North Korea Health Care Crisis: Starving Population

North Korea Health Care Crisis: Starving Population

By David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

HAMGYONG, North Korea – Human rights group calls on international community to help end regime’s ‘systematic neglect’ and prevent humanitarian disaster.  North Korea is failing to provide the most basic healthcare needs for its people, Amnesty International warns.  Barely functioning hospitals, poor hygiene and epidemics made worse by widespread malnutrition was revealed from human rights watch dog.  An investigation by the human rights watchdog found many people were also too poor to pay for treatment.

Many children in North Korea are at risk of serious malnourishment
Many children in North Korea are at risk of serious malnourishment

The state’s failure to feed its people has produced a generation where nearly 50% suffer from stunted growth, where the hungry eat poisonous plants and pig feed, amputations are conducted without anesthetic and doctors are paid in cigarettes.

“If you don’t have money you die,” said the woman, who left North Korea in 2008.

Pyongyang spends less than $1 (£0.65) per person on healthcare a year, less than any other country, according to World Health Organization figures cited in the report.

Amnesty’s report, The Crumbling State of Health Care in North Korea, is based on interviews with more than 40 North Korean health professionals, who left the country between 2004 and 2009.

“The government’s failure to provide basic education about using medication is especially worrying as North Korea fights a tuberculosis epidemic,” said Catherine Barber, Amnesty International’s Deputy Director for the Asia Pacific.

Pyongyang says it provides free healthcare for its people, but witnesses told Amnesty they had to pay for all services for the past 20 years.

One 20-year-old woman from North Hamgyong province said: “People don’t bother going to the hospital if they don’t have money because everyone knows that you have to pay.  Poor hygiene at medical facilities and a dire lack of medicines were threatening the lives of many, Amnesty warned, with people routinely trading cigarettes, food and alcohol for treatment.

A 56-year-old woman told Amnesty that her appendix was removed without anaesthetic.  “The operation took about an hour and 10 minutes. I was screaming so much from the pain – I thought I was going to die.

North Korea faces critical food shortages following famine in the 1990s which killed up to one million people and relies on international aid.

A botched currency re-evaluation in 2009 almost doubled the price of rice overnight, and one non-governmental organization cited in the report said thousands of people starved to death in January and February this year in one province alone.

Politically the North finds itself isolated – it has withdrawn from international talks over its controversial nuclear programme.

For more information, please see:

BBC – Amnesty warns of healthcare crisis in North Korea – 15 July 2010

Business Week – North Korean Health System “Dire,” – 15 July 2010

Guardian.co.uk – North Korea facing health and food crisis – 15 July 2010

Colombian Military Has Violent Weekend Fighting FARC

Colombian Rebels (Photo Courtesy of Colombia Reports)
Colombian Rebels (Photo Courtesy of Colombia Reports)

By Patrick Vanderpool
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

BOGOTA, Colombia – According to Colombian President Alvaro Uribe, the Colombian military killed nine rebels in a fierce battle on Monday in the southern part of Caqueta, in the Amazonian region. 

Colombian officials stated that the Colombian Air Force and Joint Task Force OMEGA located a rebel camp run by Rodolfo Atanas and took action.  During the attack, Colombian armed forces seized a 60 mm mortar, guns and radio communication equipment.

This attack comes on the heels of another attack on a rebel camp on Sunday, which occurred in the central state of Tolima and claimed the lives of 12 rebels. 

In what proved to be a bloody day in Colombia’s constant fight against guerrilla groups, ten Colombian soldiers were also killed Sunday in a separate battle with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) in the Arauca state in northeastern Colombia.  The FARC, Colombia’s largest rebel group, is said to have 8,000 fighters.

According to President Uribe’s website, a female rebel leader known as “Maryeri” was among those killed on Sunday.  Maryeri is said to be responsible for as many as 70 Colombian soldiers’ deaths spanning the past eight years.  Additionally, the rebel group targeted on Sunday is responsible for more than 30 attacks in the Tolima area over the past two years.

In Arauca state, Colombian soldiers approached members of the rebel group as the guerrillas were attempting to blow up an electric plant.  When the rebels spotted the Colombian military, a gun fight broke out, killing ten Colombian military officials.

