Human Rights Watch Report Alleges Rising Religious Intolerance in Indonesia

By Irving Feng
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

JAKARTA, Indonesia – Human Rights Watch (HRW), a New York-based human rights watch dog, recently released a report highlighting Indonesia’s rising religious intolerance and failure to protect religious minorities.

Police try to disperse a crowd of religious minorities. (Photo Courtesy of the BBC)

The one hundred and seven page report was compiled using research conducted from August 2011 to December 2012.  It includes over 100 interviews of local Indonesians, 71 of which were victims to crimes of religious intolerance.

The report also included information from the nonprofit Setara Institute, based in Indonesia’s capital of Jakarta, which found that 264 attacks of religious minorities occurred in 2012, 244 attacks were recorded in 2011, and 216 attacks were recorded in 2010.  These numbers show a steady increase in the amount of attacks motivated by religion against minorities in Indonesia over the course of the previous three years.

Indonesia is the most populous Muslim-majority nation in the world.  Muslims, of the Sunni variety, dominate the nation’s population, numbering around 210 million.  This massive majority has perhaps contributed to the growing religious intolerance.

Brutal attacks and constant harassment has been commonplace in Indonesia against the minority populations of Christians, Shia Muslims, and Ahmadiyah.  In addition to the attacks and harassment, the government’s actions, and lack of action, has exacerbated the situation.

Discriminatory regulations passed by the central government have had a significant effect on the religious minorities.  Local governments have allegedly refused to grant religious minorities permits to build new places of worship.  A Supreme Court decision which granted religious minorities the ability to build new places of worship has also been largely disregarded by many local authorities.

Local law enforcement has failed to curb the rising number of violent attacks being perpetrated against the religious minorities in the country.  Prosecutors have also failed to properly prosecute the few that have been brought in on charges of violence and have chosen to apply weak punishments for their crimes.

Secretary General of Indonesia’s Religious Affairs Ministry, Bahrul Hayat, released a statement, citing a government survey which was compiled at the end of last year, alleging religious harmony within the country is incredibly strong.   Bahrul Hayat urges the international community to disregard the few violations that may have occurred against religious minorities in the country.

The Secretary General believes that the few violations he noted should not be seen as the norm, but as the exception to the rule.  Many of the causes of conflicts within the country that may have been blamed on religious intolerance are actually socially, politically, culturally, or economically motivated.

HRW, however, still calls for Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to adopt a “zero tolerance” policy with regards to religious intolerance, discrimination, and the rising violence perpetrated against the religious minorities in the country.

For further information, please seeL

India Talkies – Indonesia urged to protect religious minorities from growing violence – 1 March 2013

BBC – Indonesia urged to tackle religious intolerance – 28 February 2013

Breitbart – Report: Religious violence rising in Indonesia – 28 February 2013

Business Mirror – Religious violence rising in Indonesia – 28 February 2013

Human Rights Watch – In Religion’s Name – 28 February 2013

UNICEF Report Reveals ‘Systematic’ Abuse of Palestinian Children by Israeli Prisons

By Ali Al-Bassam
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

JERUSALEM, Israel — The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) published a 22-page report last Wednesday claiming that the ill-treatment of Palestinian children in Israeli detention centers “appears to be widespread and systematic.”

 

A report by UNICEF states that Palestinian children detained in Israeli prisons are subjected to “cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment or punishment.” (Photo Courtesy of Al Arabiya)

In its report, entitled “Children in Israeli Military Detention,” UNICEF estimates that about 700 children within the West Bank aged between twelve and seventeen were arrested by Israeli forces each year.  UNICEF says that this is a rate equivalent to “an average of two children each day.”  Figures provided for the month of January reveal that 233 children are currently in custody, and 31 of those children are below the age of sixteen.  However, a spokeswoman for Israel’s Prison Service said that currently, 307 Palestinian minors are in Israeli custody, 108 of them are serving a prison sentence.  The spokeswoman said that most of those children are between sixteen and eighteen, while the rest are under sixteen.

The report also stated that Israel is the only country in the world where children are systematically tried in military courts, deeming the practices as “cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment or punishment.”   “Israel is the only place in the world where automatically, a child when he is under arrest, is put before a military tribunal,” said Jean-Nicholas Beuze, UNICEF’s regional advisor on child protection. “It does exist in other countries (but only) as an exception.”

