The Middle East

Libyan Woman Still Missing a Week After Accusing Soldiers of Rape

by Laura Hirahara
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

Eman al-Obeidy dragged from Tripoli hotel in front of reporters; Photo courtesy NYT
Eman al-Obeidy dragged from Tripoli hotel in front of reporters; Photo courtesy NYT

TRIPOLI, Lybia– Last week, 29 year old Libyan lawyer Eman al-Obeidy ran into the Rixos Hotel in Tripoli and accused 15 Libyan soldiers of gang-raping her over a period of two days.  At the hotel, where numerous foreign journalists were having breakfast, al-Obeidy showed them bruises on her face, thighs and blood on her inner thighs.  She also had what appeared to be rope burns on her wrists and ankles and shouted to the journalists, “Look at what Gadhafi’s brigades did to me. . .My honor was violated by them.”  One hotel staffer pulled out a knife and call her a traitor while another attempted to throw a dark table cloth over her head.  A government official at the hotel pulled out a gun.  A scuffle ensued when government supporters attempted to take the journalists reporting equipment.  Several reporters were kicked and pushed to the ground and one reporter’s camera was taken and smashed.  As security dragged al-Obeidy from the hotel she yelled “If you don’t see me tomorrow, then that’s it.”

Since this incident, al-Obeidy has not been seen or heard from by anyone including her sister with whom she lives, despite the government reporting they released her on Sunday.  Immediately following her claims, government spokespersons first called her mentally ill and drunk, later saying she was a prostitute.  The government is now saying that she is in fact mentally fit to stand  trial.  Government spokesman Mousa Ibrahim says they will investigate her claims but since her appearance at the hotel, the soldiers have filed slander suits against al-Obeidy.

Al-Obeidy’s claims highlight UN peacekeeper Patrick Cammaert assertion that “It is now more dangerous to be a woman than a soldier in modern wars.”  In a country like Lybia, women who are raped are considered to have lost their honor and children born to rape victims lack full legal status.  In 2006, Human Rights Watch issued a report stating that Lybia sent rape victims to ‘rehabilitation centers’ where they were imprisoned and sometimes raped by the center’s staff as punishment for bringing shame on Lybia.  Mona Eltahawy, a journalist on Muslim and Arab concerns, said of al-Obeidy’s public claims, “No one would do that unless they were raped, and especially in a conservative society.”  More recently, medical examiners have reported finding condoms and the drug Viagra in the pockets of dead Libyan soldiers, saying it is proof that soldiers are carrying out sexual assaults.

Al-Obeidy’s situation also highlights the difficulty war-rape victims have in bringing charges before the courts.  In the days following the hotel incident, lawyers and human rights activists tried to contact al-Obeidy’s sister at her home but were turned away by security forces outside of the home.  Al-Obeidy’s mother, Aisha Ahmad, says she received a phone the day after her daughter was dragged from the Tripoli hotel from a man offering Ahmad and al-Obiedy money to drop the charges against the soldiers.  Ahmad refused the money.

Ibrahim, who has claimed that journalists will be allowed to interview al-Obeidy in the coming days, said he did not know where she is, stating on Thursday, “The only place she will be other than her family house [is in a shelter]. . .Maybe she is there.”  Al-Obeidy’s family is holding out hope that she will return to them safely and have promised to support her.  In al-Obeidy’s home-town of Tobruk the family held a religious ceremony at the local mosque to show the support of the whole community.  Al-Obiedy’s mother, who says she has not been able to eat or sleep in the week since her daughter went missing, said of Gadhafi, “If I were to see his face, I would strangle him.”

For more information, please see;

Huffington PostWar’s Brutal Tactics– 31 March, 2011

NPRReports Emerging of Rape By Libyan Soldiers– 31 March, 2011

CNNHow One Voice Can Tell the Story of an Entire Movement– 1 April, 2011

The Globe and MailRape Case Underscores Gadhafi’s Brutality– 30 March, 2011

CNNAlleged Rape Victim to Meet With Journalists, Libyan Government Says– 1 April, 2011

Saudi Arabia Outlaws Protests

By Eric C. Sigmund
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia – Islamic scholars in Saudi Arabia issued a fatwa, a religious edict, Tuesday, forbidding protests in the country.  The edict declares that anti-government demonstrations are punishable as un-Islamic.  The Saudi government reports that it will print and additional 1.5 million copies of the edict, to add to the 500,000 already printed, to distribute to citizens.