The Colombian government has been battling the FARC, as well as other paramilitary rebel groups, since the mid-1960’s.  Many of these groups use the drug trade, as well as extortion, to finance their activities.  The FARC also routinely capture people and holds them hostage in exchange for ransom.  In March, the FARC released one hostage and in June, Colombian officials successfully rescued four additional hostages.

The FARC appears to be stepping up activities with the approach of the August 7 presidential inauguration of former Defense Minister Juan Manuel Santo.  The weekend’s clashes between Colombian security forces and rebels left a total of 31 people dead. However, it is being hailed as a significant blow to the FARC’s southern bloc.

For more information, please see:

CNN – Colombian Army Kills 12 FARC Rebels, president says – 12 June 2010

Colombia Reports – Army Kills 9 FARC guerrillas in Caqueta – 12 June 2010

Latin American Herald Tribune – Colombian Troops Kill 9 Rebels – 11 June 2010

Israeli Military Investigation Finds Missteps, but Killings Justified

by Warren Popp
Impuntiy Watch Reporter, Middle East

Israeli soldiers on board one of the overtaken flotilla ships. (Photo Courtesy of Al Jazeera)
Israeli soldiers onboard one of the overtaken flotilla ships. (Photo Courtesy of Al Jazeera)

TEL AVIV, Israel – An internal military investigation headed by Israel’s Major General, Giora Eiland, which was created to look into the deadly Gaza aid flotilla incident, recently completed its work. The deadly flotilla incident covered by the report occurred on May thirty-first when the Israel Defense Force (IDF) attempted to overtake a convoy of ships that was determined to break Israel’s blockade of Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid. The report found that the IDF faced violent resistance by armed activists, including being shot, stabbed, and beaten with metal objects. Activists claim that the IDF indiscriminately used live fire against activists as they boarded the ship, and that the IDF was the first to fire. The incident left several IDF soldiers seriously injured, nine activists dead, and dozens of other activists wounded. According to the IDF Spokesperson, “The [investigation] team was appointed by the Chief of the General Staff to examine the deployment towards the flotilla, the chosen course of action and other possible alternatives, advance preparations, and the operation’s implementation.”

The report concluded that the military made several mistakes in the preparation for the raid, including a failure to utilize all possible intelligence gathering methods (although the IDF claims there is no guarantee that a complete intelligence gathering effort would have created a full intelligence picture); a failure to plan for all possible contingencies, including both the general outcome that ensued and especially for the expected level of violence; and a failure to seek other technological alternatives for stopping vessels from reaching Gaza, although here the report emphasized that no country in the world, at least to their knowledge, has the ability to stop a vessel at sea in a non hostile manner.

In terms of the actions of the IDF commandos, the IDF spokesperson said the following in regards to the report: “The team determined that the Navy Commando soldiers operated properly, with professionalism, bravery and resourcefulness and that the commanders exhibited correct decision making. The report further determines that the use of live fire was justified and that the entire operation is estimable.” The report also found there were mistakes made “at quite a senior level” but did not recommend punishments for any of the officers involved in the May 31 raid.

Israel has rejected calls by the United Nations Secretary-General, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, and other world leaders for an international investigation, and has claimed it will not cooperate with a Human Rights Council commission that is being set up to investigate the incident.

In addition to the mlitary investigation, Isreal has set up a panel, the Tirkel Committee, to investigate the incident, and  to decide whether the raid was in compliance with international law. This panel consists of three retired judges and two experts, and also includes two prominent foreign observers: David Trimble, a Northern Ireland politician, and Nobel Peace Prize laureate and the Canadian jurist, Ken Watkin. The Tirkel Committee has no power to summon anyone from the IDF except for General Ashkenazi. Prime Minister Netanyahu , Defense Minister Barak, and General Ashkenazi are all expected to testify before the panel publicly and under oath. Al Jazeera reported that Mark Regev, a spokesman for the Israeli government, told Al Jazeera that, “Israel’s investigatory process, both civilian and military, meets the highest international standards,” and, “It’s standard operating procedure [to investigate] after any military operation, especially an operation that has human fatalities.”