The report states that the ill-treatment often begins with an arrest of the child, usually occurring in the middle of the night, then it continues through the prosecution and sentencing periods.  The report provides examples of abuse, such as “the practice of blindfolding children and tying their hands with plastic ties, physical and verbal abuse during transfer to an interrogation site, including the use of painful restraints.”  Children were rarely informed of their rights during questioning.

During questioning, the report states that minors are subjected to “physical violence and threats, are coerced into confessions, and do not have immediate access to a lawyer or family during questioning.”  UNICEF also pointed out that some cases existed where children suffered through prolonged exposure to the elements, and were not provided with an adequate amount of food, water, and did not had access to a toilet.

During the sentencing phase, children arrive to court shackled, are denied bail and imposition of custodial sentences, and are transferred outside of the occupied Palestinian territory to serve their sentences inside Israel.

UNICEF based its findings on more than 400 cases documented since 2009, legal papers and reports composed by both governmental and non-governmental groups, and through interviews with Palestinian minors, and Israeli and Palestinian officials and lawyers.

Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor said that ministry officials along with the Israeli military cooperated with UNICEF.   Palmor said that Israel wants to improve its treatment of Palestinian minors held in custody. “Israel will study the conclusions and will work to implement them through ongoing cooperation with UNICEF, whose work we value and respect,” he said.

For further information, please see:

Al Arabiya — Israeli Ill-Treatment of Palestinian Minors ‘Widespread, Systematic:’ UNICEF — 6 March 2013

Al Jazeera — Israel Accused of Abusing Detained Children — 6 March 2013

The Daily Star — Israel Ill-Treatment of Palestinian Minors ‘Systematic’: UN — 6 March 2013

The Jewish Press — UNICEF: Israel Treatment of Arab Minors in Custody Cruel and Inhuman — 6 March 2013

SNHR: Syrian Government Release One Correspondent in Front of the Media and on the Other Hand Kill 168, Four Tortured to Death

Press Release
Syrian Network for Human Rights

Violations Against Media Professionals:

Since the outbreak of Syrian revolution, Syrian government not just prevented all media –except pro-Alassad regime media outlets – to work freely and transmit news and the facts happening on the ground, but they also expelled, arrested tens of them , and restrict others in their work .

Syrian government’s crackdown towards media is one of the worst in the world comparing with other countries, restricting freedom of press and media in this way is a clear violation of all norms and international conventions in this regard .

This cause additional responsibility on Syrian revolutionaries, hundreds of citizens takes this task upon themselves to become citizen journalist exposing their lives to the danger of detention and death

SNHR documented since the outbreak of the Syrian Revolution up till now killing 168 media professionals and citizen journalists including 3 women , which is a clear indication of women participation in Media work in Syrian Revolution

The following link contains all the names of the killed media professionals and their death date as well as their photos and videos.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B9Bj18tlYYKBLXF4QzVXSURWZVU/edit?usp=sharing

Homs topped the list of Media victims with 73, followed by Damascus countryside with 21, Aleppo 16, Daraa 12, Damascus 9 , and the rest all around the other Syrian governorates

For the Non Syrian Media victims they were 12 all around the world

SNHR refuse to document pro-Alassad regime or pro-oppositions media outlet –where they don’t deserve the media capacity any more, cause by their actions they turned into intelligence agents depicting the faces of activists to arrest them – and forced residents by arms to admit that Alassad troops didn’t kill or shell , but on the contrary they were sophisticated in dealing and in humanity

The same for armed rebel , Media capacity falls from any correspondent carry weapon and turned into a solider

 

Detainees and torture of correspondents:

There are at least 3500 media activists and citizen journalists work as photographer, or have an administrative role on social networks, and reporters to transmit news and information to agencies and stations all around the world

According to the statements of eyewitnesses and survivors from Alassad prisons that the media activists of revolutions suffering from distinct type of torture more worse than the other detainee , 4 media activists killed under torture and 600 forcibly disappeared  .

