Saudi Justice Ministry Denies Paralysis Punishment

By Dylan Takores
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia – The Saudi Arabian Justice Ministry denied a report that an incarcerated man was sentenced to receive paralysis as punishment for stabbing and paralyzing his victim.

Mock Execution in Saudi Arabia (Photo Courtesy of Reuters)

The Saudi Arabian justice system is well known for its strict adherence to Islamist sharia law.  One form of punishment under the system is qesas, “the principle of Islamic law allowing victims analogous retribution for violent crimes.”  In other words: an-eye-for-an-eye retaliation.

Judges in the Saudi system interpret the law and order sentences at their own discretion.  Capital punishment, public flogging, and amputation are common forms of punishment.  In the past, judges have ordered eye-gouging and tooth extraction as well.

Ali al-Khawaher, 24, was incarcerated for stabbing a man ten years ago, resulting in the victim’s paralysis.  Reports surfaced that the Saudi court ordered al-Khawaher to have his spinal cord severed, rendering him paralyzed, as punishment for his crime unless he pays one million Saudi riyals (US $270,000) in compensation to the victim.

Ann Harrison of Amnesty International stated that paralysis as a means of punishment is tantamount to torture.  She further condemned Saudi Arabia’s general lack of adherence to international legal obligations by failing to remove such punishments from its legal system.  “That such a punishment may be implemented is utterly shocking, even in a context where flogging is frequently imposed as a punishment for some offenses, as happens in Saudi Arabia.”

Amnesty International frequently speaks out against the extreme forms of punishment carried out in Saudi Arabia and other countries that follow sharia law.  In 2011, an Iranian court sentenced a man to be blinded after he threw acid in a woman’s face.  Amnesty lobbied against the punishment, and his sentence was postponed and ultimately pardoned by the victim.

Britain’s Foreign Office joined Amnesty in its criticism of the alleged sentence.  A spokesman described the sentence as “grotesque,” and argued that such a punishment is prohibited under international law.

However, despite the reports that incited the humanitarian uproar, the Saudi Arabian Justice Ministry denied the issuance any such sentence.  A Ministry spokesman stated that the reports were “utterly incorrect.”  The spokesman explained that the judge dismissed the demand for an-eye-for-an-eye retribution.  Though the Ministry denied that al-Khawaher was sentenced to paralysis, the statement did not specify what punishment the judge did order.

Saudi Arabia and Iran are perhaps the most well known countries that apply strict sharia law, but Kuwait, Bahrain, Yemen, and the UAE contain elements of sharia law in their respective legal systems as well.

 

For further information, please see:

BBC – Saudi Arabia denies paralysis punishment – 9 April 2013

IBT – Saudi Arabia: Justice Ministry Denies Paralysis Sentence, Says Judge ‘Shied Away’ from Retribution Punishment – 9 April 2013

Time – Saudi Arabia Denied Report of Man Sentenced to be Surgically Paralyzed – 9 April 2013

Amnesty International – Saudi Arabia: News of paralysis sentence ‘outrageous’ – 2 April 2013

Syrian Revolution Digest: Monday, 8 April 2013

Prediction!

Whether by design or not, external players are indeed doing just enough to maintain a state of stalemate in Syria. Syrians will not be allowed to solve their problems until these players solve theirs. It’s not the Islamists who are hijacking the revolution: Islamists, loyalists, secularists, Alawites, tribalists, even nonviolence activists, all now are but instruments of implementation of agendas that they do not control or even want. This revolution has been hijacked by the usual powers-that-be. Failure to draw clear redlines in the first months, allowed for a protest movement to turn into an armed uprising, failure to create a no-fly zone allowed for the armed uprising to pave the way for a civil war, civil wars encourage external dabbling, transforming the conflict into a proxy war. Proxy wars can only be resolved through an international consensus, which usually takes years to be reached. Meanwhile, the seesaw of stalemate grinds on, with rebels pushing and Assadists pushing back. 


News

All Syria chemical arms claims must be probed: U.N.’s Ban

Syria rejects U.N. chemical weapons inspectors as proposed by Ban

‘Chemical weapons were used on Homs’: Syria’s military police defector tells of nerve gas attack: General becomes one of the most senior officers to join the rebels.

Ex-US soldier who ‘fought in Syria’ could face execution

Syrian rights group: Nearly 9,000 regime fighters killed since 2011

Video: The Bombing of Al-Bara

Video: Inside Syrian Rebel Group Northern Storm

Special Reports

Have Syria’s Kurds Had a Change of Heart? Reports indicate that YPG militiamen and Syrian rebels have agreed to share control of the strategic Sheikh Maqsood District of northern Aleppo, cutting off regime supply routes to a hospital, prison, and other key positions. Rebel fighters entered the district largely unopposed on March 31. On April 6, the Syrian military bombarded Kurdish neighborhoods in northern Aleppo, killing 15 people in a likely response to this new arrangement. The following day, Kurdish militiamen attacked a Syrian military checkpoint in the city, killing five troops.

