Special Features
ICTJ World Report: In Focus April 2013
War Crimes Prosecution Watch: Vol. 8, Issue 27
Vol. 8, Issue 2 — April 22, 2013
INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT
Central African Republic & Uganda
- BembaTrial.org: Bemba Trial Resumes Next Week
- BembaTrial.org: Bemba Had “Elementary” Military Knowledge but Troops Were Well-Trained
- BembaTrial.org: Witness Says Locals Offered MLC Fighters ‘Heartfelt Thanks’
- BembaTrial.org: Witness: Bemba Formed Commission To Probe Soldiers’ Conduct
- BembaTrial.org: Insider Says Media Reports About MLC Crimes Were Unverified
- BembaTrial.org: Bemba ‘Lost Authority’ Over Troops Deployed In Car
- BembaTrial.org: Insider Tells ICC Bemba Lacked Capacity to Command Alone
- BembaTrial.org: Bemba Hearings Cancelled For The Week
Darfur, Sudan
- Associated Press: Official: Sudan Leader not Traveling to Kenya
- AllAfrica.com: Sudan: Militia Leader Charged by ICC ‘Leading’ Darfur Tribal Clashes- Sources
- AllAfrica.com: Sudan: Central Darfur Fighters ‘Close to Catching ICC’s Ali Kushayb’
Democratic Republic of the Congo
- CapitalFM News: ICC Prosecutor Wants Congo Ex-Militia Boss Retried
- KatangaTrial.org: What Next for Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui?
Kenya
Libya
- Institute for War and Peace Reporting: Whether or Not Saif al-Islam Goes to the Hague, Libya’s Legal System Will Struggle to Deal with the Many Other Cases Likely to be Brought
- Reuters: In Jail Eight Months, Gaddafi Spy Chief Hasn’t Seen Lawyer: HRW
Cote d’Ivoire (Ivory Coast)
AFRICA
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda
- AllAfrica.com: ICTR Betrayed Rwanda, Justice Minister Tells UN
- The Province: At UN Security Council, Rwanda Kkeeps International Criminal Court out of African Affairs
EUROPE
Court of Bosnia & Herzegovina, War Crimes Chamber
- Court of Bosnia & Herzegovina: Pronouncement of the Trial Verdict in the Case v. Milorad Zivkovic et al.
- Court of Bosnia & Herzegovina: Zoran Milic Pleads Not Guilty
- Court of Bosnia & Herzegovina: Osman Brkan and Ibro Macic Plead Not Guilty
- Court of Bosnia & Herzegovina: Trial Verdict Handed Down in the Case v. Milorad Zivkovic et al.
- Justice Report: Verdict Against Six Herceg-Bosna Leaders on May 29
- Justice Report: Zoran Milic Pleads Not Guilty
- Justice Report: Srebrenica Witness Changes Line on Executions
International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia
- Institute for War and Peace Reporting: Bosnian Serb Leader says Karadzic was Peacemaker
- Institute for War and Peace Reporting: Mladic Ejected after “Lying” Comment
- Institute for War and Peace Reporting: Seselj Judgment Date Set for October
Domestic Prosecutions In The Former Yugoslavia
- Balkan Transitional Justice: Macedonia’s Tarculovski Freed Early by Hague Court
- Balkan Transitional Justice: Serbia Sends Kosovo Guerrilla For Retrial
- Balkan Transitional Justice: Serbia Charges Soldier With 18 Murders in Bihac
- Balkan Transitional Justice: Bosnian Serb Police Chief Jailed for Cajnice Expulsions
MIDDLE EAST AND ASIA
Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia
- VOA Khmer: International Side of Tribunal Loans Funds to Cambodian Side
- The Cambodia Daily: After Much Debacle, Witness Returns to Stand at KR Tribunal
- Bangkok Post: Cambodia’s Khmer Rouge Court to be ‘Downsized’
- The Phnom Penh Post: Ponchaud Testifies at the KRT
- The Phnom Penh Post: Samphan Believes in Justice, Says Ponchaud
- The Cambodia Daily: Khieu Samphan Pleads for Release on Bail
- VOA Khmer: Given Difficulties, Tribunal Observers Worry Over Exit Strategy
Syria
- New York Times: Military in Syria is Accused of Massacre
- Globe and Mail: Syria’s Assad Regime Accused of War Crimes
- Al Jazeera: Russia Backs Future Syria War Crimes Probe
Special Tribunal for Lebanon
- The Daily Star: New STL Trial Date Unlikely Before Last Quarter 2013
- The Daily Starr: STL: Alleged Witnesses List Aims to Undermine Court
- Agence France-Presse: Lebanon’s Hariri, Court Condemn Publication of Witness List
- The Daily Star: Leaked STL Witness List ‘Inaccurate’: Spokesman
- The Daily Star: Al-Mustaqbal, STL Take Action Over Hacking Incident
- The Daily Star: Judiciary to Act After ‘Witness List’ Exposed
- The Daily Star: STL Head in Lebanon for Regular Meetings: Youssef
- The Daily Star: Baragwanath’s Visit Not Connected to Leaks: STL
- The Daily Star: State Prosecutor Denies Office Behind STL Witness Leaks
- The Daily Star: Victims Want STL ‘Witness List’ Publishers Held in Contempt
-
Bangladesh International Crimes Tribunal
