Audit of Bainimarama’s Controversial Payout May Not Be Made Public

Audit of Bainimarama’s Controversial Payout May Not Be Made Public

By Sarah E. Treptow
Impunity Watch Reporter, Oceania

SUVA, Fiji – Auditor General Eroni Vatuloka has said an investigation report into a payout of $184,740 to interim PM Commodore Voreqe Bainimarama will be ready by the end of February.  The payout was reportedly for leave he said he was owed in 1978.  Mr. Vatuloka normally reports directly to Parliament, who would then make the report public.  However, under the interim regime, the reports have gone to the interim finance minister.  Currently the interim finance minister is Bainimarama.

Mr. Vatuloka began investigations in to the payout in July when the payout was made public.  Bainimarama was back-paid for 698 days, totaling $20,406.71.  At the time Bainimrama referred all questions to the army chief-of-staff, Colonel Mohammed Aziz.  Colonel Aziz denied it was a payout and said 40 officers who were seconded since the 2006 coup received similar treatment.  He said it was unfortunate Bainimarama was not paid the money until he was interim Prime Minister.

Professor Wadan Narsey has expressed concerns over the lack of transparency of Fiji’s interim government.  Narsey said, “A terribly loud question has to be asked: Why are our corporate bodies, our senior accounting firms, and our employers’ federations not demanding that the Auditor General and the Interim Government must release the audit reports to the public?”

It is unclear at this point whether the final auditor’s report will be made public.

For more information, please see:
Fiji Times – PM Audit – 10 February 2009

Fiji Times – Audit report not for public – 10 February 2009

HRW: New Bangladesh Government Should Reform Human Rights

By Pei Hu
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

DHAKA, Bangladesh – International human rights group, Human Rights Watch, urged the new Awami League government of Bangladesh to reform human rights policies. In the past there have been reports of abuses by Bangladeshi police and the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB), an elite security force that rights groups hold accountable for extrajudicial killings, arbitrary detention and torture.

Brad Adams, Human Rights Watch Asia director, said, Bangladesh’s “ new government has a large majority and a public hungry for reform …We look forward to the government using the strong mandate the prime minister and her party have obtained to tackle the very serious abuses that Bangladeshis face at the hands of the security forces and others.”

A human rights group told APF, security forces in Bangladesh unlawfully shot or tortured to death at least 149 people in 2008 when the country was ruled by an army-backed government.

Reportedly, 137 people were shot dead by police and the RAB, and 12 were tortured to death. The Bangladesh government said the killings occurred when suspects resisted arrest or were caught in crossfire between criminals and security forces. A surge in “crossfire” deaths began in 2004 when the then-democratically elected government set up the RAB to stem rising crime. Since RAB’s inception, the elite force has been accused of killing more than 540 people, mainly crime suspects and outlawed Maoists.

However, Odhikar, a Bangladeshi human rights group, said the killings were unlawful. The organization said, “What worries Odhikar and others is the absolute impunity enjoined with extrajudicial killings … None of the killings are investigated or perpetrators made to account.”

When an army-backed government took over in January 2007 after a state of emergency was imposed, people were killed, elections were cancelled, and press freedom curbed.

On December 29 2008, the secular Awami League led by Sheikh Hasina, who had served previously as a prime minister, won the elections. Adams said, “How the government responds to recommendations for human rights progress at the Human Rights Council will be an early test for the new government.”

For more information, please see:


APF – Bangladesh Security Forces Illegally Kill 149 in 2008: Rights Group -17 January 2009

Daily Star –149 Killed in Extra-judicial Action in ’08 – 8 January 2009

HRW – Bangladesh: New Government Should Act on Rights – 29 January 2009

UN Reviews China’s Human Rights Record

By Ariel Lin
Impunity Watch Report, Asia

BEIJING, China – The United Nations Human Rights Council opened its fourth session of the Universal Periodic Review in Geneva last week.  The session will examine the human rights records of 16 countries, including Germany, Canada, China, Cuba, Mexico, Russia and Saudi Arabia.  In a hearing, while European delegations called on Beijing to end the death penalty and halt torture in prisons.  Many Asian and African countries praised China’s achievements in the promotion and protection of human rights, and said China is an example for them to follow.

However, days before UN’s review on China’s Human Rights record, the officers stationed outside a government building in Beijing took away at least eight people.  They are members of a group of 30 who had traveled to the capital from around the country, protesting various problems involving local corruption.  One member carried a banner says “Safeguard human rights. I love China”.  Li Fengxian, a gray-haired woman, held up a sign with the character for “injustice”.  Li, 65, said she has spent years fighting officials in her village who give away a poverty allowance allotted to her family to other officials.