Mistrust mars deal between Syria rebels and Kurdish fighters under the surface, feelings of mutual suspicion run deep. Dozens of men wearing the Kurdish YPG militia uniform – distinct for its yellow star symbol on a red background – stand at a checkpoint. They are visibly more disciplined and organized than the FSA in Aleppo, most of whose checkpoints are manned by young, shabbily dressed fighters. A YPG commander says the Kurds’ priority is self-defense. “We are here to protect our people and residents of Sheikh Maqsoud, where the PYD has been present for years,” he says. “Some FSA rebels are respectable, but others are here just to steal. They break into company premises and loot stuff,” adds the Kurdish commander. Because of this, the fighters are well spread out in Sheikh Maqsoud. Arab rebels keep a lookout in residential areas of the district, while the YPG is responsible for the industrial part.

Despite U.S. concerns, little prevents Islamists from joining Syria fight The foreign fighters would be hard to miss for Turkish and Western intelligence operatives – they stay at established safe houses, openly recruit comrades and often stand out with distinctive appearances and habits – yet there’s been no overt effort to crack down on their presence in frontier towns. “Even with this growing jihadist threat, there’s a reluctance to do anything more proactive on Syria,” said Elizabeth O’Bagy, an analyst with the Institute for the Study of War who recently spent two weeks traveling with rebels in Syria, where she encountered Tunisian, Moroccan and Algerian fighters, she said. That observation was similar to what a McClatchy reporter witnessed during a recent trip to Syria, where he saw Egyptians and Libyans, as well as other nationalities, among rebel fighters. “The pipelines are still open and fighters are coming in quite freely,” O’Bagy said.

A Close-Up Of Syria’s Alawites, Loyalists Of A Troubled Regime Alawites might not have it good now, Hassan says, but they think it would be even worse if Assad were to fall. “There is a big group that believes that it’s their life, their survival,” he says. “There is also a group who almost make him a divine figure that will provide protection.” What the people of Tartous don’t realize, Hassan says, is that the regime is just using this sectarian promise of protection as a way to maintain its own power. He says Alawites are now trapped by fear — a fear that’s allowed them to go from oppressed to oppressors. Most of those who lead the government’s army and security forces — soldiers responsible for thousands of deaths in Syria — are Alawites.

In Syria, Follow the Money to Find the Roots of the Revolt: Economic liberalization without political reform to spread that wealth triggered the civil war, writes Majid Rafizadeh. The regime and the gilded circle of al-Assad, like those of Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, Zein Al-Abedin Ben Ali of Tunisia, and Ali Abdullah Saleh of Yemen, did gain short-term benefits in terms of wealth and capital accumulation from their privatizations and neoliberal policies—all without any of this wealth ever reaching the vast majority of the population. The flaw was that they neglected equality and distribution, political liberalization, without the foresight to realize what the eventual consequence of this imbalance of riches would be.

Were chemical weapons used in Syria? UN team poised for probe: Syrian President Bashar al-Assad called for a chemical-weapons investigation of an alleged March 19 attack, but he’s apparently gotten cold feet. Here’s why. Mr. Assad wants the UN investigators to limit themselves to one reported attack March 19 in a village outside Aleppo, Syria’s largest city and a northern stronghold of the rebellion. But the opposition, backed by Britain and France, insists that the team look into all alleged incidents of chemical-weapons use in Syria, including two attacks elsewhere on March 19 and another case from last December in Homs.

My new paper, prepared for a briefing in Washington, D.C. that took place on January 15, 2013, is now out and is titled “Syria 2013: Rise of the Warlords.” It should be read in conjunction with my previous briefing “The Shredded Tapestry,” and my recent essay “The Creation of an Unbridgeable Divide.

 

Video Highlights

Scenes from the suicide car bomb attack in the Seven Fountains Square in Damascus City http://youtu.be/BtonWc_BLYg , http://youtu.be/CnFzc6puHaI

Scenes of devastation from the aftermath of an aerial raid on the Sukkari Neighborhood in Aleppo City http://youtu.be/pOXTYpOc5-o

I’ll leave to experts to say whether this video is authentic or not, but it is currently being posted on Facebook and Twitter, and some activists are finding it a proof that the regime was behind the assassination of the Islamic Scholar Ramadan Al-Bouti. The video purports to show Al-Bouti at a time when the explosion took place http://youtu.be/XFGwwRQINvg

Two years have elapsed since the beginning of the revolution, but pro-Assad militias keep torturing their captives in the most inhumane manner http://youtu.be/gHJM1BNfvag And we see them torturing a defector by hoisting him from a tank muzzle http://youtu.be/u0r0c9BmQAI

Islamist rebels in the town of Mayadeen, Deir Ezzor Province, capture three locals accusing them of perpetrating thefts while claiming to be members of the Free Syrian Army. Summary justice imposed by Sharia courts is the way many rebels groups are using to  keep law and order in place under their control http://youtu.be/9MFK-CNdKD0

Syrian American activist Aref Agha pays a visit to injured FSA founder Col. Riyad Al-Assaad. The colonel lost a leg in an attempt on his life in the town of Mayadeen, and is currently being hospitalized in Turkey http://youtu.be/4GgVlF6qZBs