The fatwa, issued by Grand Mufti Sheikh Abdul-Aziz Al al-Sheikh, the most prominent religious official in the country, urges citizens to “have a united front….under its wise and legitimate leadership.”  Despite the government’s quick endorsement of the edict, not all Islamic scholars support a ban on free expression.   Sheikh Gamal Qotb, the former head of the Al-Azhar fatwa committee, the highest religious institution in the Sunni world, expressed that the edict was a “big mistake,” noting that protest helps to promote peace and check tyranny.

While countries throughout the region continue to experience massive popular uprisings, Saudi Arabia has been largely immune from pro-democracy resistance.  The government quickly reacted to attempts by opponents to stage mass protests on March 11 by increasing the street presence of its police forces.   Heightened security patrols and strong rhetoric from the Saudi leaderships has thus far allowed the government to suppress and deter civilian protests. 

For more information please see:

Al-Masry Al-Youm- Al-Azhar Scholar Criticizes Saudi Edict Banning Protests – Mar. 30, 2011

People’s Daily Online – Saudi Arabia Prints 1.5 Million Copies of Anti-Protest Edict –Mar. 30, 2011

Reuters Africa – Saudi Prints 1.5 Million Copies of Anti-Demo Edict – Mar. 29, 2011

Civil War Looms in Jordan after Fierce Clashes between Civilians and Government

By Eric C. Sigmund
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

AMMAN, Jordan – Civil unrest in Jordan continues to rise as protesters, unsatisfied with government concessions, become more emboldened, spurring violate clashes between protesters and government supporters.  Saturday’s clashes were the bloodiest yet in the country, leaving 2 protesters dead and 160 injured.  Concerned that Jordan is edging closer to civil war, King Abdullah II called for national unity and announced that the government “is going ahead with political and economic reforms, strongly and enthusiastically.”

Protesters Remain Strong Three Months Later Despite Crackdowns (Photo Courtesy of The Medial Line)
Protesters Remain Strong Three Months Later Despite Crackdowns (Photo Courtesy of The Medial Line)

Pro-reform protest continued to remain resilient three months after their initial outbreak despite security crackdowns from government supporters and police forces.  While the King has expressed his commitment to address the concerns of discontent citizens, some of his proposed reforms face significant opposition from Parliament.   In particular, the Jordanian Parliament has been unwilling to limit the King’s power, claiming that a diminution of the King’s constitutional authority represents a “threat to Jordan’s survival.”  Commenting on Saturday’s deadly clashes, Parliamentary leaders announced that it will “make sure [the King] remains powerful to preserve the Jordanian identity and the constitution” and warned that “political blackmail is rejected.”  

Parliament’s statements however, have not been well received by government critics and have led some political analysts to issue their own warnings about the heightened possibility of civil war.  One commentator noted that “there is a sense that the situation may explode at any moment.”   While King Abdullah has already taken some steps to calm popular discontent, such as raising pensions and reshuffling his Cabinet, these reforms have largely been rejected as half-hearted reforms which do not address protester’s core demands.  Until all their demands are met, citizens will continue to clog the streets and pursue reform notes one protester.   Given Parliaments resistance to further constitutional reforms, the prospects for peaceful reform may be dwindling in Jordan. 

For more information please see:

The Media Line – Jordan Teetering on Civil War, Local Analysts Say – Mar. 28, 2011

Agence France Presse – Jordan King Urges Unity After Unrest – Mar. 27, 2011

Al-Jazeera – Jordan’s King Calls for National Unity – Mar. 27, 2011

International Community Condemns Deadly Protests in Syria

By Eileen Gould
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

DERA’A, Syria – Syrian military troops opened fire on protestors who were demonstrating peacefully, killing a number of them.  This prompted tens of thousands of protestors in cities and towns around Syria to gather to challenge the government.

Since the protests began a week ago in the southern portion of Syria, 38 people have been killed by government forces and many more were killed on Friday.  Because the government refused to let reporters into the country, exact details about the incident are difficult to obtain.

Protestors apparently set fire to a statue of President Bashar al-Assad’s father, former President Hafez al-Assad.  Security forces then fired into the crowd and threw tear gas canisters.

A spokeswoman for the President stated that the government had not ordered the troops to fire on the protesters.

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon spoke out against the Syrian authorities’ actions and called upon them to refrain from the use of violence.  In a statement issued on March 23, he also stated that those responsible must be held accountable.

