Africa

Justice Is Served As Human Rights Activist and Leader Is Released

By Jared Kleinman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

HARARE, Zimbabwe – Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku issued a permanent stay of prosecution on Monday in the case of the prominent human rights activist Jestina Mukoko and eight other defendants facing charges of plotting to topple President Robert Mugabe’s government. Mukoko had been illegally abducted, beaten, and tortured in jail, by Zimbabwe’s security forces last year. Chidyausiku ruled that Mukoko and her co-accused could not be tried now, or in the future, because their constitutional rights had been violated.

Last year in December Mukoko, the leader of Zimbabwe Peace Project, was abducted from her Norton home in the early hours of the morning, wearing nothing but her night clothes. For weeks police claimed they did not have her in custody, only for the then State Security Minister, Didymus Mutasa, to admit in court papers that he had sanctioned the abductions as a matter of state security. Mukoko spent more than a month in several secret locations where she was tortured by state security agents to force her to confess to an anti-government plot. Her captors accused her of recruiting and attempting to recruit people, including a police officer, to undergo military training in Botswana so they could topple Mugabe’s government.

Monday’s ruling sets a precedent for other human rights and opposition activists who face similar charges and were subjected to the same conditions. They have applied to the same court to have their charges dropped but are awaiting rulings. “This is really a positive thing for activists and civil society but I hope the state will comply with the ruling because in the past they (the state) have re-arrested people on fresh trumped up charges,” John Makumbe, a political analyst and Mugabe critic, said. Innocent Gonese, a member of parliament from Tsvangirai’s party, said the judgment could be “the beginning of good things to come, politically,” but added that scores of other party activists remain jailed or face charges.

The Zimbabwe Peace Project director said she would be going home to rest and thanked everyone who had supported her during her ordeal. Mukoko also vowed to continue her activism work.

For more information, please see:

SW Radio Africa – Terror Charges Dropped Against Mukoko And 8 Others – 28 September 2009

CNN – Zimbabwe court bars activist Mukoko’s prosecution – 28 September 2009

Reuters – Zimbabwe Court Rules Activist Can’t Be Prosecuted – 28 September 2009

AP – Terror charges dropped against Zimbabwe activist – 28 September 2009

Former Mayor Denies Rwanda Genocide Charges

By Jonathan Ambaye
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

ARUSHA, Tanzania – After 15 years of being on the run from Rwandan authorities, former Mayor of the small Rwanda town of Kivumu, Gregoire Ndahimana, was finally arrested this past August.  Much talk has been made about the eventual detainment of a man who is alleged to have been the primary executor of a plan leading to the deaths of 2000 Tutsi’s in a small church in Kivumu, Rwanda.  After fleeing Rwanda for the neighboring country of the DR Congo many in Rwanda feared Ndahimana, and many others involved in the Genocide who also fled to the Congo, would never be brought to justice.

In a surprise move thought to be an encouraging sign of reconciliation between Rwanda and the Congo, the Congolese deported Ndahimana to Arusha, Tanzania where the International Criminal Tribunal of Rwanda is located, and where he will be tried.  Ndahimana’s deportation is hoped to lead to both countries releasing rebels who have fled to each respective country.  The Congolese specifically hope for the transfer of Congolese rebel leader Laurent Nkunda who is believed to be currently under house arrest in Rwanda.

On the verge of trial, Ndahimana claims his innocence and denies any involvement in the genocide and denies all charges brought against him.  As prosecutors continue their investigation and prepare their case, many are hoping new witnesses will step forward. In hopes to encourage the forwarding of information regarding Ndahimana’s case, a five million dollar reward has been offered by the United States, and has yet to be collected.

If Ndahimana is convicted it will be a huge victory for many invested in the situation because he is thought to be one of the last major offenders involved in the 1994 genocide.

For more information, please see:

BBC – Ex Mayor Denies Genocide Charges – 29 September 2009

MSN-UK – Accused Denies 1994 Rwanda Genocide – 28 September 2009

BBC – DR Congo Deports Genocide Suspect – 20 September 2009

Guinea Security Forces Kill 9 During Protest

By Jennifer M. Haralambides

CONAKRY, Guinea – In a rally against Captain Moussa Dadis Camara, security forces violently quelled the crowds, killing at least 9 people.

Junta leader, Captain Moussa Dadis Camara, who took power in a bloodless coup last year, had initially pledged not to run in a presidential election planned for this coming January, although now it looks as though he will run.

Because of this, hundreds of demonstrators joined together to rally against his campaign holding up signs reading “No to Dadis” and “Down with the Army in Power.”  They were quickly dispersed by the military who used tear gas, live ammunition and baton charges to break up the crowds.

“I have counted nine bodies but we have not yet been able to reach the stands in the stadium where there are also some dead,” said Thierno Maadjou Sow, president of the Guinean Human Rights Organization.

Cellou Dalein Diallo and Sidya Toure, two former prime ministers, were injured during the demonstrations and then taken to the Alpha Yaya Diallo camp, which is the headquarters of the junta in power.  Witnesses say that many more prominent opposition leaders were injured and taken into custody during the violence.

The security forces are still in effect and have been setting up roadway checkpoints.

“This is only the beginning of demonstrations and counter-demonstrations we can expect in the next few months,” said Gilles Yabi, a Guinea expert.

