South America

Amnesty International calls for justice for victims of paramilitary sexual violence in Colombia

By Paula Buzzi
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

BOGOTA, Colombia — Amnesty International released a new report today demanding more action from the Colombian government and justice for women and girls in Colombia who have been long-time victims of physical and sexual abuse through out the country’s 45-year civil war.

Colombia fails victims of sexual abuse. (Courtesy of Colombia Reports).
Colombia fails victims of sexual abuse. (Courtesy of Colombia Reports).

Despite claims of progress by the Colombia government, Amnesty reports that acts of sexual violence have almost doubled in the past decade. In 2010, the National Institute of Legal Medicine and Forensic Science reported 20,142 cases of sexual crime in Colombia compared to 12,732 cases in 2000. The actual number of sexual crime cases, however, is most likely a much larger number since eight out of ten cases typically go unreported by victims due to fear or shame.

Susan Lee, a director at Amnesty International, stated in the report that women are being used as “trophies of war” and that the issue of sexual violence within the military is being swept under the rug by government officials.

Included in the report were gruesome testimonies of emotional and physical suffering by Colombian women who have fallen victim to rape by paramilitary.

Shirley (name change) came forward in 2008 and told her story “so people would know this sort of thing happens.”  She stated that she was raped continuously by over 35 men for three months in 2005 until she managed to escape. None of the men she identified to authorities, however, are in jail.

“I couldn’t even tell when I was having my period, because I bled all the time. There were so many men,” she stated.

In response, the Colombian government placed Shirley in “safe housing” with other victims and — ironically– her rapists that had left the paramilitary years earlier.

Other testimony include that of women who were raped and tortured for attempting to report crimes of sexual violence to the authorities. According to a victim, although the Office of the Attorney General rehoused her, she was only afforded protection for a year and then kicked out of the protection program.

Obstacles to justice for women of sexual crime include: a lack of political and historical tradition of taking initiative in addressing these crimes, poor judicial training, and the fact that rape is not considered a crime under International law.

Amnesty International is calling for the International Criminal Court to step in and take action if the Colombian authorities continue to make crimes of sexual violence by armed men an invisible issue.

For more information, please see:

Amnesty International – Colombian authorities fail survivors of sexual violence – 21 September 2011

BBC News – Amnesty: Colombian women treated as ‘war trophies’ 21 September 2011

Colombia Reports – Colombia is failing victims of sexual violence: Amnesty International – 21 September 2011

Trust Law – Colombia failing victims of sexual violence- Amnesty – 21 September 2011

Vatican Decision Condemns Chilean Priest – Chilean Government Quick to Follow, Opens Investigation

by Emilee Gaebler
Impunity Watch Reporter – South America 

SANTIAGO, Chile – Archbishop Fernando Karadima was sentenced by the Vatican on March 18, 2011 for his sexual assault of minors.  He was moved into retirement far away from his community, immediately upon the release of the decision.  The Vatican stated he was to spend the remainder of his life in “prayer and penitence” for his actions.

Karadima celebrating mass.  (Photo Courtesy of Media Project)
Karadima celebrating mass. (Photo Courtesy of Media Project)

The 80 year old priest was an influential religious figure in Santiago.  His parishioners were from the upper -class of the city.  Karadima was a leader and mentor to five bishops and dozens of priests.  He was accused by four men  who were former parishioners.  They claimed they were sexually molested by Karadima as young boys, abuse that began over 30 years ago.

The Vatican decision has spurred the Chilean courts into action.  Karadima has not yet been prosecuted criminally for his sexual abuse of children.  A previous investigation was started back in 2010 but was dismissed shortly after for failure to prove misconduct.  The current investigation started once the Vatican decision came out.

Karadima has consistently maintained his innocence, attributing the claims leveled against him to jealousy and the devil.  Recently he has come forward to the judge, hearing his criminal prosecution, with claims that Cardinal Francisco Javier Errázuriz paid more than $1million US to stop publication of a book about Karadima’s abuse of parishoners. 

Other disturbing news surrounding the delayed investigation and prosecution has emerged.  Allegations have been made by Karadima’s lawyer, Juan Pablo Bulnes, that his office was illegally searched by police forces with no legal warrant. 

Bulnes wanted the transcripts of the Vatican trials, which he had refused to turn over and were confiscated in the serach, deemed inadmissible.  However, the Chilean Supreme Court ruled on 7 September that the evidence will be permitted in future trials, despite the controversial manner in which they were obtained.

The actual court proceedings against the priest ended back on July 19 and two months later there has still not been an announced verdict. 