The following you can see the reporters names how has been tortured to kill in prisons then the security branches hand over the bodies to their families and the signs of tortures appears on :

1-      Abdullah Hasan Kakeh – Aleppo – male – killed under torture in Military Intelligence branch  in 17-11-2012

2-      Baraa Yousef Alboshi – Sabonia / Hama – male – dissident             sergeant – was speaking media and journalist on the ground in Damascus countryside – killed in the random shelling on Altal in 11-8-2012 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXx7EehIS3c&feature=youtu.be             https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=472183366134460&set=a.376981942321270.94377.362879720398159&type=1&theater

3-      Mahmod Sudki Sakhita – Ariha / Idlib – male – media activist – Alassad army arrested him on a checkpoint and killed under torture in 22-7-2012

4-      Rami Suliman Ekbal – Dael / Daraa – male – married and have a girl child – killed under torture by Alassad troops in 21-6-2012

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=414616385255608&set=a.170186573031925.48606.165780076805908&type=1&theater

5-       Hasan Mohamad Azhari – Damascus – male – killed under torture in prison in 17-5-2012

6-      Juan Mohamad Katana – Derbasia / Hasaka – male – photographer , his body found and the sign of torture appears on it after three hours of his abduction from his house in Derbasia by masked people

7-      Farzat Yahia Aljarban – Kosayr / Homs – male – killed under torture in 20-11-2011– after he was arrested in 19-11-2011 , his body was dumped http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEbCNd7Gv0A&feature=youtu.be

 

Some of the Prominent Martyrs of Media Professionals:

Basil Shehadeh
A well known movie director, he was studying at Syracuse University in the United States, he returned to Syria in order to participate in the peaceful movement against the government. He was arrested when he was in one of the demonstrations in Damascus by the Intelligence forces in Damascus, and then released. He used his camera to document the attacks of the Syrian army on neighborhoods of the city of Homs. He was killed on 29/5/2012 in Safsafa neighborhood in the city of Homs after being bombarded by the Syrian government’s army.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/basel.jpg

Rami Al-Sayed
A revolutionary prominent media professional in Homs, where he was filming the live broadcast of the demonstrations, he was documenting the victims of the regime forces bombing; those killed and wounded along with abuses against civilians. He was martyred in besieged Baba Amr after heavy shelling by the Syrian government forces on 21/2/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/rami.jpg

Mohammed Al-Khal (Abu Bilal al-Dairi)
A media activist volunteered to document the events of the revolution in his hometown Deir Ezzor since the breakout of the revolution. He worked on monitoring most military checkpoints on the axes of the city through filming them from a long distance. He was also able to document much of the “theft and looting” by the soldiers of the regime during raids. He martyred after missile bombardment by the Syrian government forces on 25/11/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/khal.jpg

Omar Abdul Razak Altawf (Omar Homsi)
A prominent media activist in the Syrian revolution, he is from the city of Talbisa in Homs, he contributed effectively in the dissemination of news about the Syrian Revolution on the news agencies around the world. He also filmed a large number of documentaries by his personal camera. He martyred in a field execution process with two of his brothers and a number of activists when he was returning from Turkey to Talbisa at Aicardaa military checkpoint on 20/10/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/omar1.jpg
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/omar2.jpg

Tamer Al-Awaam
A film director and a political activist from Al-Suwayda. He made many documentations about the Syrian Revolution activities, the most prominent was “Memories at the Checkpoint” (Zekrayat ala Al-Hagez). He was died by shrapnel of a random bomb shell as a result of shelling Al-Ezaa district in Aleppo city by the Syria Army Forces in 9/9/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/tamer.jpg

Mary Koven
An American journalist, works for the British Sunday Times Newspaper. She was killed in 22/02/2012 as a result of targeting the Media Center for Baba Amr district by the Syrian government forces. Thus, Mary was killed along with her French photographer colleague Remi Ochlik.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/mari.jpg

Remi Ochlik
A French photographer. He worked in all the Arab Spring countries in 2011. He witnessed the Tunisian and the Egyptian Revolutions, then the war in Libya. His staling photos that is full of humanity were published in Paris Match and Time Magazines and in The Wall Street Journal. He was awarded the first prize for the young photographers in the “Visa Pour L’Image” photojournalism festival. He was killed along with his the journalist Mary Koven in Homs, Baba Amr district in 22/2/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/rimi.jpg