The Turkish group that organized the humanitarian convoy, IHH, criticized the report, particularly the claim that the IDF  was justified in using live ammunition. The IHH maintains that the IDF commandos were responsible for starting the violence. Huseyin Oruc, a member of IHH’s board reportedly told Al Jazeera, “If you compare the passengers on the Mavi Marmara and the soldiers, even their equipment… you can understand how much balance there was between the two sides.”

Turkey, whose close diplomatic relationship with Israel have faced serious strains since the incident, including the withdrawal of the Turkish Ambassador to Israel, welcomed the internal investigation and report, but is still calling on Israel to agree to a full and impartial international investigation. All nine of the activists who were killed in the incident were Turkish, including one who was a dual United States-Turkish citizen. Turkey’s Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, said that he welcomed the acknowledgement that “mistakes” were made, but believed that IDF commandos committed “a crime” and that an international investigation is warranted.

Crew members onboard the Libyan ship before its departure towards Gaza. (Photo Courtesy of Al Arabiya News channel)
Crew members onboard a Libyan ship before its departure towards Gaza. (Photo Courtesy of Al Arabiya News channel)

The report was issued during the same time that a humanitarian aid ship from Libya was heading for Gaza. The ship is carrying about fifteen activists, primarily from Libya, and a dozen crew members. The ship is associated with the Gaddafi International Charity and Development Foundation (GICDF) led by the son of the Libyan leader, Colonel Muammar el-Qaddafi. The foundation of GICDF said on its website that the boat’s goal was to deliver two-thousand tons of aid to Gaza. After threats by Israel to intercept the ship, including a disputed report that Israel issued an ultimatum to the Libyan vessel, the ship reportedly changed course on July thirteenth, and is now slowly heading towards Egypt (mechanical difficulties along with a reported dispute between the crew of the ship and the activists regarding the final destination make confirmation of this by news agencies difficult). The Egyptian government has offered to accept the ship at one of its ports in the Sinai Peninsula and then deliver the goods to Gaza. Youssef Sawani, the executive director of GICDF said, “We hope the Israelis will not ban the ship from entering the port of Gaza. If they decide to do so we have no means to object to that. This is a peaceful mission”

For more information, please see:

AFP – Israel PM to Testify Before Gaza Panel on Aug 9 – 13 July 2010

Al Jazeera – Gaza Aid Ship ‘Diverts’ to Egypt – 13 July 2010

Al Jazeera – Israel: Use of Live Fire Justified – 13 July 2010

Jerusalem Post – Conflicting Reports at Sea – 13 July 2010

Jerusalem Post – Turkey Welcomes Eiland Report But Still Wants Int’l Probe – 13 July 2010

N.Y. Times – Gaza-Bound Ship Diverts to Egypt, Averting Clash -13 July 2010

Israel Defense Force Blog – Maj. Gen. (Res.) Eiland Submits Conclusions of Military Examination Team Regarding Mavi Marmara, 12 July 2010– 12 July 2010

N.Y. Timess – Israeli Military Finds Flotilla Killings Justified – 12 July 2010

Al Arabiya News Channel – Gaza-Bound Aid Ship Sets Sail From Greece – 10 July 2010

ICC Charges Sudanese President with Genocide

ICC judges issued an arrest warrant charging al-Bashir with three counts of genocide: by killing, by causing mental and physical harm, and by deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction. (Photo Courtesy of ABC)
ICC judges issued an arrest warrant charging al-Bashir with three counts of genocide: by killing, by causing mental and physical harm, and "by deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction." (Photo Courtesy of ABC)

By Sovereign Hager
Managing Editor- News, Impunity Watch

THE HAGUE, Netherlands-The Pre-Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued a second arrest warrant for Sudanese President Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir. The chamber found reasonable grounds to believe Bashir responsible for three counts of genocide committed against the Fur, Masalit, and Zaghawa ethnic groups.

The ICC issued its first arrest warrant against Bashir in March of 2009 and it continues to be in effect. The first arrest warrant is for five counts of crimes against humanity, including murder, extermination, forcible transfer, torture, and rape. It also included two counts for war crimes: intentionally directing attacks against a civilian population and pillaging.

The initial arrest warrant rejected the genocide charge, which the Prosecutor appealed on July of 2009. In February of 2010, the Appeals Chamber reversed the decision unanimously on the genocide charge due to an erroneous standard of proof. The Appeals Chamber then ordered the Pre-Trial Chamber to decide the genocide charge again based on a correct standard of proof – reasoable grounds.

