Even a “Big Man” Must Face Justice: Lessons From the Trial of Charles Taylor

Even a “Big Man” Must Face Justice: Lessons From the Trial of Charles Taylor

Human Rights Watch Special Report

 

For a questions and answers document on the Charles Taylor trial and judgment, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/node/106451

To view a special webpage on the Charles Taylor trial, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/topic/international-justice/charles-taylor

To read a chronology of the Charles Taylor case, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/04/11/prosecutor-v-charles-ghankay-taylor-chronology-case-special-court-sierra-leone

For more Human Rights Watch reporting about the armed conflict in Sierra Leone, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/node/106424

For more Human Rights Watch reporting about the armed conflict in Liberia, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/node/106425

For more information, please contact:
In New York, Annie Gell (English): +1-510-541-0843; or +1-212-377-9424; or gella@hrw.org
In New York, Elise Keppler (English): +1-917-687-8576; or +1-212- 216-1249; or kepplee@hrw.org
In Stuttgart, Géraldine Mattioli-Zeltner (French): +49-711-722-300-90; or +49-151-4650-8928 (mobile); or mattiog@hrw.org

SNHR and DCHRS: Female Detainees Without Rights in Syrian Prisons

Bring This Mother Back to her Children:

On 19 May 2011, civilian and military clad personnel from a Syrian Air Force patrol stormed Anna’noo’ Photography Center, located on Ibn Seena Road in the city of Jableh in Lattakia Province.  Four medium-sized men from the patrol dragged away Mrs. Majida Mahmoud who had been working at the center for two years.  She was thrown into their vehicle and taken to an undisclosed location.  There were no female officers accompanying the patrol.  This was the last anybody saw Mrs. Mahmoud before her disappearance, as reported by eyewitness, Mr. (Q. N.).

Majida Adnan Mahmoud was born in the city of Jableh on 14 November 1977.  She resided in Al-Fayd neighborhood and has two children from a previous marriage, the children (Ali ,a 12 year old boy and Nour, a 10 year old girl) currently live with her mother, Safa.

The Syrian regime has forbidden any communication with the Mrs. Mahmoud.  She was kidnapped more than a month ago, and even the appointment of a lawyer, to handle her case and ensure her rights are maintained, has been denied to her.  Further, the regime has also not stated the nature of Mrs. Mahmoud’s charge that lead to her detention.

Nonetheless, female ex-detainees have stated that they bumped into Mrs. Mahmoud in holding cells or interrogation halls and have confirmed she had was arrested for communicating with her relative, Abdulhadi Mahmoud.  He is one of the most wanted men in Jableh city for charges of igniting the revolution and being one of its central leaders and activists.  Additionally, earlier this year the Syrian Aerial Intelligence arrested and detained her brother, Adnan Mahmoud for two months.  Upon his release he exhibited signs of severe and prolonged torture.

Mariam, Majida Mahmoud’s nickname, was transferred to Lattakia after her forced disappearance and later to the capital Damascus, according to the account of eyewitness (S. S.) who met her at the capital prison.  No one in Mariam’s family has been allowed to see her at this point.

Damascus Center for Human Rights and the Syrian Network for Human Rights call on international bodies and organizations to mobilize and press the Syrian regime for the protection of Mrs. Majida and the ensuring of her safe return to her children.  DCHR and SNHR call on these organizations to press for the human rights’ organizations getting access to Mrs. Majida so she can be represented and so the realities of female detainees across Syrian prisons in the Arab world be highlighted for all the world to see.

Syrian Revolution Digest – Tuesday 24 July 2012

THE COMMENTARY IN THIS PIECE DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE VIEWS OF IMPUNITY WATCH.  

*WARNING VIDEOS MAY CONTAIN GRAPHIC IMAGES*

A New Middle Eastern WMD Saga!

Damascus City is officially the oldest continuously inhabited city in the world. An assault on Damascus is an assault on history. Indeed, it’s part of our collective memory and consciousness that is being pounded to the ground as we watch and throw our hands in the air.

Monday July 23, 2012

Today’s Death toll: 175. The Breakdown: 90 in Damascus and Suburbs, 25 in Daraa, 15 in Aleppo, 15 in Idlib, 10 in Deir Ezzor, 9 in Homs, 7 in Hama, 3 in Lattakia, and 1 in Raqqah.