The U.S. has also expressed concern over the situation in Syria.  “We urge on the government of Syria what we have urged on the governments in other regions: that they pursue a peaceful course here, that they participate in a political dialogue with their people, because that is the better path,” stated White House spokesman Jay Carney.

Human rights organizations have also condemned the manner in which authorities responded to the protestors.

Philip Luther, Amnesty International’s Deputy Director for the Middle East and North Africa, stated, “The Syrian authorities must cease the use of excessive force to crush protests and immediately release all of those detained for the peaceful expression of their beliefs.”

Authorities also closed roads to the town of Dera’a and detained as many as 93 people, including a man who had been appointed as a community leader to negotiate with the authorities.  Recent reports indicate that almost all of these people, ranging in age from 14 to 45 and including students and journalists, have been released.

On Thursday, the government of Syria stated that it would consider reforms, including a possible end to the emergency law, which were passed in 1963.  This law permits the government to override the constitution and penal code statutes and also allows authorities to make preventive arrests.

According to a representative of Amnesty International, it is questionable as to whether the government will keep their promises to reform the law.  “The government has made similar statements before, yet the repressive state of emergency has endured with little tolerance for dissenting views for nearly half a century.”

Amnesty further called upon the Syrian government to stop the use of excessive force and to allow peaceful protestors to assemble freely.

For more information please see:
AFP – US condemns new Syria violence – 25 March 2011

Amnesty International – Syria Death Toll Climbs As Protests Spread – 25 March 2011

UN News Centre – Syria: UN human rights office voices concerns about situation – 25 March 2011

Amnesty International – Spiralling Syria Death Toll Reports ‘Disturbing’ – 24 March 2011

UN Secretary-General – Secretary-General Condemns Violence in Southern Syria, Urges Investigation – 23 March 2011

Jerusalem Bombing Kills One, Injures Dozens Amid Escalating Tension

By Eileen Gould
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

JERUSALEM, Israel – A bomb planted near West Jerusalem’s Central Bus station was detonated, killing one person, and injuring three dozen others, earlier this week.  The attack has been described as the “worst attack in Jerusalem in four years” and has prompted international criticism.

The bomb, weighing between two and four pounds and packed with ball bearings to increase damage, detonated just as two buses arrived at the bus station.  The U.S. State Department has announced that six Americans were injured.  Some of the victims were as young as 15.

Investigators believe the attack was the work of Palestinian terrorists, though no one has taken responsibility as of yet. Islamic Jihad, a militant Palestinian organization, and the Popular Resistance Committees, another militant group that is close to Hamas, praised it.

The bombing came as the tension between Israelis and Palestinians has escalated.  In the last week, stray fire from the response of Israeli troops to a rocket attack killed a sixty year old man and three Palestinian children.  The Israeli Air Force also killed four members of Islamic Jihad, a militant Palestinian organization, in Gaza.  According to the Israeli military, these men planned to launch rockets at Israel.

These recent bouts of violence may have discouraged any prospects of Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Wednesday, “We will act vigorously, responsibly and prudently in order to maintain the quiet and the security that have prevailed here over the past two years.”

The Palestinian Authority has also denounced the bombing, as well as Israel’s actions in Gaza.  On Wednesday Prime Minister Salam Fayyad stated, “I condemn this terrorist operation in the strongest terms, regardless of which party stands behind it.”

Nir Barkat, the mayor of Jerusalem, characterized the attack as “cowardly” and noted that residents should continue to live their daily lives such that it gives the impression that terrorists cannot win in the end.  “It’s important to return to our regular routines as quickly as possible. When terror attempts to disrupt our way of life, the best solution is to get back to normal as quickly as possible. Events in Jerusalem will not be cancelled and Jerusalem will not stop running.”

Human Rights Watch has called the bombing of civilians “a despicable crime that should be promptly investigated and prosecuted”.

For more information please see:
The Epoch Times – Israel Promises ‘Tough Reaction’ for Jerusalem Bombing – 25 March 2011

ABC News – British Woman Killed, Six Americans Injured in Jerusalem Bombing, Palestinian Terrorists Blamed – 24 March 2011

Human Rights Watch – Israel: Jerusalem Bombing an Indefensible Attack on Civilians – 24 March 2011

Globes – Bomb Explodes near Jerusalem bus – 23 March 2011

The Epoch Times – Jerusalem Bomb Kills One, Injures Dozens More – 23 March 2011

New York Times – Jerusalem Blast Raises Fears of Growing Violence – 23 March 2011