Asia

Kyrgyzstan Ethnic War Erupts From Politically Funded Massacres

David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

OSH, Kyrgyzstan – Unmitigated violence, resulting in a significant death toll, has engulfed Kyrgyzstan.   The hostilities stem from a breakdown in government and effective security forces outside of Bishkek which precipitated quickly into a crisis waiting to happen, again. Similar violence was seen 20 years prior in 1990, where more than 300 people died during clashes between Kyrgyz and Uzbeks over land ownership near Osh. Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev was forced to send in troops to quell the violence.

Kyrgyzstan vigilantes rampage government buildings with Crimson Kyrgyz flags in hand
Kyrgyzstan vigilantes rampage government buildings with Crimson Kyrgyz flags

The U.N. has found evidence of bloody intent behind the chaos in Kyrgyzstan, which continues to kill hundreds and leaves the nation’s second-biggest city a smoldering ruin.  Political violence has also sent more than 100,000 ethnic Uzbeks fleeing.  The declaration by the U.N. that the fighting was “orchestrated, targeted and well-planned” – set off by organized groups of gunmen in ski masks – bolsters government claims that hired attackers marauded through Osh, shooting at both Kyrgyz and Uzbeks to inflame old tensions.

Bakiev’s removal from power on April 7 after bloody clashes between police and protesters in the capital, Bishkek, has ignited old grievances between ethnic Kyrgyz and the minority Uzbek population.  Opposition leaders had accused Bakiev of corruption and consolidating power by keeping key economic and security posts in the hands of relatives or close associates.

The focal point of the current violence has been the south of the country, where Bakiev enjoys the bulk of his backing and where his supporters have sought to undermine the provisional administration in Bishkek led by Roza Otunbayeva.

“Well-armed people who were obviously well prepared for this conflict were shooting at us,” said Teymurat Yuldashev, 26, who had bullet wounds of different calibers in his arm and chest. “They were organized, with weapons, militants and snipers. They simply destroyed us.”

Over 200,000 Uzbeks have fled for their lives to neighboring Uzbekistan, and tens of thousands more, most of them women and children, were camped on the Kyrgyz side or stranded behind barbed-wire fences in a no man’s land where reports of rape and brutal beating consumes them.

A state of emergency has been declared in both Osh as well as the city of Jalal-Abad where the violence has now spread, with police given the authority to shoot to kill.

With more than 200,000 ethnic Uzbeks streaming into camps in neighboring Uzbekistan, according to the Uzbek foreign ministry, there has been a prompting to close a number of border crossings and ask for international assistance.

Fears mount as Uzbekistan may be forced to intervene militarily if the death toll across the border continues to climb, leading to further instability in Kyrgyzstan.  Other countries which border Kyrgyzstan, including China, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, will also fear being drawn into the crisis.

Until the new central government has gained legitimacy in all the Kyrgyz Republic’s regions through free and fair elections in October, and equal distribution of land and property it is likely that there will be further unrest and possible deaths.  For its part, the interim government accuses Bakiev and his supporters of orchestrating the violence, a charge he denies.

For more information, please see:

CNN World – Concern over refugees grows as calm falls on Kyrgyzstan – 16 June 2010

Al Jazeera English – Kyrgyzstan toll ‘could be higher – 16 June 2010

The Huffington Post – Kyrgyz Violence: Red Cross Says ‘Several Hundred’ Killed In Ethnic Fighting – 15 June 2010

Taliban Justice? 7 Year old Child Spy Executed

David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter; Asia

KABUL, Afghanistan – The Taliban plague and reign of terror continues amidst the government’s limited ability to regulate and control their activities.  The execution of a 7 year old boy, which has the Taliban thugs being branded internally as “inhuman” allegedly executed the boy after a hurried kangaroo court where the boy, allegedly the grandson of a village elder, was found guilty of being a spy.

Unbridled mayhem worsens as Taliban executes 7 year old kid
Unbridled mayhem worsens as Taliban executes 7 year old kid

The latest episode demonstrates an expression of unbridled authority which has led to a 7 year-old boy’s murder, in what has been regarded to be an apparent act of retribution. The boy had allegedly been providing allied forces with information on Taliban movements.

