The Middle East

Israel Opens West Bank Prison to Journalists

By Dylan Takores
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

JERUSALEM, Israel – Israeli prison officials agreed to admit journalists to view the interior conditions of a West Bank prison that holds Palestinian inmates.

Palestinian using a sling to hurl tear gas back at Israeli forces. (Photo Courtesy of Reuters)

The Israel Prison Service (IPS) made the decision in response to reports of torture and wrongful death of multiple Palestinian inmates that were detained in Israeli custody.  In particular, one prisoner died of cancer earlier this month, spurring accusations of mistreatment and failure to provide proper medical assistance.

Prison warden Yaakov Shalom boldly stated, “We have nothing to hide,” after agreeing to allow journalists to view Ofer, a prison in the West Bank that holds approximately 700 Palestinian detainees.  Ofer is just one of a group of prisons that collectively hold roughly 5,000 Palestinian prisoners.

The prison exterior is large and intimidating.  High walls lined with guard towers are capped with barbed wire.  Inside, the prison is divided into sections based on the inmates’ faction membership.  Some of individual sections are devoted to Fatah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, smaller groups, and inmates under 18 years of age.

Inmates are generally permitted to pray in prison yards surrounded by a fence of metal bars.  Abdul Kahir Srour, a Palestinian inmate and resident of Ramallah, claimed his treatment “fluctuated” as a result of the allegations against the IPS.  Nevertheless, Srour maintained his innocence, asserting that he has been in custody for five months without charge for alleged activities related to Hamas.

Despite four months of pleading, Muhammad Natsheh, an inmate in the Hamas section, complained that prison guards denied accommodation to his request for specific medical treatment.  A prison medic stated that referrals were provided when necessary, arguing, “There is no neglect.”

Silwad resident Tarek Hamed, 17, explained that he was beaten by soldiers following his arrest for throwing stones at a highway near his home.  Due to the mistreatment, his sentence was reduced from five months to one month of imprisonment.  Yousef Hamed, 15, received similar treatment for the same offense.  Mohammed Safi, 17, recalled that he was “slapped around” after his arrest and interrogation.  However, none of the boys cited any mistreatment at the Ofer facility itself.

Shalom stated that his policies and interactions with inmates remained unchanged in the wake of the outside allegations.  He concluded, “As long as they don’t create disturbances, it doesn’t matter what is going on outside.  They have a lot to lose, and it’s worth it for them to behave accordingly.”

 

For further information, please see:

Reuters – Palestinians open Israeli jail replica to honour prisoners – 16 April 2013

Xinhua – Israel offers rare visit of Ofer prison ahead of Palestinian Prisoner Day – 15 April 2013

Media Line – Israel Trumpets Fair Treatment in Prisons – 14 April 2013

Washington Post – Israel allows journalists to visit West Bank prison after deaths in custody – 14 April 2013

Impunity Watch – Palestinian Inmate Death Causes Widespread Protests – 25 February 2013

Start Your Engines: Tear Gas Fired at Activists in Bahrain

By Dylan Takores
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

MANAMA, Bahrain – Police fired tear gas at activists at the Jabriya school for boys in Manama on Tuesday following a protest for the release of a detained student.

Activists flee from police tear gas. (Photo Courtesy of Bahrain Center for Human Rights)

Police arrested Hassan Humidan, 17, on Monday as part of a government crackdown on protests and general unrest in anticipation of the upcoming F1 Grand Prix race scheduled to take place next week.  Humidan is one of approximately 100 people that have been arrested in the past month as a result of increased law enforcement and boosted security.

The government claimed the police acted within the bounds of the law.  The Ministry of the Interior tweeted that “police dealt with a group of thugs outside Jabriya school according to legal regulations.”

Many observers tweeted pictures of protestors fleeing from the tear gas.  According to the Associated Press, Mohamed Jaber, a father of one of the Jabriya school’s students, attempted to pick up his son from the school, but was denied entrance by police.

The protests are a reaction to the Bahraini government’s human rights violations.  Activists call for the cancelation of the Grand Prix race.  The confrontation is the most recent in a span of clashes that began in February 2011.

The race was planned to exhibit to the world that the social unrest in Bahrain decreased and the nation is stabilizing.  Andy Slaughter, Chairman of the All-Party Parliamentary Group Democracy in Bahrain, reported to the BBC that “There is a close relationship between the race and the repression by a regime that is using F1 to try and establish normalcy.”  Slaughter referred to the race as a “propaganda exercise.”

Clashes between the government and human rights activists occur in Bahrain on a near-daily basis.  Human rights groups approximate that fifty individuals have died since confrontations began two years ago.  The government disputes this number.

Despite the violence, the Bahraini government refuses to cancel the race.  Nicholas McGeehan of Human Rights Watch criticized the government’s decision to go ahead with the race, condemning it as a “political event which will gloss over serious rights violations.”

