The Middle East

Female Genital Mutilation Remains Widespread Practice Among Iraqi Kurds

By Dallas Steele
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

Kurdish Girls and Women are at Risk of Forced Female Circumcisions. (Photo Courtesy of CNN)
Kurdish girls and women remain at risk of receiving forced circumcisions. (Photo Courtesy of AFP)

SULAIMANIYA, Iraq– In the autonomous Iraqi region of Kurdistan, female circumcision continues to occur, and has become increasingly prevalent in the last decade. The procedure, medically known as clitoridectomy, involves the partial or total removal of the clitoris.

In Kurdistan, the operation is typically performed by individuals who have not received medical training, and often conducted with an unsantized razor blade. The practice, which is neither mandated by Islam nor found in the Koran, is intended to deprive young girls and women of any sexual urges or desires in order to preserve their fidelity.

Although the Kurdish Regional Government (KRG) does not keep statistics on female circumcisions or post-operative medical consequences, it is believed that at least forty percent of girls and women in Iraq’s Kurdistan region have undergone the procedure. Other studies have found that up to eighty percent of women fourteen years of age and older have had at least a partial clitoridectomy.

The KRG has received increasing pressure to enact legislation banning the practice on young girls and unconsenting adult women. The KRG’s Justice Ministry circulated an order in 2007 announcing that it would arrest and punish any practitioners of female genital mutilation. Furthermore, a draft law banning the practice was enacted by the Kurdistan Regional Parliament in 2007.  However, both efforts by the KRG to suppress the practice have largely been ignored.  

Kurdish women who have undergone the procedure have testified to the damaging effects that procedure has, physically and mentally. Baxcha A., a twenty-two-year-old married woman, relayed her nightmarish experience to members of Human Rights Watch as they conducted a survey on the topic in 2009. Baxcha told the advocacy organization how, at the age of five, she was held to the ground, and was forced to undergo the surgery. Baxcha reported that she only given water and ash to place on the wound after the procedure.

Human Rights Watch, and other human rights groups, have called on Kurdish authorities to outlaw the practice and enforce a ban on female genital mutilation. Kurdish officials have responded by downplaying the statistics of various studies concerning female circumcision in the area. Furthermore, Mariwan Naqshbandi, spokesman for Kurdistan’s Ministry of Endowment and Religious Affairs, has dismissed the surveys and stated that Kurdistan has “issues far more important” to confront than female genital mutilation.

For more information, please see:

CNN – Human rights group urges Kurds to ban female circumcision – 17 June 2010

BBC – HRW presses Iraqi Kurds to ban female circumcision – 16 June 2010

The New York Times – Kurdistan Is Urged to Ban Genital Cutting – 16 June 2010

Anniversary of Iranian Election Passes Quietly, but not Unnoticed

By Warren Popp
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

Green Revolution Protesters (Photo by jeffmcneill on Flickr)
Large numbers of "Green Revolution" Protesters took to the streets last year (Photo by "jeffmcneill" on Flickr)
TEHRAN, Iran – Last Saturday marked the one-year anniversary of the “Green Revolution” in Iran, the protest movement that formed in reaction to the outcome of the Iranian presidential elections, with many Iranians believing that the opposition candidate, Mir Hossein Mousavi, was the legitimate winner over incumbent President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. The massive protests were met by a violent government crackdown which killed dozens of people and led to the imprisonment of many others.

Iranian authorities, most prominently Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, blamed last year’s massive protests on Western powers, accusing them of orchestrating the protests as part of an attempt to topple the Iranian regime.

While opposition leaders made plans to organize major protests to mark the anniversary, they called off the plans, “to protect the lives and property of people,” when the government both denied their protest permit and vowed to suppress any protests. Mousavi told his supporters that the “best means” to voice their discontent is to expand the social networks and websites: The same sources that originally propelled the movement and gave it the nickname, the “Twitter Revolution.”

The one-year anniversary was met with a relatively calm response in Iran, with small protests, sporadic clashes, and reports of ninety one  protesters arrested, including a political ally of Mousavi’s, Davoud Roshani, and a labour union activist, Reza Shahabi.

Iran’s Intelligence Ministry reportedly sent text messages to random citizens that were clearly designed to intimidate them. Bloomberg Businessweek cited the website Rahesabz as reporting that the messages said: “Dear citizen, you have been deceived by the foreign media and are cooperating with them. If repeated, you will be dealt with according to the Islamic punishment law.”

The international community takes notice

GENEVA, Switzerland – While the response to the June 13th anniversary inside Iran was limited, the international community seized the opportunity to condemn the extensive human rights abuses in Iran. On June 11, 2010, criticism was levelled against Iran when the Human Rights Councils conducted its Universal Periodic Review of Iran. Countries such as the United States, Britain, and Norway accused Iran of violating human rights, freedom of speech and expressions, and denying access to the Council’s special rapporteurs—specialists who are given mandates to report on various human rights issues.

