Africa

Taylor Accuses Prosecution of Misleading the Court

By Jonathan Ambaye
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa Desk

THE HAGUE, Netherlands-On Monday, November 2, 2009, Charles Taylor’s trial, for his alleged role in serious international crimes committed by Sierra Leone rebels during the country’s civil war, resumed. On this day, Charles Taylor gave testimony accusing the prosecution of misleading the Special Court for Sierra Leone. This accusation came as a result of the prosecution introducing evidence that when Taylor was Liberia’s President, he acted as a mediator between divided Sierra Leonean rebel commanders, and that he further was involved in appointing rebel leaders and providing his country as a safe haven to rebels on “the run”.

The evidence came in the form of testimony by Vamunya Sherif, a former Deputy Director of Operations in the Liberian Secret Service during Taylor’’s presidency. In January of 2008, Sherif testified that Taylor played a role as a meditator between two senior rebel commanders of Sierra Leone’s Revolutionary Front (RUF), Issa Sesay and Sam Bockarie. According to Sherif’s testimony, Taylor invited the two commanders to Liberia with the intent to help them resolve their conflict. It is alleged by Sheriff, that during this time Taylor appointed Sesay as the leader of the RUF in place of Sam Bockarie. Sherif concluded his testimony alleging that subsequent to the leadership change, Bockarie fled to Liberia where he sought a safe haven.

In response to this testimony, Taylor dismissed Sherif’s testimony as “lies”.  Taylor went on to say, “No such situation occurred where I sent for Sam Bockarie and Issa Sesay to discuss a conflict between them that will lead to the departure of Bockarie.” In additional response to the prosecutions introduction of the evidence Taylor said “the prosecution knows that no such meeting took place because they have gone through major documents that tell how Bockarie left Sierra Leone, so for them to ask that question when they know that no such meeting too place is sinister, and the prosecution misled the court.”

Taylor went on to refute other claims made by Sherif that included linking arms and ammunition exchanges between Bockarie and Liberia. For the past week Taylor has had to respond to testimonies by the prosecution’s witnesses regarding his relationship with RUF commander Bockarie. Taylor has adamantly denied many of these allegations.

For more information please see:

All Africa – Charles Taylor Accuses Prosecution of “Misleading” The Special Court for Sierra Leone – 2 November 2009

Charles Taylor Trial – Charles Taylor Accuses Prosecution of “Misleading” The Special Court for Sierra Leone – 2 November 2009

Charles Taylor Trial – Charles Taylor and Sam Bockarie Did Not Have Master Servant Relationship – 29 October 2009

U.N. Support Suspended to Peacekeeping Unit For Ironic Civilian Killings

By Jared Kleinman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

KINSHASA, DRC – The U.N. has suspended logistical and operational support for the Congolese army’s 213th Brigade which was confirmed to have killed at least 62 civilians during a peacekeeper-backed offensive against the rebel group, the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR).

For months, human rights groups have exposed the fact that Congolese armed forces in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo have brutally killed hundreds of civilians and committed widespread rape, while they received more than $6 million worth of U.N. military and logistical backing for its Kimiya operation.

The UN peacekeeping mission, MONUC, is a partner with the Congolese army in operation Kimia II, which began on March 2. The aim of the peacekeeping mission is to disarm by force the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR), a Rwandan Hutu militia group, some of whose leaders participated in the genocide in Rwanda in 1994. MONUC provides substantial operational and logistics support to the soldiers, including military firepower, transport, rations, and fuel.

Humanitarian agencies and rights groups have decried the civilian toll of the offensive, which has disarmed around 1,300 FDLR fighters at the cost of more than 7,000 women and girls raped and more than 900,000 people forced to flee their homes.

Human Rights Watch conducted 21 fact-finding missions in North and South Kivu from January to October 2009, and found that Congolese army soldiers had deliberately killed at least 505 civilians from the start of operation Kimia II in March through September. Most of the victims were women, children, and the elderly. Some were decapitated. Others were chopped to death by machete, beaten to death with clubs, or shot as they tried to flee.