- GlobalPost: G Azam Committed No Offence Hobnobbing with ’71 Junta: Defence
- Bangladesh News 24: ICT Hears War Crime Charges Against Mobarak
- Bangladesh News 24: Tribunal’s Apr 15 Deadline on Azam’s Defence
- GlobalPost: War Crimes Trial: Prosecutor Suffers Blow for Making Half Truth
- Gulf Times: Govt Firm on Executing War Tribunal Verdicts: Minister
- Daily Mail: NHS Boss Faces Death Penalty Over Charges of Torture and 18 Murders in Bangladesh
- Bangladesh News 24: Kamaruzzaman Verdict ‘Any Day’
- The Daily Star:Verdict Any Day: Prosecution Seeks Death, Defence Claims No Charges Proved
War Crimes Investigations in Burma
- Shan Herald: Shan Rebels-Burma Army Clash, Thousands Flee
- Radio Free Asia: Refugees Fear Fighting, Forced Labor in Burma’s Shan State
NORTH AND SOUTH AMERICA
United States
- Organization of American States: Inter-American Commission on Human Rights Wraps Up its 147th Session
- The New York Times: Targeted Killing Comes to Define War on Terror
- Organization of American States: Inter-American Commission on Human Rights 2012 Annual Report
- The Miami Herald: U.S. Troops Detail Skirmish with Guantánamo Captives
- Human Rights First: Pressure Mounting for White House Transparency on Drones
- The Orlando Sentinel: Florida to Be First State to Regulate Drones
South & Central America
Chile
Colombia
Guatemala
- Fox News Latino: Otto Pérez Molina Implicated in Trial of Former Guatemalan Strongman Ríos Montt
- CNN: Guatemala Confronts a Dark Chapter
- UN News Centre: Prosecuting Past Crimes Provides Hope to Survivors in Guatemala – UN Envoy
- Reuters: Judge Suspends Genocide Trial of Guatemala’s Rios Montt
TOPICS
Terrorism
- Associated Press: Turkish Lawmakers Change Anti-Terror Laws to Boost Freedoms, But Critics Say Move Falls Short
- Reuters: U.S. Condoned Torture After 9/11, Must Close Guantanamo: Report
- ABC News: Iraq Executes 21 Men Convicted of Terrorism
- Yahoo News: Vanishing Files Delay Guantanamo Hearings in 9/11 Case
- Hindustan Times: German Bakery Blast Case: Himayat Baig Gets Death
Piracy
- The Japan Times: Government to Let Ships Carry Armed Guards
- Marine Log: Total Cost of Piracy: $5.7 Billion to $6.1 Billion
Gender-Based Violence
- The Independent: Justice for Ruth Berry Peal, Who Was Forcibly Mutilated in Liberia, But Still No Ban on FGM
- International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics: Australia Signs National Compact to End Female Genital Mutilation
- UN News Centre: New G8 Initiative a Beacon of Hope for Victims of Sexual Violence – UN Envoy
- AfriqueJet: Gender-Based Violence Hits Criminal Dimension in Mali
REPORTS
UN Reports
- UN News Centre: Assembly Stresses Role of International Criminal Courts in Fostering Reconciliation
- UN News Centre: Prosecuting Past Crimes Provides Hope to Survivors in Guatemala
- UN News Centre: Ban Marks Rwandan Genocide with Call for Arrest and Prosecution of Remaining Fugitives
NGO Reports
- Human Rights Watch: Syria: Aerial Attacks Strike Civilians
- Amnesty International: Indonesia: Time to Face the Past: Justice for Past Abuses in Indonesia’s Aceh Province
TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSIONS
Nepal
- International Justice Resource Center: Truth and Reconciliation Commission for Nepal Continues to Face Criticism
- The Himalayan: German Delegation Raises TRC Concern
Ivory Coast
Liberia
United States
COMMENTARY AND PERSPECTIVES
- Opinio Juris: NYU JILP Symposium: New Thoughts About Barayagwiza: Reactions to Policing International Prosecutors
- Opinio Juris: NYU JILP Symposium: The Rhetoric of Remedies
- Opinio Juris: NYU JILP Symposium: Response to the Commentary on Policing International Prosecutors
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: Explaining and Justifying International Courts as Agents and Actors: Comments on von Bogdany and Venzke’s ‘On the Functions of International Courts
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: A Consideration of ‘On the Functions of International Courts: An Appraisal in Light of Their Burgeoning Public Authority’
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: A Reply to the Comments of Andreas Follesdal and Ruti Teitel
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: Where to Find Liberal Principles of Criminal Law
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: International Criminal Law and Moral Agency
- Opinio Juris: LJIL Symposium: The Idea of Justice in International Criminal Law
- EJIL: Talk!: Progressive Development of International Human Rights Law: The Reports of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic
- Justice in Conflict: Transitional Justice as Politics
- Opinio Juris: Bensouda on Palestinian Ratification of the Rome Statute
WORTH READING
- Annotated Leading Cases of International Criminal Tribunals – Volume 43 : When National and International Substantive Criminal Law Overlap: Decision on Appeal Against Closing Order Indicting Kaing Giel Eav aka ‘Duch’
- Chicago Journal of International Law: Jurisdiction, Immunity, Legality, and Jus Cogens
- University of Minnesota Law School Legal Studies Research Paper Series: Gendered Harms and Their Interface with International Criminal Law: Norms, Challenges and Domestication
- Source: The Special Tribunal for Lebanon Declines to Review UN Security Council Action: Retreating from Tadić’s Legacy in the Ayyash Jurisdiction and Legality Decisions
- International Center for Counter Terrorism Research Paper : Boundaries of the Battlefield: A Critical Look at the Legal Paradigms and Rules in Countering Terrorism
Notes From Makeni Part 1: “What Charles Taylor’s Judgment Means in Rural Sierra Leone”
By Reta Raymond
Special Features Editor
I am a third-year student at Syracuse University College of Law, and spent this past summer as an intern at Access to Justice Law Centre, a NGO in Makeni, Sierra Leone. These journal entries document my time spent in Sierra Leone. The opinions expressed in this series are purely my own, and not those of Access to Justice Law Centre.
“Charles Taylor couldn’t escape the law, and neither can your husband!” exclaimed Madiana, a Project Coordinator at Access to Justice Law Centre (“AJLC”). I was at a community outreach event in a rural village, about thirty minutes outside of Makeni, in northern Sierra Leone. That day, AJLC brought members of the community together to discuss the legal rights of women and children and provided resources for those seeking help. The woman Madiana was addressing had been skeptical of the law’s ability to stop her husband from beating her. This woman had once before reported her husband to the Family Support Unit of the Police Department, but to no avail.
I came to Sierra Leone after my second year of law school at Syracuse University to work as an intern at AJLC. AJLC is a non-governmental organization that serves women and children throughout northern Sierra Leone. They provide mediation, counseling, and litigation services. It was at this community outreach event, during the first week of my internship, that I began to realize how a failed state could rebuild the rule of law.
Many local people I’ve spoken to agree that Sierra Leone was a failed state when the civil war ended in 2002. The United Nations and the Sierra Leonean government created the Special Court for Sierra Leone as a way of seeking justice for the widespread atrocities that were committed against civilians during the war. The Special Court was mandated to prosecute the few who bore the “greatest responsibility” for the war crimes. Finally, on April 26, 2012, after a five-year trial, former Liberian President Charles Taylor was found guilty of eleven counts of aiding and abetting the war in Sierra Leone.
However, those who did not bear the greatest responsibility, but were responsible in fact for the atrocities, were reintegrated into society after the war. This issue of reintegration is perplexing. How can respect for the rule of law be instilled in former rebel soldiers who once killed and amputated the limbs of civilians and now work as motorbike taxi drivers or selling mobile phone airtime? How do they react when they carry an amputee to the market? How can perpetrators of atrocities and their victims live alongside one another, as if the war never happened? How do other victims respect the rule of law, when it was not applied to the individual perpetrators of the crimes against them?
While it is hard to speculate on the true impact of Charles Taylor’s judgment, it is clearly has value in rebuilding the rule of law, here in Sierra Leone. The current government is working to set precedents in the area of anti-corruption by indicting top officials. With steps like this Sierra Leone seems capable of proving that no one can escape conviction, not Charles Taylor, not ministers, and not abusive husbands in rural villages.
Through this series, “Notes from Makeni,” I hope to give readers an insight into some of my experiences here in Sierra Leone. I am fortunate to be working with some very talented legal professionals here at Access to Justice Law Centre; they are engaged in strengthening this country, village by village.