqsoud, rebels and Kurdish groups have joined together to fight forces loyal to Bashar Assad.

My new paper, prepared for a briefing in Washington, D.C. that took place on January 15, 2013, is now out and is titled “Syria 2013: Rise of the Warlords.” It should be read in conjunction with my previous briefing “The Shredded Tapestry,” and my recent essay “The Creation of an Unbridgeable Divide.

 

Video Highlights

Clashes between rebels and pro-Assad militias intensify in Jobar Neighborhood in Damascus City http://youtu.be/nIp2HgFFCsc ,http://youtu.be/H-oeADBmkBI Tanks take part http://youtu.be/-ABeA9AJFl0The pounding of southern neighborhoods continueshttp://youtu.be/iikZawUmTs0 Jets take part in the poundinghttp://youtu.be/7mMh3cg_HPE , http://youtu.be/3f0s1AEJF7o ,http://youtu.be/qxb-HrOoSdI The pounding leaves many building on fire inYarmouk Camp http://youtu.be/Sc2z3wlkRr4

Suburbs of Eastern Ghoutah were also targeted: http://youtu.be/2HnAZ-j_Teg , http://youtu.be/ohuP0DaRw-A , http://youtu.be/Yo1ukkCJCdw ,http://youtu.be/wPfKJw8Bhr0

To the West, the town of Moadamiya continues to be poundedhttp://youtu.be/rCt_tY6x10Q , http://youtu.be/D2eh_AXAs-Y

Leaked video shows pro-Assad militias torturing a detainee to death by stabbing him with dull knives then shooting. The people who uploaded the video claim that one of the militiamen we see near the end was killed later by rebelshttp://youtu.be/YWuRcbYvkI4 Another leaked video shows pro-Assad troops preparing a missile for launch http://youtu.be/Od4pmGApCgQ A third leaked video shows pro-Assad militias burning the bodies of dead detaineeshttp://youtu.be/G08QlXRFszk

The pounding of rebel strongholds in Homs City continues: Wa’erhttp://youtu.be/DiuXjP6mG38

The pounding of the town of Rastan, Homs, continueshttp://youtu.be/Gp0rL45ZyfY , http://youtu.be/_p6d3x6Ak3o

The town of Talbisseh, Homs, is targeted by MiGshttp://youtu.be/LlXcRlDJPmY

The pounding of the town of Morek, Hama leaves three children deadhttp://youtu.be/4nby5LRVpOU