The Pre-Trial Chamber I concluded that in fact there was reasonable grounds to believe that Bashir had the specific intent to destroy in part three ethnic groups.

In issueing the warrant, the Pre-Trial Chamber I seeks international co-operation in obtaining the surrender and arrest of Bashir for the charges on both the first and second arrest warrants. A request has been sent to the Sudanese authorities as well as to all State Parties to the Rome Statute, and the United Nations Security Counicl members that are not parties to the Rome Statute.

The United Nations Security Council referred the situation in Darfur to the ICC via resolution 1593, on March 31, 2005. Four cases are being heard under this resolution.

The Sudanese government criticised the ICC decision, calling it a “political decision” and stating that “Sudan does not pay attention to this political campaign and will respond to it with more economic achievements. Sudan’s minister of information called the indictment a “desperate attempt to create instability in Sudan in order to stop its development process.” Bashir refuses to recognize the ICC’s authority and refuses to stand trial.

Genocide is considered the gravest crime in international law, requiring proof of an intent to wipe out “in whole or in part” a racial, religious, or ethnic group. ICC Prosecutor, Moreno-Ocampo accused Bahir of keeping 2.5 million refugees from specific ethnic groups in Darfur in camps “under genocide conditions, like a gigantic Auschwitz.”

For more information, please see:

Open Democracy-The Omar al-Bashir Indictment: the ICC and the Darfur Crisis-15 July 2010

International Criminal Court-Trial Chamber Issues a Second Warrant of Arrest Against Omar Al Bashir for Counts of Genocide-12 July, 2010

Rueters-Omar Bashir Indicted for Genocide-12 July, 2010

Gilad Shalit update: Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with captured soldier’s parents

By Polly Johnson
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

Gilad Shalits parents meet with Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu. (Photo Courtesy of BBC.)
Gilad Shalit's parents meet with Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu. (Photo Courtesy of Ha'aretz.)

JERUSALEM, Israel – Last Friday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his wife Sara held an hour-long meeting with the parents of captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit.

Noam and Aviva Shalit reached Netanyahu’s official residence in Jerusalem following a twelve-day march, in an effort to secure their son’s release. Gilad, now twenty-three years old, was captured in June 2006 by Palestinian militants and has been held in Gaza by Hamas militants who have demanded the release of as many as one thousand Palestinian prisoners in exchange for Shalit’s release.

Shalit’s family set up a protest tent at the culmination of the protest march, vowing to demonstrate outside the weekly cabinet meetings until their son is released. Over the weekend, visitors streamed in and out of the tent, in a showing of support for the family.

Following the meeting with Netanyahu, Noam Shalit said that there was no new news, but also indicated that the family did not have high hopes prior to their meeting with Netanyahu.

“We have received no news yet that might calm us or change the situation. We’ll remain in the tent as planned; there is no change. We’ll stay here until Gilad returns,” Noam said.

Netanyahu, who recently returned from a trip to the United States, told the couple that the issue of their son’s release was one of the topics discussed with U.S. President Barack Obama and other senior officials in Washington.

“It’s not just the tens of thousands of marchers who support you, but all the citizens of the state of Israel,” Netanyahu told the Shalits. “There are also millions of people abroad who are with you, as are my wife and myself.”

Palestinian news agency Ma’an reported on Sunday that Netanyahu asked former U.S. president Bill Clinton to help mediate the release of Shalit. Netanyahu met with Clinton during his trip to Washington, where he proposed that Clinton visit Gaza to negotiate with senior Hamas officials.

Netanyahu has said that Israel will release one thousand Palestinian prisoners, though not all the ones that Hamas wants. Some that might be released are serving multiple life sentences for their roles in organizing suicide bombings.

For more information, please see:

BBC – Netanyahu meets Shalit’s parents – 9 July 2010

Ha’aretz – Shalit family to protest outside weekly cabinet meetings – 11 July 2010

Ha’aretz – Report: Netanyahu asks Bill Clinton to mediate Shalit release – 11 July 2010

The Media Line – Public Support for the Release of Gilad Shalit Continues after Five Years – 12 July 2010