“Some Congolese army soldiers are committing war crimes by viciously targeting the very people they should be protecting,” said Anneke Van Woudenberg, senior researcher at Human Rights Watch. “MONUC’s continued willingness to provide support for such abusive military operations implicates them in violations of the laws of war.”

“We welcome the steps that the U.N. has taken to suspend operations to this one brigade. But I am afraid we are documenting these kinds of atrocities, not just in this one area but in many other areas as well,” said Van Woudenberg. “And we think the U.N. now needs to immediately suspend all of its support to this military operation until abusive commanders are removed and safeguards are in place in protect civilians.”

Head of the U.N. peacekeeping force in Congo, Alain Le Roy, said despite confirmation of soldiers in the Congolese army’s 213th Brigade participated in the massacre of at least 62 people between May and September, the U.N. has no intention of withdrawing broader support for the offensive.

“(The U.N.) will continue its engagement on the side of the Congolese army in the operation, which is very important in order to neutralize the FDLR.” Said Le Roy. “We have a case [where] clearly some units have behaved badly and some civilians have been killed in quite an important number. But we are not suspending our support to the Kimiya operation, not at all,”

The U.N.’s humanitarian coordinator in Congo and the deputy head of MONUC, Ross Mountain, said that withdrawing the mission’s support for the operations would limit its ability to protect civilians. While admitting that there had been abuses by almost 50,000 government soldiers involved in the operations, Mountain denied claims made by HRW that MONUC had been aware as early as May of the widespread crimes carried out by the army.

The operation, in Congo’s volatile eastern border provinces of North and South Kivu, was part of an agreement aimed at improving relations between Congo and Rwanda, enemies during a 1998-2003 war. The presence in eastern Congo of the FDLR is considered to be a root cause of over a decade of conflict and a humanitarian crisis that has killed an estimated 5.4 million people. Despite suspending some Congolese unites, the U.N. Security Council voted unanimously last month to continue supporting the Congolese army.

For more information, please see:

Reuters – U.N. Defends Congo Role Despite Army Killings – 3 Nov 2009

VOA news – Rights Group Demands U.N. Aid Cut-Off to Congolese Army – 03 November 2009

The Huffington Post – Human Rights Watch Damns MONUC in Congo: Leaked UN Internal Memo Supports the Accusations – 2 November 2009

Amnesty International – Surge in Army Atrocities – U.N. Peacekeeping Force Knowingly Supports Abusive Military Operations – 2 November 2009

British Mercenary Pardoned by Equatorial Guinea President

By Jonathan Ambaye
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa Desk

DAKAR, Senegal-Today the government of Equatorial Guinea announced it had pardoned Simon Mann and four other South Africans who had been imprisoned for a failed attempt to overthrow the country’s President Teodoro Obiang Nguema. In March 2004, a plane from South Africa was impounded by Zimbabwean police. Simon Mann, along with over seventy other mercenaries, was aboard the plane with the intent to pick up weapons and proceed to Equatorial Guinea in order to carry out a coup.

Upon the plane landing the police suspected the mercenaries intentions and instead arrested everyone on board the plane. Mann served four years in a Zimbabwean jail before his extradition to Equatorial Guinea where he was tried, convicted, and sentenced to 34 years in prison for being the author of a plot to carry out a coup.  Simon strongly contended that he was only an accomplice and not the leader of the plot.

On Tuesday, an advisor to Equatorial Guinea President Obiang, Miguel Mifuno said Mann was released on humanitarian grounds. He also said, “Simon Mann conducted himself in an exemplary fashion during his trial and his incarceration in Equatorial Guinea. He has had some health problems. And was operated on. He is now in good health but the President thinks he should now be allowed to live in peace with his family.”

Simon Mann is an alumnus of Britain’s prominent educational institution, Eton College, and comes from a wealthy family of brewers. His involvement in the conspiracy included other Britons including Sir Mark Thatcher, the son of former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. Sir Mark Thatcher had been fined and given a suspended sentence in South Africa in 2005 for unknowingly helping to finance the plot.

Upon Mann’s release, he said he was “delighted” that he would be reunited with his family and that was thrilled at the news.

