Africa

Judge Adjourns Bennett’s Trial for Torture Determination

By Jennifer M. Haralambides
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

HARARE, Zimbabwe – The trial of a Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s senior aide was adjourned in the Harare High Court on today so the judge could deliberate the admissibility of evidence that was allegedly gathered through torture.

The state’s key witness, Peter Michael Hitschmann, who was convicted of the illegal possession of weapons in 2007, alleges that he was tortured into implicating Bennett in the coup plot.  Bennett’s lawyers claim the state is insistent upon using the statements made by Hitschmann in order to show that Bennett planned to overthrow President Robert Mugabe.

Hitschmann was arrested in 2006 and initially accused of plotting to assassinate Mugabe.  Bennett had not been linked to the case until his arrest this past February.

The charges Bennett faces are for “possessing weapons for the purpose of terrorism.”  They carry a possible death sentence or life imprisonment if convicted.

Mugabe’s Zanu-PF party leaders deny any accusations of torture, saying it should be left to the judge to determine the merits of Bennett’s case.  Sources also say that Bennett has been a thorn in the side of Mugabe’s Zanu-PF party for some time.

Beatrice Mtetwa, Bennett’s defense attorney, said that Bennett “cannot have a fair trial if false, inadmissible and no[n] existent evidence is smuggled into the court.”

He [Hitschmann] has disowned that statement and does not want to testify for the state,” she added.

This trial comes at a critical time for the country because the Southern African Development Community has instructed Mugabe and Tsvangirai to resolve their differences with in the next 30 days.

Lovemore Matombo, the president of the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Union, and another Mugabe critic, was also arrested Sunday night while addressing local union members.  Other local union leaders and national staff members were also arrested.

Tsvangirai’s party, The Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), has called the prosecution of Bennett a “malicious prosecution” which caused the party to temporarily withdraw from the unity government with Mugabe last month.

The judge is expected to make his ruling on the admissibility of the evidence on Wednesday.

For more information, please see:

Aljazeera – Tsvangirai Aide’s Trial Adjourned – 9 November 2009

AFP – Zimbabwe Lawyer: Witness Tortured in Weapons Trial – 9 November 2009

AP – Trial for Top Zimbabwean PM’s Aide Gets Under Way – 9 November 2009

CNN – Mugabe Opponent Bennett’s Trial Adjourned – 9 November 2009

Daily Nation – Zimbabwe Minister’s Trial Begins – 9 November 2009

DR Congo Army Attacks Civilians at Measles Vaccination Site

By Jennifer M. Haralambides
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

DR Congo – The Congolese army attacked villages where civilians gathered to receive measles vaccinations.

The aid agency Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) denounced the attacks in North Kivu as “an abuse of humanitarian action.”  Thousands of civilians were attacked when they visited sites set up specifically to combat a measles epidemic.  The clinics were set up in order to provide the vaccine to workers otherwise unable to access regions controlled by the Hutu Rebels.

The aid agency said the clinics were targeted despite the security guarantees surrounding the aid camps.  Now MSF fears the ramifications of this attack will affect future attempts to immunize the public.  The targeting of civilians has been a major concern for charities operating in the region.  United Nations (UN) support for the government has been dependent on it respecting the neutrality of civilians.

“We feel we were used as bait . . . . How will MSF be perceived by the population now?  Will our patients still feel safe enough to come for medical care?” Said Luis Encinas, head of MSF programs in Central Africa.

The UN army has been helping the Congolese government in the offensive against Rwandan rebels since January 2009.  Now, the Congolese government says the military operations have been suspended to allow for a UN inquiry into the allegations that Congolese soldiers were responsible for killing civilians.

A military spokesman for the Congo’s UN mission said the government was unaware of the incident.

The leaders of the rebel group, the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR), fled to the area in 1994 after being accused of taking part in Rwanda’s genocide and have since been fighting with the local Tutsi population.  There have also been reports that more than 7,000 women and girls have been raped and more than 900,000 people forced to flee their homes.