The pounding of Deir Ezzor City continues http://youtu.be/x3Y0J1hgct8 , http://youtu.be/2v7lrcfsjSI , http://youtu.be/9SXHd7QjeFw , http://youtu.be/NhmWLXfiIJM

Intense clashes continue to take place in and around the village of Abel, Homs Province http://youtu.be/4hnvPxGHtSI , http://youtu.be/FFW_AVLLMm0 , http://youtu.be/ZwKaMh7tcqs , http://youtu.be/h7Dk3VCl5k4

UNRWA Reopens Food Centers in Gaza

By Dylan Takores
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

JERUSALEM, Israel – The United Nations Relief and Work Agency (UNRWA) reopened its food distribution centers in the Gaza Strip after Palestinian leaders assured the safety of Agency workers.

Sit-in at UNRWA Gaza center. (Photo Courtesy of AFP)

The UNRWA operates several centers in the Gaza Strip that provide food and humanitarian relief to approximately 800,000 impoverished Palestinians refugees.  However, protests that began on April 4 forced the Agency to temporarily shut down operations in an effort to protect the safety of its workers.

Hundreds of Palestinian refugees staged protests outside the centers following an announcement that program funds will be severely cut back.  The UNRWA explained that it can no longer afford to provide cash assistance to some 21,000 families in Gaza while still operating educational facilities.

The Agency struggles with a $67.2 million deficit in funding.  Rising costs in education and increased enrollment place further pressure on the already strained Agency budget.  Robert Turner, the UNRWA’s head of operations in Gaza, defended the Agency’s decision in a statement to IRIN: “There was simply no way to continue the cash program and also continue to provide high-quality education.”

The UNRWA refused to reopen its facilities until the safety of its workers was guaranteed.  Agency spokesman Chris Gunness stated that the Agency understands the frustration and pressure placed on the Palestinian people as a result of heightened Israeli blockades.  However, “UNRWA must ensure the safety and security of its staff.”

Violent protests ensued after the UNRWA’s announcement, but Gunness said that the Agency decided to reopen its facilities because “different local parties” assured that the property and its workers will not be harmed.  Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri condemned the violence against the Agency, but also described the closure as unjustified.

Hamas deployed police at Agency centers to prevent a resurgence of violence.  Abu Zuhri told a local media station, “We are providing appropriate conditions for UNRWA’s work.”  The Agency regretted that it was forced to close operations, but stated that if its workers are further endangered, it will shut down operations once again.

The cutback will save the Agency approximately $5.5 million per year.  In return, the Agency will offer job programs to the most poor and needy families in Gaza.

 

For further information, please see:

BBC – UN reopens Gaza food centres after compound attack – 9 April 2013

IRIN – UN reopens food distribution centers in Gaza – 9 April 2013

The Jordan Times – UN reopens Gaza food distribution centers – 8 April 2013

Ynet – UN agency reopens Gaza food distribution centers – 8 April 2013

Zambian Gay Rights Activist Arrested for Incitement

By Hannah Stewart
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

LUSAKA, Zambia — Paul Kasonkomona, a prominent gay and lesbian rights activist was arrested in Zambia after appearing on a live television calling for same-sex relations to be decriminalized.  He has been charged with “inciting the public to take part in indecent activities.”

Kasonkomona remains detained as police await further instructions. (Photograph Courtesy of Muvi Television)

Reports state that the police tried to stop the interview and take Kasonkomona off-air, but the producers and station management refused.  Plainclothes policemen apprehended Kasonkomona as he attempted to leave the station with colleagues, including a lawyer.  Muvi TV reports that Kasonkomona was transported to Woodlands Police Station for interrogation.

Homosexual acts are still illegal in Zambia, a traditionally conservative nation where many people believe that homosexuality violates their religious beliefs.

Offenses such as sodomy, or sex between women, carry a minimum sentence of 15 years or a maximum of life.  Specifically the Zambian Penal Code states that, “any person who has carnal knowledge of any person against the order of nature . . .  commits a felony” and can be imprisoned “for a term not less than 15 years and may be liable to imprisonment for life.”

Moreover, “any male who, whether in public or private, commits any act of gross indecency with a male . . . commits a felony and is liable, upon conviction, to imprisonment for a term not less than seven years and not exceeding 14 years.”

Kasonkomona, who calls himself a human rights activist, has called upon the government factions to harmonize their obligations and to protect gay rights.  As such, he has said that LGBTQ rights are like any other form of human rights, which should be respected at all cost

A group of same-sex couples attempted to register their marriages in Lusaka last week, but they were stopped by authorities and threatened with arrest.  However, the European Union last month offered financial support for organizations that seek to promote the rights of gay people in Zambia

For more information, please see:

All Africa – Zambia: Gay Rights Activist Arrested at Muvi TV – 8 April 2013

BBC – Zambia Gay Rights Activist Paul Kasonkomona Arrested – 8 April 2013

Digital Journal – Zambia Gay Rights Activist Arrested – 8 April 2013

The Global Post – Zambia Gay Rights Activist Arrested – 8 April 2013