Daoud Ahmadi, spokesman for the provincial governor of Helmand, said that the killing happened days after the boy’s grandfather, Abdul Woodod Alokozai, spoke out against militants in their home village.  In the past, militants have carried out similar killings of those accused of spying, Ahmadi said.  Three years ago, a 70-year-old woman and a child in the Musa Qala district of the province were executed following the same allegations, he said.

Afghan President Hamid Karzai after looking into reports of the execution, condemned the act if confirmed to be true.  “I don’t think there’s a crime bigger than that that even the most inhuman forces on earth can commit,” Karzai said. “A 7-year-old boy cannot be a spy. A 7-year-old boy cannot be anything but a 7-year-old boy, and therefore hanging or shooting to kill a 7-year-old boy… is a crime against humanity.”

Dawoud Ahmadi, said “The innocent boy was not a spy, but he may have informed the police or soldiers about planted explosives,” Ahmadi told Central Asia Today.  “If this is true, it is an absolutely horrific crime,” added British Prime Minister David Cameron, while on a stop in Kabul. “I think it says more about the Taliban than any book, than any article, than any speech could ever say.”  Ahmadi said: “His grandfather is a tribal elder in the village and the village is under the control of the Taliban. His grandfather said some good things about the government and he formed a small group of people to stand against the Taliban. That’s why the Taliban killed his grandson in revenge.”

Qari Yousef Ahmaid, the Taliban spokesman, denies that any of his militants were involved. “The Taliban’s enemies are the Afghan Government and the foreign forces,” he said. “We never kill children. Everyone knows a seven-year-old can’t be a spy.”

For more information, please see:

CNN World NewsOfficials: Taliban executed boy, 7, for spying – 10 June 2010

London Times – Taleban hang 7-year-old boy to punish family – 11 June 2010

Pattaya Daily News – Taliban Hang 7-Year-Old Allegedly Spying for Allied Forces – 11 June 2010

New York Daily News – Taliban hang 7-year-old boy accused of being a spy – 10 June 2010

Marriage Turned Massacre: Afgan Wedding Bombed

By David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

KANDAHAR, Afghanistan – Weddings, once a sacred ceremony, fall victim to tragedy as the Taliban indiscriminately attacks civilians. On Wednesday, in Afghanistan’s Kandahar’s southern province, 39 people were killed and 73 others were wounded.  The explosion came during a wedding dinner, between 9:30 and 10 p.m., striking the area where the men and boys were dining separately from the women. All the casualties were men or boys, village officials said.

Impunity mounts as Weddings become Targets
Violence mounts as weddings become targets

Toror Yalai Wesa, the governor of Kandahar, told Al Jazeera that a survivor had said a car bomb was the cause of the explosion.  “We don’t have any women casualties. Most of them are adult men and some are young children,” he said.  The man getting married was a policeman from one of the checkpoints in the area, the governor said.  The groom was one of those wounded in the attack, according to his brother, Mohammad Zanif.  “We don’t know what happened.  There was an enormous explosion and as a result everyone there was either killed or injured,” he told AFP.

The International Security Assistance Force confirmed the bombing but had no information on casualties.  They and Afghan forces have secured the area.  It is unclear what caused the blast or why the wedding was targeted.  No one has yet said they planted a device.  Last week, Afghanistan held a national peace council and endorsed a plan to seek peace with the Taliban. But violence has continued unabated.

Relatives of the wounded gathered at an area hospital and local television appealed for people to donate blood to help treat the injured. Local television appealed to people for blood donations to help those injured.  Although the surrounding district is a base for the Taliban, the families at the wedding were not known to have links with the authorities or security forces, AFP reported.

On Monday, Nato’s International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) lost 10 soldiers on its deadliest day in months within what has been a violent week.  In earlier violence on Wednesday, four American Nato soldiers were killed when their helicopter was shot down in neighbouring Helmand province.  The Taliban claimed its fighters had shot down the aircraft with a rocket-propelled grenade in Sangin district.  More than 20 Nato soldiers have died this week.

Kandahar is set to be the next focus of Nato’s military drive against the Taliban.

For more information, please see:

CNN World News – 39 dead in blast at Afghanistan wedding – 9 June 2010

Al Jazeera English – Dozens killed in Afghan wedding – 9 June 2010

BBC News – Afghanistan explosion ‘kills dozens’ in Kandahar – 9 June 2010

Image courtesy of the Washington Post

Taliban suspects will be reviewed and released.