For more information, please see:

BBC – DR Congo Army “Used Aid as Bait” – 6 Friday 2009

Reuters – Congo Army Attacked Measle Vaccine Sites-Aid Agency – 6 November 2009

VOA – Thousand Flee Ethnic Violence in Northern DRC – 6 November 2009

Youth Recruitment in Somalia

By Kylie M Tsudama
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

MOGADISHU, Somalia – The Kenyan government has been accused of secretly recruiting and training youths from the north eastern region to fight for the Somali transition government against al-Shabaab.

The al-Shabaab militant group in Somalia has accused Kenyan leadership of secret recruitment of fighters amongst young Kenyan Somalis to fight the Islamist movement.  al-Shabaab Islamic administration representative Sheikh Hassan Yaqub said Kenya’s north eastern region members of parliament (MPs) are responsible for the recruitment.

“Somali MPs in Kenyan parliament are responsible for recruitment of fighters in Kenyan border towns and we are warning them,” said Yaqub.

In the last three weeks at least 200 Kenyans of Somali origin have been recruited.

Habiba Kosar, one of many parents speaking out, said her 18-year-old son is being trained in a Kenyan government security facility.

“My son was picked in the middle of the night.  He is being trained for Somalia.  We have never seen Somalia and have no connection with the country.  I just want my son back,” she said.

Parents in Kenya have petitioned the government and local leaders for return of their children.

“The parents are claiming that their sons are [being] secretly smuggled out of the town in the name of army recruitment.  It is shocking to hear that [the] Kenyan government has indulged itself in such activities which can cause [this] region great concerns,” said Mayor Mohammed Gabow of Garissa town, headquarters of Kenya’s north eastern province.

Gabow accused the government of luring young men with large sums of money because of the rampant unemployment.

Both the Kenyan and Somali transitional government deny these claims.

“This is cheap propaganda disseminated by some militia groups in Somalia,” said a spokesman.  “What I am aware of is that the Kenya government and, by extension the Kenya police, has been, and will continue to be, training Somali youths to serve as policemen in their country.”

Kenyan authorities are accused of directly supporting the recruitment drive.

Escaped recruit Sharmarke Abdi said he escaped after two weeks of training alongside hundreds of Kenyan and Somali youths.

“We were told that the United Nations was supporting the recruitment.  We were transported in government vehicles.  We began training immediately.  Some of the trainers were from Somalia,” he said.

Conflict in Somalia continues as Islamist fighters and transitional government troops keep fighting.  Most recently, two have been killed and five others injured after heavy fighting with bitter shelling.  Islamists are fighting in favor of converting to an Islamic state while the current President is heading a transitional government.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera – Youth Lured to Fight in Somalia – 07 November 2009

All Africa – Somalia: Fighting Kills Two, Wounds Five Others in North Mogadishu – 07 November 2009

Garowe Online – Somalia: Al-Shabaab Accuses Kenyan MPs Over Youth Recruitment – 07 November 2009

Impunity Watch – Kenya Recruiting Soldiers in Somalia – 25 October 2009

ICC Claims Strong Cases in Kenyan Post-Election Violence

By Kylie M Tsudama
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

NAIROBI, Kenya – Luis Moreno Ocampo, chief prosecutor for the international Criminal Court (ICC) announced that he would bring two to three post-election violence cases to trial by next July.

Ocampo has said that he has a “strong case” against some for crimes committed during the 2007 post-election violence.  He believes speed is of utmost importance so Kenya does not experience the same type of violence during its next election in 2012.

“Everyone is worried about the next election in Kenya in 2012.  That is why I understand the importance of speed,” Ocampo said.  “I’ll go to the communities.  I”ll see the victims, listen to them.  I have to collect the evidence.  Then I’ll present my case.  Then the names will be known.  In the meantime, my duty is to make criminal records ready- who gave orders to kill.  That’s it.”

President Mwai Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga met with Ocampo and he told them that he would be asking the ICC’s pretrial judges for permission to launch an investigation in December.

In October, former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan, acting as crisis mediator, warned that there was a serious risk of violence at the next presidential election if the killings were not prosecuted.