Cities & Towns Under Shelling: Harasta, Arbeen, Moadamiyah, Haran Al-Awameed, Zabadani, Madaya, Eltal, Dmeir, Hameh, Yelda, Rankous, Qarrah (Damascus Suburbs), Sit Zeinab, Al-Qadam, Modan, Al-Hajar Al-Aswad, Yarmouk, Kafar Sousseh, Mazzeh, Qaboun, Barzeh (Damascus City), Daraa City, Khirbet Al-Ghazaleh, Tafas, Bostra Al-Sham, Na’eemah, Mseifrah, Jimreen, Hraak (Daraa), Rastan, Talbisseh, Houla, Tal Kalakh, Al-Qusayr, Al-Hosn, Al-Ghanto, Al-Bouaydah, Old Homs (Homs Province), Hreitan, Elbab, Eizaz, Marei, Bayanoun (Aleppo Province), Haffeh, Jabal Al-Akrad (Lattakia), Deir Ezzor City, Mouhassan, Albou Kamal (Deir Ezzor Province), Kafar Zeiteh, Hawash, Shahshabo, Hama City (Hama Province), Jabal Al-Zawiyeh, Maar’at Al-Nouman, Saraqib, Maar Shoureen (Idlib)

News

Senior Israeli official: Syria regime ‘acting responsibly’ about chemical weapons Assad has been moving some of the chemical stockpiles to bases remote from the fighting or having greater security, the source added.

Mortar shell from Syria lands near Israeli border In second incident this week, a mortar shell lands close to border in northern Golan Heights; IDF: It is the result of fighting between Syrian army and rebels.

Op-Eds & Special Reports

Will Syria use chemical weapons against foreigners? The past week of fighting in Syria has escalated international pressure on President Bashar al-Assad. Syrian officials now say they won’t use their biological and chemical weapons ‘unless Syria faces external aggression.’

As Syria Teeters, So Do Decades-Old Assumptions About the Middle EastThe conflict is testing the brittle bonds of a national identity in states carved out of old Ottoman provinces at the end of World War I.

Analysis: The myth of Palestinian neutrality in Syria It is both painfully ironic and incredibly moving that Yarmouk, built to host ethnically cleansed Palestinians, has now turned into a safe haven for Syrians fleeing the shelling on Tadamon and Midan; that UNRWA schools became shelters in the last few days; and that Palestinian residents of the camp have donated mattresses, meals and medicine for their wounded Syrian neighbors. These acts of solidarity have been beacons of inspiration amid the endless cycle of violence and grief that has descended upon Syria.

Analysis: Syrian Civil War Enters New Phase The rebels are winning. But the latest events do not yet herald the beginning of the regime’s last stand. That moment has not yet arrived. When it does, it may well not take place in Damascus.

In Syria conflict, U.S. struggles to fill intelligence gaps With no CIA operatives on the ground in Syria and only a handful stationed at key border posts, the agency has been heavily dependent on its counterparts in Jordan and Turkey and on other regional allies.

Is Syria’s Bashar Assad Going the Way of Muammar Gaddafi? As his regime slowly crumbles and options for exile and reconciliation narrow, Syria’s embattled President Bashar Assad looks likely to cling grimly on to power, no matter the consequences.

The Saga

Not too long ago, the Wall Street Journal published a report including leaks from the American officials to the effect that Assad has moved part of his WMD stockpiles from Damascus in the direction of Homs. Today, we got confirmation from the regime itself that the regime does indeed have WMD stockpiles and that it would them in case it is attacked by a foreign power. Considering the fact that the rebels are considered to be foreign agents working for external powers, the assertion made that WMDs will not be used against the people rang hollow.

But the whole situation becomes even more Kafkaesque when we take in consideration that Iraq was invaded for suspicion of having WMDs, and here we have a neighboring regime openly boasting of its WMD capacity and threatening to use it. Yet all that President would say about this is that “the world is watching!” But that’s exactly what the world has been doing since the beginning of the revolution, and what difference did that make so far? How exactly did that impact the behavior of Assad ad his militias? If the world is not planning to act, who gives the damn that it’s watching. After all, we are not putting on a show for its amusement.

But the plot thickened even more today.

According to Israeli officials, Assad has moved stockpiles of WMDs to more “secure areas” for safekeeping. The only secure areas today are located along the coast and in the coastal mountains where WMDs’ presence could also serve to secure the enclave for Assad when push comes to shove.

There were reports circulated by Kurdish activists not too long ago through Facebook claiming that Assad moved some of his stockpiles as well to the Kurdish-majority town of Qamishly in the northeast. The town has recently fallen under the control of the Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD), the Syrian branch of the PKK. If these reports were true, then Turkey’s worst enemies might be about to get their hands on stockpiles of chemical weapons. Personally, however, I seriously doubt that these reports are true. It does not make sense for Assad to move any WMDs to a region where his control has become tenuous from day one in the revolution. The logical place for WMDs at this stage is the coast and the surrounding mountains.