Both the Bahraini government and Formula One President and CEO Bernie Ecclestone contended that the race is crucial to the country’s fragile economy.  The government vowed to maintain strict security over the event.

 

For further information, please see:

Albawaba – Police ‘fire tear gas’ at boys’ school following student’s arrest – 16 April 2013

BBC – Bahrain: Police ‘fire tear gas’ at boys’ school – 16 April 2013

Philly.com – Bahrain GP on despite anti-government protests – 16 April 2013

Washington Post – Bahrain police raid high school, fire tear gas in clash with students following arrest – 16 April 2013

Former Kuwaiti MP Sentenced to Five Years for Allegedly Insulting Emir

By Ali Al-Bassam
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

KUWAIT CITY, Kuwait — Opposition leader and former MP Mussallam al-Barrak was sentenced to five years in prison last Monday for allegedly insulting the Emir of Kuwait, Sheikh Sabah al-Ahmad Al-Sabah.  The court declared that Barrak was guilty of “undermining the Emir’s status.”

Former MP Musallam al-Barrak was sentenced to five years in prison for allegedly insulting the Emir. (Photo Courtesy of Ahram Online)

In Kuwait, criticizing the emir is a crime, and carries a maximum penalty of five years in jail.  Barrack allegedly committed the crime on October fifteenth, at the height of a standoff between the government and former lawmakers over a decree that amended the 2006 voter law, reducing the number of candidates from four to two.  He was detained for four days in late October and was released on bail.  The government said that the amendment was necessary because it “addressed legal loopholes and brought the country in line with international election standards.”  The bill’s opposers said that “it was meant to reduce its influence and ensure the election of a rubber-stamped parliament.”  Barrak also faces trial on several other counts, including charges of storming parliament and participating in protests.

“The court has sentenced the defendant Mussallam al-Barrak to five years in prison with immediate effect,” said Judge Wael al-Atiqi, amid tight security at the Palace of Justice.  After receiving the sentence, Barrak gave a speech to his supporters, proclaiming his innocence.  “[The] ruling is illegal but I will give myself up to police if they come to pick me up,” said Barrak at his residence.  Since the sentence is set to begin immediately, police can arrest him at any time.

One of Barrak’s attorneys, Abdullah al-Ahmed, said that the ruling was moot.  “The ruling is null and void because it violated the legal procedures and for failing to provide the defense team with sufficient guarantees,” said al-Ahmed.  “We will appeal against the ruling in the appeals court.”  This is not the first time that Barrak’s attorneys had shown their frustrations with the Palace of Justice.  On April 8, they walked out of the court when Judge al-Atqi refused to hear the defense team’s witnesses.

Hundreds of Barrak’s supporters rushed to his Al-Andalus residence, 12 miles away from Kuwait City, to show their support after the sentence.  Activists have agreed to hold a demonstration in protest of the ruling next Monday.  Former MPs also visited Barrak’s residence to show their support.  “The ruling is purely political… far away from the principles of justice.”

Recently, Kuwait has not been hesitant to throw opposition supporters in prison, especially those who have used social media to voice their criticisms. One activist was sentenced to ten years in prison after he was convicted of using Twitter to insult the Emir.

For further information, please see:

Ahram Online — Kuwait Opposition Leader Jailed for ‘Insulting’ Emir Sheikh Sabah — 15 April 2013

Al Arabiya — Kuwaiti Opposition Leader Jailed for 5 Years for Insulting Emir — 15 April 2013

Al Jazeera — Kuwait Jails Former MP for ‘Insulting Emir’ — 15 April 2013

Gulf News — Kuwait Opposition Leader Jailed for 5 Years for Insulting Emir — 15 April 2013

No Investigation into November’s Public Slayings in Gaza

By Justin Dorman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

JERUSALEM, Israel – Four months ago, in November, seven Palestinian prisoners, who were believed to have been spies for Israel, were publicly killed and dragged through the streets for all to see. Gaza’s Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh promised to

The men who murdered and dragged the bodies of alleged collaborators through the streets have yet to be brought to justice despite promises made four months ago. (Photo Courtesy of the New York Daily News)

look into the deaths. Hamas’s deputy leader, Moussa Abu Marzouk said that the killings were unlawful, and that the murderers would be brought to justice.

International human rights group, Human Rights Watch, says that the promises to bring about justice were falsehoods. Hamas has denied the claims of Human Rights Watch. Hamas claims that the men who were killed had already been convicted by a military court before they were taken and killed. Additionally, Ihab al-Ghusain, Hamas spokesman, has claimed that the prosecutor general set up an inquiry into the murders immediately after the incident.

Human Rights Watch believes that there was injustice present at every stage of the treatment of these seven men. Their belief is that the evidence that was used to convict the seven was obtained through the illegal means of torture.