 

For further information, please see;

The Santiago Times – New Scandal Rattles Chile’s Catholic Church – 11 September 2011

The Santiago Times – Controversial Evidence Permitted in High-Profile Sex Abuse Case – 8 September 2011

Vatican Insider – The Karadima Scandal: The Vatican Model of Justice – 1 July 2011

The New York Times – Chilean Priest Found Guilty of Abusing Minors – 18 February 2011

Former Director of Colombia’s Administrative Security Department sentenced to 25 years in prison for ties to paramilitary group and murder

By Paula Buzzi
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America


BOGOTA, Colombia — Former Director of the Administrative Security Department, Jorge Aurelio Norguera, was ordered to pay a fine of $1.9 million and sentenced to 25 years in prison on Wednesday by Colombia’s Supreme Court of Justice for his ties with far right-wing military groups and his involvement in the murder of a human rights worker in 2004.

Jorge Noguera receives stiff prison sentence for paramilitary ties. (Photo Courtesy of Huffington Post).
Jorge Noguera receives stiff prison sentence for paramilitary ties. (Photo Courtesy of Huffington Post).

Noguera, 47, was found guilty of destroying public documents and giving illegal right-wing death squads names of leftist activists, students and labor union leaders so they could be killed. The Supreme Court specifically held Noguera in connection to the murder of Alfredo Correa de Andreis, a prominent sociologist and human rights worker who was shot by assassins belonging to a paramilitary group in 2004.


According to a former senior deputy at Colombia’s Administrative Department of Security (DAS), Noguera helped coordinate Andreis assassination after Andreis had reportedly investigated suspicious activity by the right-wing military.


In addition to his sentencing and fine, Noguera has also been ordered to pay $89,000 in restitution to Andreis’ family. A lawyer for Andreis’ family said public money from DAS had been used for his murder.


Noguera’s sentencing is one of many scandals to come out of Colombia’s Administrative Department of Security (DAS). Several former officials and staffers of DAS have been investigated and accused of illegally wiretapping opposition leaders and judges.


Former President of Colombia, Alvaro Uribe, has also been accused of ordering DAS to wiretap his opponents while he was president. Uribe has denied any involvement with the wiretapping, stating last month “I never gave orders to do anything illegal.”


On Wednesday, Uribe referenced Noguera in a tweeter message stating: “I nominated him because of his résumé and his family. I trusted him; if he transgressed the law, it pains me and I offer apologies to the citizenry.” In a speech regarding Noguera in 2006, Uribe famously stated “I put my hands into fire for him.”


Noguera’s sentencing is the stiffest punishment to have been handed out so far to a member of Uribe’s government.


Director of the Americas for Amnesty International, Susan Lee, says Noguera’s sentencing is a critical move in the right direction for justice in Colombia. She calls for all those responsible for crimes under DAS to be promptly brought to justice.


In 2003, Colombia began a program which offered financial and legal assistance to members of paramilitary groups that voluntarily quit.


For more information, please see:


Ahram – Colombian Ex-Spy Chief Gets Stiff Prison Sentence 15 September 2011


CNN – Colombian Court Sentences Former Spy Chief for Paramilitary Ties – 15 September 2011

NY Times – Ex-Spy Chief of Colombia Is Sentenced to Prison – 14 September 2011

The Huffington Post – Jorge Noguera, Colombia’s Domestic Intelligence Chief, Convicted Of Criminal Conspiracy – 14 September 2011

Venezuela’s Presidential Elections Moved Forwards Possibly Assuring Chavez Re-election

by Emilee Gaebler
Impunity Watch Rep0rter, South America

CARACAS, Venezuela – Election changes have just been announced in Venezuela by Tibisay Lucena, the president of the National Electoral Council.  Presidential elections traditionally take place in December of election years.  In the upcoming 2012 election year, the Venezuelan Presidential election has been moved up to October 7.

Tibisay Lucena announces the election date changes.  (Photo Courtesy of El Universal)
Tibisay Lucena announces the election date changes. (Photo Courtesy of El Universal)

President Chavez tweeted, “7 October 2012: your destiny is written! We will write another revolutionary victory on your page! We will live and we will conquer!” as a response to this announcement.

Chavez, who announced his intention to run for re-election earlier, will be up for a third term in office and a victory will place him in power of Venezuela for a consecutive 18 years.  In 2007, Chavez attempted to modify the Constitution, which he had drafted, to allow him to run for re-election for a  third term.  This move was unsuccessful. 

Again, in 2009, Chavez sought to strike down term limits and amend the Constitution.  This move was highly controversial as it was noted that Constitutional amendments are only permissible once per congressional term.  Despite the reservations of this being an unconstitutional act, Chavez was successful, paving the way for his upcoming 2012 campaign. 