The Iranian delegation responded that they welcomed visits by the special rapporteurs in “due course”; however, no special rapporteur has been given access to Iran since 2005. Some of Iran’s allies and neighbors in the Council, such as Kuwait, Pakistan, Venezuela, and Cuba, praised and defended Tehran’s human rights record in the same Council meeting.

On 17 June, 2010, Iran also became a contentious topic in the Human Rights Council when Norway, on behalf of fifty-four countries, gave a statement marking the anniversary of Iran’s election crackdown, criticizing Iran’s human rights record, especially since last year’s election, including, “the violent suppression of dissent, detention and executions without due process of law, severe discrimination against women and minorities including people of the Bah’ai faith, and restrictions on freedom of expression and religion.”

Iran responded to the crticism by issuing a procedural challenge, claiming that country-specific statements are not allowed under the particular topic, the Vienna Declaration and Program of Action. With the support of several other countries on the Council, the Council was delayed by several hours as the Council sought to avoid a contentious vote on the issue.

World leaders, including United States President Barack Obama, and NGOs such as Amnesty International also used the June 13th anniversary as an opportunity to criticize the human rights record of Iran, and to call for the World community to support the Iranian people in the fight for freedom. In a statement, President Obama said, “It is the responsibility of all free people and free nations to make it clear that we are on the side of those who seek freedom, justice and dignity, as surely as hope and history are.” He also said the election will be “remembered for how the Iranian government brutally suppressed dissent and murdered the innocent, including a young woman left to die in the street.”

For more information, please see:

Tehran Times – 91 Detained in Tehran on Presidential Poll Anniversary: Police – 17 June 2010

Washington Times – Editorial: Iran’s Twitter Revolution – 16 June 2009

Wall Street Journal – On Vote Anniversary, Iran Is Quiet Amid Heavy Security – 14 June 2010

Al Jazeera – Iran Marks Poll Anniversary – 13 June 2010

Bloomberg Businessweek – Iran Authorities Say 91 People Detained on Election Anniversary – 13 June 2010

BBC – Tehran Clashes Reported on Iran Vote Anniversary – 12 June 2010

Inter Press Service – Iran Pressured to Open Doors to U.N. Rights Investigators – 11 June 2010

AFP – Obama Urges Support for Iranian ‘Freedom’ – 10 June 2010

AP – US Urges Iran to Fulfill Human Rights Pledges – 10 June 2010

N.Y. Times – Iran Defends Rights Record as Opposition Cancels Rally – 10 June 2010

Israeli agent wanted in connection with Hamas murder

By Polly Johnson
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

WARSAW, Poland – Polish authorities have arrested a suspected Israeli agent in connection with the murder of a Hamas leader in Dubai earlier this year.

Germany is now seeking the extradition of Uri Brodsky, suspected in the January assassination of a Hamas commander, identified as Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, one of the founders of the Palestinian group Hamas’ military wing.

Brodsky was allegedly involved in illegally obtaining a German passport, according to a spokesman for the German prosecution, who added that it’s now up to the Poles to decide whether to give Brodsky up to Germany, where he will faces charges of espionage and forgery.

Arrested on June 4 at the Warsaw airport on suspicion that he assisted one of the assassins with obtaining a fraudulent passport, Polish authorities have a month to decide on extradition.

He allegedly worked with Mossad, Israel’s intelligence agency. Israel opposes Poland’s proposed extradition of Brodsky to Germany. However, according to the Polish prosecutor, the extradition is based on a European warrant, which, consistent with European Union standards, leaves Poland with little choice in the decision.

Der Spiegel, a German magazine, reported that the Israeli embassy in Warsaw is urging Poland not to extradite Brodsky to Germany.

His wife also issued a statement urging the authorities to permit Brodsky to be turned over to the Dubai authorities to be tried there.

He will not face charges in connection with the assassination of the Hamas commander, only the espionage and forgery charges.

Officials from Dubai have claimed that Israeli agents are responsible for the January killing and provided the names of two dozen alleged assassins who carried out the plot using fraudulent passports from several different countries, including Britain, the Irish Republic, France, Australia, and Germany. The Dubai police have released surveillance footage showing the alleged Mossad suspects from the hit squad. According to the police, al-Mabhouh was drugged and suffocated.