Middle East director of Human Rights Watch, Sarah Whitson exclaimed that, “even before the killings, the abuses the men suffered made the criminal justice system a travesty, regardless of their guilt or innocence.”

Furthermore, “Hamas’s inability or unwillingness to investigate the brazen murders of seven men makes a mockery of its claims that it’s upholding the rule of law in Gaza,” said Whitson.

She ultimately suggests that, “Hamas should be taking concrete steps to reform the criminal justice system and break the cycle of impunity that, as these men’s cases show, lets torturers and killers roam free.”

Human Rights Watch’s report came out on Thursday, when the amnesty period for Israeli collaborators to turn themselves in to the Palestinian authorities would come to an end. Security forces are now expected to be making sweeping arrests of alleged collaborators.

Hopefully anyone now arrested as a collaborator will be treated in conformity with justice and not tortured, killed, and paraded around town being dragged by motorcyclists.

Besides for collaborators, Hamas has also been looking to capture Israeli soldiers working the border in order to broker prisoner exchanges with Israel. Israel’s Shin Bet internal security service has said that since 2013, there have been thirty-three reported kidnapping attempts compared to just twenty-four in all of 2012.

For further information, please see:

United Press International – HRW: Hamas did not Probe Palestinian ‘Collaborator’ Deaths as Promised – 12 April 2013

BBC – Hamas Failed to Probe Palestinian ‘Collaborator’ Deaths – 11 April 2013

Jewish Press – Human Rights Watch Slamming Hamas for Ignoring Public Murders – 11 April 2013

New York Daily News – Human Rights Watch Slams Hamas for Failing to Investigate the Slaying of Seven Palestinians who Were Dragged Through the Streets of Gaza – 11 April 2013

Morsi Declares Military did not Commit Malpractice

By Justin Dorman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

CAIRO, Egypt – Impunity is defined as “exemption from punishment or freedom from the injurious consequences of an action.” Issues of impunity generally arise when a government injures its own people and refuses to punish itself. Sometimes, like in the case of modern day Egypt, a separate group will cause the injury while the government will pretend the atrocities never happened.

President Mohamed Morsi and the Egyptian military will stand together in solidarity for now. (Photo Courtesy of the Guardian)

It was just a week ago that Egypt’s president, Mohamed Morsi was covertly investigating accusations of military malpractice. Accusations of acts committed since the 2011 uprising included torture, killings, and abductions of Egyptians. Additionally, army doctors were reported to have been ordered to operate on patients without any anesthetic.

The investigation was leaked, and instead of substantiating the claims to the public, Morsi denied that any bad acts transpired that could feasibly besmirch the name of the Egyptian military. Morsi took his protection of the military one step further and actually promoted several generals to lieutenant-generals.

Morsi announced to the public, “any insult against the armed forces is an insult against all of us, and we reject any kind of insults . . . I announce this to the whole world: we appreciate the great role that the armed forces has been playing in maintaining the safety and security of this country.”

This was followed by General Abdel Fattah Sisi declaring that, “the armed forces during the last two years was very, very fond of Egypt and the people of Egypt and did not commit any malpractices what so ever.” He added, “by God I swear that the army, since 25 January 2011, did not kill and did not order to kill, did not deceive and did not order to deceive.”

Why after investigating and learning of military misconduct did Morsi defend the military so vigorously?

Because after studying the careers of Anwar Sadat and Hosni Mubarak, Morsi learned that in this game of pharaoh thrones, you either win or you die or you find yourself in Torah Prison.

Many interpret virtually all maneuvers by Morsi as power plays. Immediately after being elected, he took away a great amount of power from the military who were ruling the country.

Morsi tried to make concessions to keep the military happy by allowing them to try civilians in military court and allegedly striking a deal to stay out of their affairs in exchange for their support. Nonetheless, Morsi must have feared what Professor Robert Springborg, expert on Egyptian military feared; that with the economic situation deteriorating, and a utter lack of political stability, that amongst threats to the military, the military was eventually going to re-insert itself into Egyptian politics at the Muslim Brotherhood’s expense.

As a result of another alleged power play, Morsi’s nephew has recently been admitted into a military training academy. This has been interpreted by Springborg as a message that the Muslim Brotherhood is going to move in on the military. A keep your friends close, but your enemies even closer type of move.

Springborg may have the correct interpretation of this maneuver. Perhaps though, the boy just seeks to serve the realm of Egypt.

For further information, please see:

ABC News – Egypt top General, President Deny Army Abuse Claim – 12 April 2013

Guardian – Mohamed Morsi Backs Egyptian Military After Malpractice Allegations – 12 April 2013

Naharnet News Desk – Egpytian Protesters Operated on Without Anesthetic – 12 April 2013

New York Times – Leaked Report to Egypt’s President Implicates Army in Torture and Killing of Civilians – 10 April 2013