Earlier this summer, in June, Chavez announced that he was battling cancer.  On June 20 he had a tumor removed in Cuba and since then has undergone multiple rounds of chemotherapy.  He announced Tuesday that he will start a final round of chemotherapy soon.  He expects to be at full strength when he begins campaigning in December. 

Approval ratings for Chavez stood at 70% at his 2006 re-election.  Current polls place his ratings at roughly 50%.  Opposition parties point out that moving the election date forward makes it harder for other candidates to successfully challenge Chavez.  They note that this is a particularly opportune time for rival parties due to the President’s weakened position.

Instead of receiving a full year in which to campaign, the candidates will only get eight months to mount a successful opposition.  MercoPress reports that political analyst Luis Vicente Leon believes shortening the campaign period will favor Chavez because an effective opposition needs to spend extensive time traveling around the country, meeting people and gathering support.  Additionally, Chavez’s unlimited access to broadcast hours makes him the most recognizable politician in the Venezuelan arena.

The National Electoral Council is justifying their decision by citing a need to separate national from regional and local elections.  Regional and local elections of governors will still take place in December.  Tibisay Lucena claims this division is to benefit voters, so they can focus on each election, instead of having the Presidential race overshadow the others.

 

For more information, please see;

Americas Quarterly – Date Set for Venezuela’s 2012 Presidential Election – 14 September 2011

El Universal – Venezuelan Electoral Body Decides to Separate Elections – 14 September 2011

Latin American Herald Tribune – Venezuela Sets Presidential Elections for 7 October 2010 – 14 September 2011

MercoPress – Venezuelan Presidential Election Moved Forward to 7 October 2012 – 14 September 2011

Violence in the Alemão slum as Peace Force Struggles to Overcome Drug Gangs

by Emilee Gaebler
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

BRASÍLIA, Brazil – The Alemão slum complex in Rio de Janeiro is once again beset by violence.  On Sunday evening, a scuffle between residents and the assigned Peace Force in the community took place.  Reports of this incident show that three residents were arrested and that pepper spray and rubber bullets were used to disperse crowds.  There were no reported deaths, although one woman was hit by a rubber bullet and a police officer was hit in the head with a stone.  

Peace Force soldiers open fire in the Alemão slum.  (Photo Courtesy of MercoPress)
Peace Force soldiers open fire in the Alemão slum. (Photo Courtesy of MercoPress)

The Peace Force has been present in the Alemão slum since November of last year.  At that time, security forces entered and gained control as part of a “pacification program”.  This program was an attempt to curb violence levels, in preparation for hosting the 2014 World Cup and 2016 Olympics.  Alemão had been the base for the Red Command, Rio’s largest drug gang.  The securing of the complex was viewed as a huge success as it severely inhibited drug trafficking and related violence.

Reports of how Sunday’s altercation began vary.  The Peace Force claims to have been assaulted by residents throwing stones and bottles as a foot patrol team arrested a man who had harassed them.  Residents say that it started with a request, from a Peace Force team, to lower the volume on a television set at a bar and escalated from there. 

Following Sunday’s scuffle, on Tuesday, a group of drug traffickers from a neighboring slum opened fire on the soldiers patrolling Alemão.  The Washington Post reports that television broadcasts show residents running to find cover from the bullets flying through the air.  Locals claim that a 15 year-old girl was killed in the fight and at least 16 others were wounded.  Authorities deny that any deaths occurred as a result of the struggle.

The aunt of the 15 year-old girl, allegedly killed from a stray bullet, was frustrated by the government’s response.  She stated, “I’m very angry because I was born and raised here and no one in my family has ever been killed in shootings. Now that (the slum) has been pacified, I’m seeing one of them killed. Where’s the state? Where are the authorities?”

Other residents voiced concerns that even with the Peace Force presence they do not feel any safer.  Also heard were complaints of overly aggressive policing in Alemão.  Authorities announced that police will now force occupations of the neighboring two slums as that is where the drug traffickers are believed to have originated from. 

 For more information, please see;

MercoPress – Brazilian Forces Try to Regain Control of Shantytown Again Lost to Criminal Gangs – 8 September 2011

BBC News – Extra Troops Sent to Rio Slum After Gunfight Erupts – 7 September 2011

The Washington Post – More Troops Flood Into Rio de Janeiro Slum After Fellow Soldiers Attacked by Gangs – 7 September 2011

The Rio Times – Confrontation in Complexo Alemão – 5 September 2011