The military take-over by Captain Camara had some initial support, although the recent anti-government protests to Camara’s potential run for the presidency show that the tide has shifted.

If Captain Camara stands for president, it will be a violation of the agreement between the military and civil forces which has kept him in power.
For more information, please see:

AFP – At Least 10 Killed at Guinea Demonstration – 28 September 2009

BBC – Protesters Killed in Guinea Rally – 28 September 2009

Reuters – Guinea Forces Kill 9 in Crackdown – Group – 28 September 2009

Taylor Denied More Allegations in Court

By Kylie M Tsudama
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

THE HAGUE, Netherlands – Charles Taylor remains on the stand in the International Criminal Court (ICC) defending his actions during the Sierra Leonean civil war.  He continues to defend himself against the allegations that he armed and supported Sierra Leonean rebels who killed and mutilated thousands.

This week Taylor denied allegations that he ordered an attack by Sierra Leonean rebels on Guinea to oust President Lansana Conte in 2000.

“No I did not, no I did not,” he said.  “We were being attacked by LURD (Liberians United for Reconciliation and Democracy) from Guinea but I was equally busy with other issues that were not war-like.  It was in my best interest to attack Guinea but why not use Liberians for that?”

Taylor also denied having any knowledge of a planned rebel attack on Sierra Leone in 1991 and called those allegations “lies.”  He was responding to allegations brought in 2008 by a prosecution witness who said that Taylor took part in a plan with the RUF (Revolutionary United Front) rebels to invade Sierra Leone.

“It’s a lie,” said Taylor responding to the witness’ account that he saw Taylor and RUF leader Foday Sankoh together in Voinjama, Liberia making plans to attack Sierra Leone.  “I had not even gone from Kakata to Gbangha and so I would not have moved to Voinjama.  There is no way you can get to Voinjama except you go through Gbangha.”  He added, “May be he saw a ghost of someone looking like Charles Taylor, its all a lie.”

Allegations that Taylor gave Sankoh $20,000 as payment for safekeeping diamonds have also been denied.

“If I wanted to send money for Sankoh, I would have done so through the Liberian Foreign Minister who was in Lome,”Taylor said.  “It would have been a good gesture just like Eyadema (former Togolese President) and Obasanjo (former Nigerian President) did give him money, but I did not.”

The trial will resume on Tuesday, as the ICC will be observing a holiday on Monday.

For more information, please see:

CharlesTaylorTrial.org – Taylor Denies Giving Money to Rebel Leader or Safekeeping Diamonds – 24 September 2009

CharlesTaylorTrial.org – ‘I Did Not Know of Any Prior Plans for the Invasion of Sierra Leone in 1991,” Taylor Says – 23 September 2009

CharlesTaylorTrial.org – Taylor Did Not Order the RUF to Attack Guinea – 22 September 2009

International Criminal Court Upholds Charges Against Congolese Militia Leader

By Kylie M Tsudama
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

THE HAGUE, Netherlands – Yesterday the appeal chamber of the International Criminal Court (ICC) ruled to uphold charges against Germain Katanga, commander of a Congolese militia, and a trial against him may proceed.

Earlier this year Katanga challenged the admissibility of the case before the ICC saying that the case should be dropped because he is also under investigation by authorities in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DR Congo).  He argued that the charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity that he faces in the ICC could not be upheld because he is being tried for the same crimes in the DR Congo and the ICC case violated complementarity.  The appeals court chose to uphold the trial court’s decision to hear the case.

“The appeals chamber is convinced that the (trial) court decided rightly that the case against the accused can be heard,” said Judge Daniel Ntanda Nsereko.

DR Congo Justice Minister Emmanuel-Janvier Luzolo and other officials took part in the hearing at the ICC and insisted to the court that all charges in the DR Congo had been dropped.  They believed that the appropriate place to try Katanga was in the ICC.

“The DRC has made it clear that it wished for him to be prosecuted before the ICC,” Nsereko said.

Katanga is the former leader of the Front for Patriotic Resistance of Ituri (FRPI).  He is being tried with fellow defendant Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui, who is the former leader of the Nationalist and Integrationist Front (FNI) rebel group.  They are both facing trial for murder, rape, and other atrocities committed in February 2003 when their forces jointly attacked Bogoro in Ituri, a mineral-rich village in northeastern DR Congo.  Katanga is also accused of using women as sex slaves and enlisting child soldiers.  He faces three counts of crimes against humanity and six counts of war crimes.

The joint trial is set to begin on November 24, a postponement from the original start date of September 24 because of the lost appeal and the prosecution’s need for more time to prepare its 1,000 pages of evidence and witness details.

So far, the ICC has issued four arrest warrants for war crimes in the DR Congo.  The other two men accused are Thomas Lubanga, ex-militia chief who is currently on trial in The Hague, and Bosco Ntaganda who is still at large.

For more information, please see:

AFP – DR Congo Warlord to be Tried at War Crimes Trial – 25 September 2009

ICC – Appeals Chamber Upholds the Decision on the Admissibility of the Case Against Germain Katanga – 25 September 2009

Jurist – ICC Upholds Charges Against Accused DRC Rebel Leader – 25 September 2009

UN News Centre – Trial of Congolese Militia Leader Can Proceed, International Criminal Court Rules – 25 September 2009