But the move by Bashar Al-Assad may not have come soon enough, if we are to believe these sensational claims made by Captain Maher Al-Nouaimai, the official spokesman of the Free Syrian Army. For in an interview with the Saudi newspaper Al-Watan, Al-Nouaimi says that the Damascus rebels have recently captured missiles from a base on Mount Qasayoun that are actually loaded with WMDs. He also said that the rebels now have 15 helicopter gunships under their disposal after their original pilots defected and joined the rebels.

It’s difficult to dismiss these reports offhand, since they are made by the official spokesman for the FSA, but it’s reasonable to demand and expect proof, perhaps in the form of a video.

Meanwhile, irrespective of whether these reports are true or false, the regime can now use WMDs and blame it on the rebels.

Video Highlights

A massacre in the Damascene suburb of Daraya resulting from the continued shelling http://youtu.be/sxKrqpnG2tw In nearby Moadamiyah, local activists found dead bodies that seem to have been intentionally set on fire http://youtu.be/-Hh3X_nIVm8 In Al-Hameh, people prepare the victims of another massacre for burial http://youtu.be/sYU4WjOpSVo Another massacre takes place in Dmeirhttp://youtu.be/gG1sDh068O4 In Kafar Sousseh, another massacre (July 22)http://youtu.be/2FCM9khKCdk

The pounding of Zabadani continues by night http://youtu.be/LYdfg3SLyjo and during the day http://youtu.be/kvfX9vTcgYk , http://youtu.be/w4JxRfcpxUI

Local activists take control of the political security apparatus in the Damascene suburb of Harasta http://youtu.be/e_9oGjMIDWE

The nearby suburb of Saqba is being patrolled by pro-Assad militias in their tankshttp://youtu.be/QlWTWcRslW8 , http://youtu.be/2wW0XQVNuPI

In Damascus City, the pounding of the old Cactus Groves in Mazzeh Bassateencontinues http://youtu.be/SrtrRa5sN7U The nearby neighborhood of Ikhlas was completely destroyed, the building under construction we can see behind it is the new Iranian Embassy  http://youtu.be/NokdFN3fWAU ,http://youtu.be/0VTxvkUoK_w , http://youtu.be/YfWQ-RTvsoU

The pounding of Al-Qadam Neighborhood continues http://youtu.be/KSlUzoqnaeIScenes of havoc and destruction from Qaboun http://youtu.be/IjlIHl__1VQ

Tanks and buses belonging to pro-Assad militias patrol the neighborhood ofNaher Eisheh in Damascus City http://youtu.be/apyDUARFtTU ,http://youtu.be/NB_iDJerYC4 The neighborhood was pounded by helicopter gunships a day earlier http://youtu.be/hE1dxML_-D8

An internal interview with Abou Joum’ah, the leader of Al-Tawhid Brigade in Aleppo Province, whose members are taking part in the battles of Aleppo city as well. The interview took place on July 18. http://youtu.be/8kPf37O1MnQ Abou Joum’ah vows to close down the embassies of Iran, Russia and China and to sever all relations with these countries once Syria is liberated. Other leaders pledge to liberate Aleppo.

In Aleppo City, pro-Assad militias are busy targeting and killing activists. This is one from the neighborhood of Marjeh http://youtu.be/ormPw7P1fgw Elsewhere in Aleppo City, a video leaked by activists from inside the central prison shows imprisoned activists receiving treatment for wounds received during clashes with prison authorities http://youtu.be/Ccx_lJ-gQVk Eight activists were reported dead.

In Sakhour Neighborhood, clashes between FSA units and pro-Assad militias left two tanks destroyed http://youtu.be/Ig0XI43quZ4 ,http://youtu.be/2wW0XQVNuPI One tank was confiscatedhttp://youtu.be/T7TB9TM6xGE In Hanano, clashes http://youtu.be/FSalyGIq-sA ,http://youtu.be/537fYojHnVg left one tank destroyedhttp://youtu.be/DqbOJtkM8oQ , http://youtu.be/Wb7uMdHFfAI Residents stream out of the neighborhood http://youtu.be/aoikwVgvKhE

In Salaheddine Neighborhood, local activists clean their streets to make up for the interruption of services http://youtu.be/ndHZ5Y6kCuA Elsewhere in the neighborhood, pro-Assad militias engage in random shooting to terrorize the residents http://youtu.be/lGFLdikTR5o