Today, Prime Minister Odinga said that he would surrender to the ICC if Ocampo built a strong case linking him to the violence.

“I will not wait to be arrested.  I will volunteer information,” he said.

Ocampo made the decision to proceed unilaterally because the Kenyan government decided not to refer the case to the ICC.

“President Kibaki and I agreed that the prosecutor should proceed with his work and Kenya would cooperate.  We also didn’t want to show that our judicial system had failed,” said Odinga.  That’s why Kenya did not make a formal referral of the case to the ICC.

Odinga also said that the Kenyan government would fully cooperate with Prosecutor Ocampo.

“President Kibaki and I agreed that the prosecutor should proceed with his work and Kenya would cooperate.  We also didn’t want to show that our judicial system had failed,” said Odinga.  That’s why Kenya did not make a formal referral of the case to the ICC.

The current Kenyan government operates as a power-sharing entity between the Prime Minister and the President.  Both President Kibaki and Prime Minister Odinga have agreed to cooperate with any trials, although they remain committed to “local judicial mechanisms.”

“My mandate is to end impunity of the most serious crimes,” says Ocampo.  “I will do that.”

For more information, please see:

Daily Nation – Raila Assures ICC of Kenya’s Support – 08 November 2009

Al Jazeera – Ocampo to Request Kenya Trials – 07 November 2009

BBC – ICC Seeking Speedy Kenya Trials – 07 November 2009

Reuters India – ICC’s Ocampo Says Has Strong Case in Kenya – 07 November 2009

Taylor Accuses Prosecution of Misleading the Court

By Jonathan Ambaye
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa Desk

THE HAGUE, Netherlands-On Monday, November 2, 2009, Charles Taylor’s trial, for his alleged role in serious international crimes committed by Sierra Leone rebels during the country’s civil war, resumed. On this day, Charles Taylor gave testimony accusing the prosecution of misleading the Special Court for Sierra Leone. This accusation came as a result of the prosecution introducing evidence that when Taylor was Liberia’s President, he acted as a mediator between divided Sierra Leonean rebel commanders, and that he further was involved in appointing rebel leaders and providing his country as a safe haven to rebels on “the run”.

The evidence came in the form of testimony by Vamunya Sherif, a former Deputy Director of Operations in the Liberian Secret Service during Taylor’’s presidency. In January of 2008, Sherif testified that Taylor played a role as a meditator between two senior rebel commanders of Sierra Leone’s Revolutionary Front (RUF), Issa Sesay and Sam Bockarie. According to Sherif’s testimony, Taylor invited the two commanders to Liberia with the intent to help them resolve their conflict. It is alleged by Sheriff, that during this time Taylor appointed Sesay as the leader of the RUF in place of Sam Bockarie. Sherif concluded his testimony alleging that subsequent to the leadership change, Bockarie fled to Liberia where he sought a safe haven.

In response to this testimony, Taylor dismissed Sherif’s testimony as “lies”.  Taylor went on to say, “No such situation occurred where I sent for Sam Bockarie and Issa Sesay to discuss a conflict between them that will lead to the departure of Bockarie.” In additional response to the prosecutions introduction of the evidence Taylor said “the prosecution knows that no such meeting took place because they have gone through major documents that tell how Bockarie left Sierra Leone, so for them to ask that question when they know that no such meeting too place is sinister, and the prosecution misled the court.”

Taylor went on to refute other claims made by Sherif that included linking arms and ammunition exchanges between Bockarie and Liberia. For the past week Taylor has had to respond to testimonies by the prosecution’s witnesses regarding his relationship with RUF commander Bockarie. Taylor has adamantly denied many of these allegations.

For more information please see:

All Africa – Charles Taylor Accuses Prosecution of “Misleading” The Special Court for Sierra Leone – 2 November 2009

Charles Taylor Trial – Charles Taylor Accuses Prosecution of “Misleading” The Special Court for Sierra Leone – 2 November 2009

Charles Taylor Trial – Charles Taylor and Sam Bockarie Did Not Have Master Servant Relationship – 29 October 2009