By Kwangmin Ahn
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

KABUL, Afghanistan –Afghan President Hamid Karzai has ordered a review of the cases of every Taliban suspect in the country’s prisons. cThe head of international forces in Afghanistan, General Stanley McChrystal, told the BBC that Mr Karzai had asked “to get sovereignty over all detention operations in Afghanistan and we are working full speed to do that”, with the aim of achieving this by the end of the year.

General McChrystal said Mr. Karzai had asked him to release suspects in cases where evidence was doubtful, or where they did not pose a threat. He added that as Mr. Karzai’s review process took off, he anticipated that international forces would be able to provide “good visibility on the background why a person was detained, rationale for release or continued detention”.

Mr. Karzai’s announcement of prisoner case reviews is the first official response to the national peace conference, which ended on Friday. The conference discussed measures to promote reconciliation, including negotiations with militant factions, and recommended the release of Taliban suspects being held in Afghan police custody and by the US military if they were being held on “inaccurate statements or unsubstantiated allegations”.

Delegates to the conference also urged the Taliban to cut its ties with the al Qaeda terror network and asked that Taliban prisoners be freed from international detention centers. Among other things, the delegates recommended that names of all Taliban members should be removed from blacklists maintained by the United States and United Nations. Those lists contain the names of suspected militants that U.S. authorities and their allies would like to arrest.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera – Afghan officials resign over attack – 06 June 2010

CNN – Afghan officers quit over peace conference attack– 06 June 2010

BBC – President Hamid Karzai orders Afghan prisoner review– 06 June 2010

U.S. Kills Civilians in Drone Strikes over Pakistan and Afghanistan

By David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

WAZIRSTAN, Afghanistan – Nine people were killed one Friday night when a suspected U.S. drone struck North Waziristan, near the border of Pakistan and Afghanistan, according local officials.  The dead consisted of two children, two women and five men, Pakistani intelligence and administrative officials said.  Investigators from the US military have found that “inaccurate and unprofessional” reporting by US operators of a drone was behind a missile strike that killed 23 Afghan civilians in February.”

US crew faulted for drone deaths

(Image courtesy of apakistannews.com)

Four American officers – two described as senior – received formal reprimands over the incident.  Ge.neral Stanley McChrystal, the top US and Nato commander in Afghanistan, called for the Air Force to investigate the actions of the crew involved in the incident.  “Our most important mission here is to protect the Afghan people,” he told reporters.  McChrystal had apologized to Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, shortly after the attack.

“Inadvertently killing or injuring civilians is heartbreaking and undermines their trust and confidence in our mission. We will do all we can to regain that trust.”

Because the drone strikes kill innocent civilians and bystanders along with leaders from far away, they “infuriate the Muslim male”, said Addicott, thus making them more willing to join the movement. The men in Pakistan’s tribal region “view Americans as cowards and weasels”, he added.

The UN says at least 2,412 civilians were killed in the Afghan conflict in 2009 – a 14 per cent increase over the previous year.  Nato and Afghan government forces were responsible for 25 per cent of the deaths and of those, about 60 per cent were due to airstrikes, the UN said in a report published in January.

While using drones to attack what amounts to military targets might not be strictly illegal under existing laws of war, Alston says, because such practices “make it easier to kill without risk to a state’s forces, policymakers and commanders will be tempted to interpret the legal limitations on who can be killed, and under what circumstances, too expansively.” Moreover, Alston says, “Because [drone] operators are based thousands of miles away from the battlefield and undertake operations entirely through computer screens and remote audio feed, there is a risk of developing a ‘PlayStation’ mentality to killing.” Alston recommends that governments should also make public “the number of civilians collaterally killed in a targeted killing operation, and the measures in place to prevent such casualties.”

For more information, please see:

CNN World News – 9 killed in suspected U.S. drone strike in Pakistan – 22 May 2010

IPS News – CIA Drone Operators Oppose Strikes as Helping al Qaeda – 3 June 2010

Al Jazeera English – US crew faulted for drone deaths – 30 May 2010

Image Courtesy of A Pakistan News