For more information, please see:

BBC – Israeli wanted over Dubai killing ‘held in Poland’ – 12 June 2010

Al Jazeera – Poland holds alleged Israeli spy – 13 June 2010

The Jerusalem Post – Poles support agent’s extradition – 14 June 2010

Bloomberg Businessweek – Poland May Seek Surrender of Suspected Mossad Agent Tomorrow – 15 June 2010

Examiner – Mossad agent allegedly involved in Hamas killing now to be extradited to Germany – 15 June 2010

Haaretz.com – Poland to extradite alleged Mossad agent to Germany – 15 June 2010

Arab League Takes Action Against Israel’s Blockade of Gaza Strip

By Alyxandra Stanczak
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

CAIRO, Egypt– Amr Moussa, Secretary General of the Arab League, visited the Gaza Strip today to call for an end to a blockade that has been in effect since Hamas took over the Gaza Strip in 2007.  Moussa called for a break in the blockade and said the position of the Arab League is clear in this matter.

Children and other vulnerable groups are the real victims of Israels blockade.
Children and other vulnerable groups are the real victims of Israel’s blockade.                          (Photo courtesy of Amnesty International.)

The Arab League was formed in 1945 and consists of 22 members, including Palestine, and four observers. Relations between the Arab League and Israel have historically been strained. When the League was formed they called for an embargo of Jewish businesses operating within Palestine. More recently, Israeli – Arab League relations have been improving, signified by Arab League representatives meeting with then Israeli prime minister Olmert and other high-ranking ministers in 2007. This meeting was the first time Israel received an official Arab League delegation.

The blockade has resulted in unemployment, inflated food prices resulting in reliance upon humanitarian aid, and poverty. Items barred in the blockade include basic goods such as food and fuel. Food which is not delivered by the UN and other agencies is often smuggled through the Egypt-Gaza border and is sold to Gaza residents. More than half of Gaza’s population are considered vulnerable; especially children, the elderly, the sick, and refugees. Civilians, rather than armed anti-Israeli groups, are most likely to be affected by the blockade.

Moussa’s trip was coordinated with the Palestinian Authority, which governs parts of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and he is scheduled to meet with Hamas prime minister Haniyeh. Moussa’s trip to Gaza has already had an apparent effect in Israel, with Israeli prime minister Netanyahu responding that he supports an easing of the blockade, but still opposes a complete lift on the blockade.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera – Arab League demands Gaza siege end – 13 June 2010

Haaretz – Netanyahu: Naval blockade on Gaza will not be lifted – 13 June 2010

Amnesty International – Suffocating Gaza – The Israeli Blockade’s Effects on Palestinians – 1 June 2010

Palestinian Man Shot Dead by Israeli Police After Hit-and-Run

By Dallas Steele
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

EAST JERUSALEM, Israel — As tensions remain at an unprecedented high, Israeli border police officers have shot and killed a Palestinian driver who may have intentionally hit two border police officers with his motor vehicle on Friday. The incident began when the driver, forty-0ne-year-old Ziad al-Jolani, rammed his Mitsubishi van into two border police officers. It remains unclear whether al-Jolani intended to injure the two officers or whether the entire incident was an accident.

Tensions run high in East Jerusalem between Israeli border police officers and Palestinian men restricted from travelling
Tensions run high in East Jerusalem between Israeli border police officers and Palestinian men restricted from travelling. (Photo Courtesy of Al Jazeera)

Micky Rosenfeld, an Israeli police spokesman, said that after al-Jolani struck the two officers with his van, one of the officers fired warning shots in the air and called for the driver to stop his vehicle. As the driver ignored the border police officers’ request by driving away, the officers began to give chase to al-Jolani. Al-Jolani got out of his van in an attempt to flee by foot while the border police officers continued to call for the driver to cease and desist. After continuing to ignore the demand to halt, a border guard shot al-Jolani dead.

Palestinian witnesses have given a similar account as Rosenfeld, but have made the claim that the Israeli police officers began to fire indiscriminately in al-Jolani’s direction, causing not only his death, but the serious injury of a young woman as well.

Conflicting reports have been made on the injury of the passenger in al-Jolani’s van, Mahmoud al-Jolani, as some reports have stated he was injured during the incident and others saying he was injured earlier that day in a stone-throwing incident.

The killing has come at an extreme low point in Palestinian-Israeli relations. The checkpoint where the shooting occurred was located in the neighborhood of Wadi al-Joz, an area predominantly inhabited by Palestinians, but became part of Israeli territory after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

Additionally, Israeli police had just recently announced a limited-access policy for Palestinian men under the age of forty travelling from East Jerusalem to the al-Aqsa Mosque for Friday prayers. This move was made in response to the heightened tensions in the region following last month’s clash between Israel’s commando raid on a Turkish ship bound for Gaza that left nine activists dead.

For more information, please see:

Al Jazeera — Israeli police kill Palestinian man — 11 June 2010

CNN — Palestinian driver shot dead after striking Israeli border guards — 11 June 2010

NY Times — Police kill Palestinian driver in East Jerusalem — 11 June 2010