Mika Yamamoto
A Japanese journalist. A pioneer in the field of video journalism and she was awarded many prizes. She was working for the Independent Media Group (Japan Press). She was killed as a result of shelling Aleppo city by the Syrian Army Forces while fulfilling her media responsibility in covering the current events there in 21/08/2012.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/mika.jpg

 

Media Professionals in Prison:

Mazen Darwish
A journalist, a member in the International Federation of Journalists, the founder and the head of “The Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression”. He was interned in 16/2/2012 after breaking into the center by the Air Force Intelligence Forces. Since he was interned, he was not accused of any crime, and he is still interned and suffering from several health problems.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/mazen.jpg

Activist, Ali Othman:
One of the most famous media activists in Homs. He participated in documenting tens of crimes and violations against the Syrian citizens. One of his most famous and important works was the first video for shelling when he commented: “Baba Amr is being shelled, where are you Arabs?”

He was interned in 28/3/2012 by military security detachment in Al-Bab city in Aleppo. He was then sent to the military security branch to end his journey in Palestine branch after only days from the being interned, and he is still interned.
http://syrianhr.org/Upload/savefiles/ali.png

 

Condemnation and Blame:

SNHR as human rights organization condemn blatantly targeting the journalist and attacks against them which is classifies as crimes against humanity and  holds Bashar Alassad as the Syrian president and the commander of the Army forces , the hole responsibility of all acts of murders , torture and massacres that have occurred in Syria.

Assad is primarily responsible for ordering these acts, and we consider all officials of the Syrian government , which leads the security and  army operations as a direct partner of this crimes , and  the same for the Iranian government and Hezbullah participate actively killings and holds them legal judiciary and responsibility , as well as all financiers and supporters of the system and who is committing massacres an almost unstopped daily basis, systematic in day or night, and we hold them all reactions and consequences, and that may be issued from the Syrian people, especially relatives of the martyrs and their families .

We demand the Security Council and the United Nations and Member States to work at a maximum speed to take all safe to protect civilians in Syria, and they are in droop for supporting the Syrian people and the protection of civilians bear with the Syrian regime a great deal of responsibility where they have to comply with the responsibility of ethical, legal and accelerate steps toward reference all those involved in the those massacres to the international Criminal Court.

Also appeals all the media around the world to standby their colleague in Syria who are risking their lives to give the voice of truth , even to transmit  a small part from the Syrian people suffering , thus all the media organization around the world have to launch an extensive campaign to press the Syrian government and demand them to  allow all media around the world unconditionally to carry out their mission and media role.

الشبكة السورية لحقوق الإنسان 

Syrian Network for Human Rights 

https://www.facebook.com/syrianhr

Syrian Revolution Digest: Wednesday, 6 March 2013

The Real Spillover Effect!

What’s the point of the international order that the United States in particular has played a crucial role in establishing, as flawed as it is, if conflicts like the one raging in Syria are neglected? What’s the point of working hard to come up with the legal notion of “Responsibility to Protect” if it is to be ignored when the challenge ahead is actually serious? Even if the dissolution of Syria followed by a regional meltdown had little impact on U.S. strategic interests, and that’s a rather big IF, the real spillover effect that we all should fear is the breakdown of the existing international order with no alternative in sight but chaos. It might take the world years before we get to this point, but we will get there eventually and the starting point will be the way the conflict in Syria was ignored and mismanaged. Why Syria and not Congo? The ongoing real time documentation of major developments over the last two years, the inherent racism in the current order which still ascribes more psychological and political relevance to developments closer to the West, and the timing of this development in Syria which coincides with a series of economic, social and political upheavals in different parts of the world, will combined in due course of time to give developments in Syria that weight. This has the potential of becoming the hair that broke the camel’s back.

Today’s Death Toll: 141 martyrs, including 12 children, 11 women and 2 martyrs under torture. 34 martyrs reported in Damascus and Suburbs, 27 in Homs, 30 in Idlib, 18 in Raqqa, 16 in Aleppo, 6 in Deir Ezzor, 4 in Lattakia, 3 in Hama and 3 in Daraa (LCCs).