In Jabal Al-Akrad, Lattakia, fires from the pounding carried out by pro-Assad militias keep burning http://youtu.be/1vAWUAh9KaA

In Homs Province, the pounding of Talbisseh continueshttp://youtu.be/K7ybLBnn7RI So does the pounding of Rastanhttp://youtu.be/OM8NQ7OPGks The pounding of Old Homs as wellhttp://youtu.be/MbM-zn0nY4c , http://youtu.be/mDPnonnTFYI ,http://youtu.be/WXTEH91s4zg

The pounding of Hawash, Sahel Al-Ghab, Hama Province, continueshttp://youtu.be/4RCFcg0DyDg , http://youtu.be/IsIYPOXU9hY

Daraa City, among other towns in Daraa Province, continue to be poundedhttp://youtu.be/YeBvSkuxf8Y , http://youtu.be/3ZPZs6AcrEk Homes catch firehttp://youtu.be/IfsKAc6GPXw Nearby Al-Hraak was pounded as wellhttp://youtu.be/-Eeovd1FSqs , http://youtu.be/hmDufsKHwuE

Nasa Justice: Flogging Solution for FARC Rebels

By Margaret Janelle Hutchinson
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

BOGOTA, Colombia – Four Nasa Indians who had taken up arms with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, or FARC appeared before a group of roughly 1,000 elders and residents of Nasa reserves in the embattled southwestern province of Cauca over the weekend.  The defendants, one minor and three adults, were convicted of attacking civilians and disrupting the “harmony” of the community. The minor was sentenced to 10 lashes and each adult received 30 lashes.

Through flogging FARC rebels have the option of rejoining their Nasa community. (Photo courtesy of Fox News Latino)

Watch: FARC rebels flogged by Colombian tribe. (Video Courtesy of Al Jazeera)

The trial, part of a push by the indigenous tribe to get both FARC rebels and government forces off their land, is lawful under Colombia’s 1991 constitution, which promises autonomy to the nation’s 102 indigenous ethnic groups.

The Nasa, also known as the Paez, do not consider the sentence to be a “punishment”, but rather see the flogging as a “solution” that allows the defendants to restore balance to their relationship with the community and with their spirit.

Marcos Yule, the governor of the Toribio reservation, explained that the solutions that are normally imposed under the indigenous law are the “cepo,” a wooden structure that presses on the legs or hands, temporary burial where only the head is above ground, the “whip to beat the illness, counseling and even … exile.”

The four FARC fighters were whipped on the lower half of their bodies, causing serious wounds on the backs of their legs that were treated by community medics.

“The adults received the 30 (lashes) but the minor could not take the 10 and it was lowered to half that, because … he is 16,” Yule said.

The four had been held since last Wednesday, when members of the Nasa Indigenous Guard apprehended them in the mountains near Toribio with rifles and explosives.

The trial is the latest chapter in Colombia’s half-century old internal struggle.

Many Colombians have felt far removed from the armed conflict between the government and the FARC.  In truth, much of the violence plays out in remote regions, having the greatest impact on the most marginalized members of society.

At least 33 indigenous people have been murdered this year in Colombia, compared with 118 in all of 2011 with Nasa Indians of the southwestern province of Cauca accounting for the largest number of fatalities.

When Nasa Indians stormed a military communications base in the southwest province of Cauca late last week, the reality of the fighting was again brought to the forefront.

President Juan Manuel Santos, feeling the political ramifications of the Nasa’s actions, alleges that some of the 115,000 Nasa are allied with rebels of the leftist FARC, which authorities say purchases the high-quality marijuana that many indigenous grow.  On July 18, President Santos released an intercepted email supposedly written in May by a local FARC commander, which called for the “spread of propaganda in the municipalities of northern Cauca so that locals demand the withdrawal of security forces.”

Contradicting the government’s characterization of the protestors is the fact that they seem to be staying true to their stated desire to rid Toribio of all armed actors, legal or not. In addition to the recent trial and sentencing of the four FARC rebels, demonstrators claim to have dismantled a FARC campsite in the area.

For further information, please see:

Fox News Latino – Indigenous Leader Slain in Colombia – 24 July 2012

In Sight – Questioning Ties Between Colombia Indigenous and FARC Rebels – 23 July 2012

Al Jazeera – ‘FARC rebels’ flogged by Colombian tribe – 22 July 2012

Fox News Latino – Colombian Indigenous Court Sentences Rebels to Flogging – 22 July 2012

The Miami Herald – Indian upheaval bares Colombia’s nagging conflict – 21 July 2012