For more information please see:

All Africa – Government Frees Mercenaries – 3 November 2009
BBC – Pardoned Briton Due For UK Return – 3 November 2009
NY Times – Equatorial Guinea Frees British Mercenary – 3 November 2009
VOA – British Coup Leader Pardoned In West Africa – 3 November 2009

Congolese Army Killed 62 Civilians in DR Congo

By Jennifer M. Haralambides
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

KINSHASA, Democratic Republic of Congo – Due to accusations that the Congolese army killed 62 civilians, the United Nations (UN) has withdrawn its support to the soldiers operating in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).

“[C]ivilians have been clearly targeted in attacks by certain elements of the FARDC (the Armed Forces of the Democratic Republic of Congo),” said UN peacekeeping chief Alain Leroy.

Human Rights activists have persistently said that ethnic Hutus were being killed by the Congolese army.  They have also accused the UN of doing little to stop the killings.

Leroy stated that the peacekeeping mission (Monuc) will “immediately suspend” its logistical and operational support to the army units who are implicated in the killings.

Source say that at least 62 civilians, including women and children, were killed between May and September 2009 in the Nord-Kivu province.

There is currently a UN joint inquiry in the killings being carried out with the Congolese army.  The UN is awaiting the results of the inquiry before any further action.

Human Rights groups have estimated that hundreds of civilians have been killed and thousands of women have been raped by rebels and soldiers since DR Congo and Rwanda launched the joint offensive in January.

The Hutu rebel group has been at the heart of the years of unrest in the region.  They have participated in the massacres of more than 500,000 Tutsis and moderate Hutus.  The UN has been providing logistical assistance to the FARDC since March in their efforts to tackle Rwandan Hutu rebels.

For more information, please see:

AFP – UN Suspends Support for DR Congo Army Over Killings – 2 November 2009

AP – UN: Congolese Army Killed 62 Civilians in E. Congo – 2 November 2009

BBC – UN Drops Congo Army Over Killings – 2 November 2009

Xinhua – DR Congo in Better Situation But Still in Aftermath of Insecurity – 2 November 2009

Reuters –  Lack of U.N. Air Power Endangers Congo Civilians – 1 November 2009

Mugabe Takes a “Sharp Dig” at Tsvangirai

By Jennifer M. Haralambides
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

HARARE, Zimbabwe – Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and President Robert Mugabe continue to verbally combat one another amidst their efforts to work together.

This past Saturday, Mugabe took a “sharp dig” at Tsvangirai and criticized his decision to boycott the country’s Unity Cabinet.  On October 16, Tsvangirai temporarily withdrew from the Cabinet citing a lack of co-operation and human rights abuses by Mugabe and his party as the reason why.

“Even if some person is not mentally stable he is still your partner . . . . We bound ourselves to work together even though we had disparate positions.  We will continue talking, no matter what,” continued Mugabe.

Mugabe, 85 years-old, has ruled Zimbabwe since its independence from Britain in 1980.  Mugabe said that although he disagrees with his former coalition partner, he remains committed to working with his party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), to reform the power-sharing agreement.

While speaking at the funeral of one of his party’s senate members, Mugabe said the MDC party has “one leg in, and one leg out” of the government.

“The requirement is that we indeed continue step-by-step to move together and whatever are the difficulties, become our difficulties together,” he continued.

Mugabe criticizes any external involvement regarding the disengagement of the MDC party from the cabinet.  He says that it is not for outsiders to resolve.  Mugabe also slammed Western countries for misusing their economic power to impose sanctions on his country.  And he announced that Zimbabwe would consider taking the fight against the sanctions tot he international fora.

Political unrest and violence both hover in the horizon as these two leaders try to re-forge a unity government.  In February of this year, the leaders combined to form a unity government.  This occurred after two violence-plagued elections left the country at a political standstill and in economic ruin.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera – Mugabe Criticises MDC Boycott – 31 October 2009

AP – Zimbabwe Pres.: Opposition “Not Mentally Stable” – 31 October 2009

AP – Zimbabwe: Mugabe Takes Sharp Dig at Tsvangirai – 31 October 2009

Xinhua – Zimbabwe’s Political Problems for Zimbabweans to Solve: Mugabe – 31 October 2009