Points of Random Shelling: 440 points: Shelling with Warplanes was reported in 33 points, with the fiercest shelling taking place in Raqqa, shelling with SCUD missiles was documented in 3 points; cluster bombs in 5 points; where vacuum bombs in 1 point in Maaret Noaman, and another point in Dar Abeera in Homs; whereas, shelling with Mortars was reported in 130 points, with artillery in 155 and with rocket launchers in 113 points (LCCs).

Clashes: 142. Successful operations include “liberating” both the political and the military security headquarters in Raqqa City, shooting downa MiG in the town of Heesh, Idlib, and shelling the military airports of Minnigh and Nairab in Aleppo with local made rockets. In Homs, FSA rebels managed to destroy a loyalist checkpoint in Zablatanim, and in Damascus City, they repelled an attack on Jobar Neighborhood (LCCs).

 

News

Syria’s refugee tide passes one-million mark Around half the refugees are children, most of them aged under 11, and the numbers leaving are mounting every week, the United Nations refugee agency said in statement. “With a million people in flight, millions more displaced internally, and thousands of people continuing to cross the border every day, Syria is spiraling towards full-scale disaster,” U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres said in a statement.

Syria crisis: Teenage mother ‘becomes millionth refugee’ (Video) A teenager has become the one millionth refugee of the crisis in Syria, according to the UN. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees has warned the country is “spiralling towards full-scale disaster”. Half of the refugees so far are children, the UN said, most of them under 11 and often traumatised by their experiences. Bushra, 19, registered as a refugee in Lebanon, along with her young children, as the BBC’s Nik Gowing reports.

U.N.: 20 peacekeepers detained in Syria The U.N. Security Council demanded their immediate and unconditional release. The capture of the peacekeepers marked a new escalation in the spillover of Syria’s civil war, now entering its third year. It followed the Feb. 25 announcement that a member of the peacekeeping force, known as UNDOF, was unaccounted for. The U.N. said the peacekeeping member, who has not been identified, is still missing. Russia’s U.N. Ambassador Vitaly Churkin, the current Security Council president, said talks are under way between U.N. officials from the peacekeeping force, known as UNDOF, and the captors.

Arab League discusses giving Syria’s seat to opposition
… ministers meeting in Cairo were divided on whether to let the opponents of President Bashar al-Assad take over Syria’s seat, previously held by the Damascus government. “The discussions on giving the Syrian seat to the opposition are taking place now and there are countries for it and others against it,” one diplomat said on the condition of anonymity.

Syria world’s top destination for jihadists, says William Hague, as aid promised Syria has become the “top destination for jihadists” across the world, William Hague said on Wednesday, announcing that Britain will give the opposition “non-lethal” military equipment for the first time.

Syria War: Rebels Joined By Chechnya Islamic Militants In ‘Jihad’ Against Assad (VIDEO) “This is the first time that a mass number of Chechens have taken part in military actions abroad,” said analyst Mairbek Vatchagayev, based in Paris, adding that claims were made that Chechens had fought with the Taliban in Afghanistan or in Iraq, but no definitive proof had been given.

Syria’s Assad says Chavez death is “personal loss” Chavez, an ally and regular guest of Assad’s, shipped diesel fuel to Syria last year to help it overcome shortages caused by Western sanctions, and described the Syrian conflict as an international plot backed by Western powers. Assad described Chavez’s death as “a great loss to me personally and to the people of Syria”.

Syria Civil War Threatens Cradle of World Cultures Tanks, looters prey on treasures of past civilizations of Macedonia, Rome and the Byzantine Empire and roots of Islam, Christianity and Judaism

 

Special Reports

Aleppo at War: Everyday Life in the Death Zone
In Aleppo, every footstep is a crunch. The streets are strewn with rubble and broken glass from destroyed buildings and shattered windows. It’s a sound that distinguishes a walk around this war-torn Syrian town from any other city in the world.

Syria’s House of Cards
After two years, 1 million refugees, and more than 70,000 dead, some Syrians — and one American president — are still looking to protect their own interests rather than save a country.