The incident is not unusual.  These people often come with stacks of documents and pictures of their loved ones.  Most are detained by police and sent home.  “My goal today is to defeat corruption with the law and win some justice,” said Chen Xinchun, a 40-year-old farmer from Sichuan province. He has come to Beijing five times trying to plead with the Cabinet, the courts and the public security bureau for an investigation into the death of his mother at 20 years ago.  Chen said someone connected with local police beat his mother to death.

China presented a report on human rights in the country to the United Nations.  In the report, China said, “The international community should respect the principle of the indivisibility of human rights and attach equal importance to civil and political rights and economic, social and cultural rights as well as the right to development.”

China’s ambassador, Li Baodong, defended his country’s rights record to the council.  He rejected suggestions from Western countries that China uses torture and jails dissidents and insisting China’s policies are guided by the rule of law. “China is the world’s largest developing country. We are fully aware of our difficulties and challenges in the field of human rights,” he said.

Some human rights activists were angered by the report, stating China had failed to address key concerns such as persecution on religious and ethnic grounds and press censorship.  The report omits any references to abuses that are occurring across China, according to Amnesty International.  It fails to mention the unrest in Tibet last year, the crackdown on Uighurs in the western Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region and the persecution of religious followers, including members of Falun Gong, the London- based group said.

For more information, please see:

AP – China hammers dissent despite looming UN review – 07 February 2009

AP – China police take away citizens airing grievances – 06 February 2009

Reuters – China human rights record stirs struggle at home – 08 February 2009

Reuters – China says protects human rights, West voices doubt – 09 February 2009

Wall Street Journal – Human Rights, the U.N. and China – 09 February 2009

XinHua – Foreign Ministry: UN human rights review important to China – 05 February 2009

UN, Commonwealth Team to Review Political Situation in Fiji

By Hayley J. Campbell
Impunity Watch Reporter, Oceania

SUVA, Fiji – A United Nations and Commonwealth Joint Technical Team arrives in Fiji today to begin a fact-finding mission of the political situation.

The UN and Commonwealth has decided to act together after receiving a request to mediate an “inclusive, independent and time-bound political dialogue process.” The team consists of Mari Yamashita and Alex Grzybowski from the United Nations and Juliet Solomon and Sabhita Raju from the Commonwealth.

As part of its agenda, the Team will meet with members of Fiji’s interim Government as well as key stakeholders.

The goal of the fact-finding mission is to facilitate Fiji’s return to democratic rule through elections. Meanwhile, Fiji’s Interim Prime Minister, Commodore Frank Bainimarama, has been unwilling to relinquish power or set a date for those elections.

In 2006, Bainimarama led the bloodless coup of Fiji’s Federal government. Since then, he has promised to restore stability and democracy, but has yet to step down as Interim Prime Minister.

Ousted Prime Minister, Laisenia Qarase, says he looks forward to meeting with representatives from the UN and Commonwealth.

According to the Office of the United Nations Resident Coordinator in Fiji, the Technical Team will remain in Fiji until Saturday the 14th.

For more information, please see:
Fiji Times – UN, Commonwealth to follow up on technical missions – 09 February 2009

Radio New Zealand International – United Nations and Commonwealth joint technical team in Fiji – 08 February 2009

Fiji Times – UN to gather data on Fiji – 08 February 2009

Another No Confidence Motion Filed in French Polynesia

By Sarah E. Treptow
Impunity Watch Reporter, Oceania

PAPEETE, Tahiti – A no confidence motion was filed this week and signed by fifteen French Polynesia Assembly representatives from three political groups.  The groups are trying to put an end to five years of chronic instability, citing the chronic political instability that has had a severe impact on the local economy, political behaviors from the past, and the wish to form a majority exempt from political division.

The motion names pro-Tahiti independence leader Oscar Temaru as candidate to replace Gaston Tong Sang as Tahiti’s president.  The assembly will vote next week on the motion, which would topple the nine-month-old Tong Sang government.  It would also mark the fourth government under Temaru’s power since 2004 and become the eighth government Tahiti has had over the past five years.

The motion is the work of Temaru’s Union for Democracy coalition, Gaston Flosse’s pro-France, pro-Tahiti autonomy Tahoera’a Huiraatira party, and Jean-Christophe Bouissou’s pro-France, pro-Tahiti autonomy Rautahi party.  The three leaders claim to represent 31 of the assembly’s 57 seats, or a three-vote majority.  The 31 seats would give Temaru the biggest majority of any of the eight governments since 2004.

The no confidence motion ended more than two months of speculation, political maneuvering, and political summits involving Tahiti’s four key political leaders.

For more information, please see:
Tahiti Presse – Tong Sang claims Temaru’s only interest is “to block Flosse” – 05 February 2009

Pacific Islands Report – Another No Confidence Motion Filed in Tahiti – 06 February 2009

Fiji Times – Polynesia Vote – 07 February 2009