Syria’s war: Keeping up appearances
The regime continues to pay salaries to Syria’s civil servants, wherever they may be, even though government offices in swathes of the country are empty. Earlier this month the north-eastern provincial city of Raqqa fell to Mr Assad’s enemies—the first city to do so. Yet the show must go on. In Damascus the electricity board still issues citizens with bills. The postal service still delivers mail no more erratically than before. Even the Meteorological Office is on hand to publish forecasts of rain. For Syrians who enjoy star-gazing, the Astronomical Society has notified them to look out for a comet between March 12th and 14th.

Change the Focus of the Syria Debate
One approach would be for western governments to initiate assistance programs through the multilateral agencies (such as the UN, Islamic Development Bank and World Bank Group) which were designed for this purpose, but equally importantly, have the resources to put personnel on the ground and devote the funds necessary to have a meaningful impact. Call it ‘pre-emptive development’. Another idea is to create lending and guarantee schemes specifically earmarked for high risk post-conflict reconstruction. This has of course been done in the past, but usually too long after a conflict has ended, and often implemented too late to be maximally effective to those most in need. If we want post-conflict Syria to end up better prepared to survive the chaos and despair engulfing Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and elsewhere in the region, we must do a much better job of marshalling and deploying the civilian, political and economic resources essential to the establishment of political stability. If this were to occur, perhaps Syria could serve as a turning point in ‘pre-emptive’ post-conflict reconstruction and development, rather than a continuation of the flawed approach that has been replicated numerous times over past decades, with predictable results.

My new paper, prepared for a briefing in Washington, D.C. that took place on January 15, 2013, is now out and is titled “Syria 2013: Rise of the Warlords.” It should be read in conjunction with my previous briefing “The Shredded Tapestry,” and my recent essay “The Creation of an Unbridgeable Divide.

Quickly Noted
* “Pre-emptive development” is an interesting concept indeed, and one that the United States and European Union seems to be dabbling with at this stage in connection to developments in Syria, but the problem here is that the impact of such preemption will remain negligible so long as scuds and bombs keep raining down on people in liberated areas. Bear in mind what’s happening to Raqqah City at this stage: over 30 aerial raids have been undertaken and two scuds hit neighboring communities in the 24 hours following its liberation. What possible developmental activity can take place in these conditions? We don’t just anything to be done, we need the right thing to be done. If there no will to do that, than doing nothing might be preferable.

 

Video Highlights

A missile attack on Jobar Neighborhood, Damascus City http://youtu.be/XcjVJ-U_E7k The neighborhood of Tadamon was also pounded http://youtu.be/uujd1cr-UgY

In the town of Daraya, Damascus Suburbs, a local factory burns to the ground on account of the constant shelling by pro-regime militias http://youtu.be/Os0eH0r6sVQ

A Scud launched from the Qalamoun region in Damascus Suburbs takes course towards Raqqa Province passing over the town of Yabroud http://youtu.be/nigMFRm6OZI

The pounding of the town of Rabeeah in North Latakia by pro-regime militias http://youtu.be/ApWf7cs8P30

Rebels in Aleppo keep up their pounding of the Kuweiris Military Airport using home-made rockets http://youtu.be/oCznimD_ReA , http://youtu.be/QCTHLx0zneg , http://youtu.be/fowb2w6V0mQ , http://youtu.be/WqXti-T4Qdc

Clashes in Daraa continue http://youtu.be/4sFkjg48hCg , http://youtu.be/YMJP-fTyErA , http://youtu.be/Mfn3SK2EFhQ

Raqqa City: Over 30 air raids in less than 24 hours following the city’s liberation took their toll http://youtu.be/iCNT4SF4e3c , http://youtu.be/xvg8S8SPyw0 , http://youtu.be/oIuoCjqxtXk , http://youtu.be/raXjbd8a0M

Turkmen protest the elections in Gaziantep for a council in Aleppo Province, claiming they are being marginalized http://youtu.be/j26Ow23GcrU

The town of Jamla near the border with Israel continues to witness heavy clashes between rebels and loyalist militias http://youtu.be/bgvlHSGUL9s It’s a group affiliated with the rebels in Jamla that is currently holding the UN observer.

The battle for control of rebel strongholds in Homs city continues http://youtu.be/9Jkyc8E3vvY , http://youtu.be/EaVyZ0KHGNQ , http://youtu.be/uKLGQJm4lwM , http://youtu.be/DrfCv8966u4 , http://youtu.be/yrEkU2pbziM

Chris Smith, Chairman of House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Human Rights, Denied Russian Visa

By Madeline Schiesser
Impunity Watch Reporter, Europe

MOSCOW, Russia – U.S. Representative Chris Smith, a leading congressional human-rights advocate, was denied a visa to travel to Russia last week by authorities in Moscow.  Smith believes the denial is in retaliation for the recently passed U.S. Magnitsky Act, which imposes sanctions and visa bans on Russian officials believed involved in human rights violations.

Rep. Chris Smith (R-NJ). (Photo Courtesy of the Moscow Times)

Russia has never before denied Rep. Chris Smith (R-NJ), the chairman of the House Foreign Affairs subcommittee on human rights, a visa.  Smith says “The Magnitsky bill is the reason I didn’t get the visa.  This is the first time.  I was shocked.  During the worst days of the Soviet Union I went there repeatedly.”  Smith vocally backed and voted in favor of the bill, as did 364 other members of the House.  Russia is now among a short list of countries, including China, Cuba, and Belarus, to deny Smith, a veteran of the House since 1981, a visa.

No official reason has been given for refusing the visa and the Russian Embassy in Washington has refused to comment on visa issues.  However, Russian Ambassador to the U.S. Sergey Kislyak told Smith that the decision was made in Moscow, not Washington.

Although the State Department, including U.S. Ambassador to Russia Mike McFaul, attempted to intercede on Smith’s behalf, Moscow was not swayed.

The purpose of Smith’s visit was to discuss the frosty relations between Russia and the United States since the passage of the Magnitsky Act, particularly Russia’s reply, the Dima Yakovlev Law.  This law, passed shortly before the end of last year, ended U.S. adoption of Russian orphans (citing concerns American parents abuse Russian children) and reciprocal sanctions including visa bans and asset freezes for alleged U.S. human rights violators.

“I even have a resolution that highlights the fact that those 19 kids died.  If somebody is responsible for this, they ought to pay a price,” Smith lamented.  “I was going over to talk about adoption and human trafficking.  They have legitimate concerns that we have to meet.”

Russian authorities were incensed when U.S. President Barack Obama signed the Magnitsky Act into law in December, and considered the Act, labeling certain Russian officials as connected to human rights abuses, as meddling in Russian domestic affairs.  By mid-April, the Obama administration is required to submit a list of Russian officials to be blacklisted, which could further heighten tensions between the countries.

Valery Garbuzov, the deputy director of the Institute for U.S. and Canadian Studies in Moscow, has warned that Smith’s visa denial may be the first volley in an extended visa war.  He further cautioned that the nations’ top leaders need to take actions to halt such a visa war.  “President Obama cannot cancel the Magnitsky Act, so relations will have to be built on these premises,” he said. “At the same time, the Russian response was excessive, which made the situation snowball.”

MP Alexei Pushkov, head of the State Duma’s International Affairs Committee, said whether U.S. officials receive visas is dependent upon the United States, and noted that the sponsors of the Magnitsky Act will not be allowed to travel to Russia, in the “spirit” of the Dima Yakovlv law.  “We were not the initiators of this process,” he said.  “In every country, restrictions can be put in place for certain categories of people based on the spirit of existing legislation.”

Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov declared in January that Russia has a “Guantanamo list” of 71 U.S. nationals who are barred from entering Russia due to human rights violations.

Smith, however, is determined to keep a dialogue open with Russia, and plans to continue to push for the visa. “I was going over to talk about adoption and human trafficking,” Smith said. “They have legitimate concerns that we have to meet. I’m disappointed but I am determined to have it reversed. So I’m going to reapply.”

For further information, please see:

Moscow Times – U.S. Lawmaker Says Russia Denied Him Visa – 28 March 2013

RIA Novosti – US Official Denied Russian Visa, Cites Magnitsky Row: Report – 28 February 2013

RT – We Did Not Initiate the Visa Row With US – Russian Lawmaker – 28 February 2013

The Cable – Russia Denies Visa for Leading Congressional Human-Rights Advocate – 27 February 2013