The Middle East

Easter in Libya, not as Joyous as Usual

By Justin Dorman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

TRIPOLI, Libya – Earlier this month, smoke billowed from Benghazi’s Coptic church, but it had nothing to do with the coming of a new pope. A group of jihadist militants set the church on fire while the church’s priest was still inside. Some local Muslims rushed in to save the priest, but the church was successfully scorched. Do not expect the church to be resurrected this Easter, because currently any action that can be perceived to threaten Islamic culture is being met with plenty of hostility in Libya.

St. Mark’s Coptic church in Benghazi was set ablaze and is now a blackened ruin. (Photo Courtesy of the Guardian)

Hide your bibles, hide your faith, because the Islamic militants and Office of Preventive Security are getting every Christian. Whether a Coptic Christian or one of the Greek Orthodox faith, it has been recommended that you keep your Easter celebration low key. While many Muslims in Libya are very friendly with their Christian neighbors, others get very offended by anything non-Islamic.

Besides the burning of Benghazi’s Coptic church, there was a bombing of a Coptic church in Misrata killing two, and a shooting of a Greek Orthodox priest outside of his home. Additionally, at least fifty-one Christians, forty-nine of which were Copts, have been arrested. One of the Copts died while being held in detention. An evangelist warehouse was also raided, which resulted in the seizure of approximately fifty-five thousand Bibles and Christian tracts.

The surviving arrested Copts were released as a “diplomatic gesture.” Preventive security commander Abdul Salam Barghathi was amazed that the bibles were being printed in the city of Benghazi and that they were even being given to children.

The official causes of the arrests have come under charges of proselytizing and spreading Christian literature. Barghathi said that, “Libya is 100 per cent Muslim, we don’t have Christians and Jews, and nobody will accept any other religions.” He added that, “anything that comes from abroad can be an invasion against our ideas and our thoughts, which can be a danger to homeland security.”

Reverend Vasihar Baskaran of Tripoli’s Christ the King church stated that, “we usually celebrate [Easter] with pomp, but I said no. . .I thought it was better not to attract the attention of bad elements. I told the congregation: when the service is finished, don’t stand in the churchyard and drink tea on the church steps.”

An Egyptian Christian living in Benghazi, Meged Labib, said that she will have her Easter services in her home since her priest has ran back to Egypt.

For further information, please see:

Scotsman – Libyan Christians Spending Easter in Fear – 30 March 2013

Bloomberg – Libya’s Christians Tense as Easter Celebrations Commence – 29 March 2013

Guardian – Christians in Libya Braced for Easter Trouble from Islamists – 29 March 2013

Radio Vaticana – Libyan Christians Prepare for Holy Week Amid Persecution – 25 March 2013

Syrian Opposition Opens its First Embassy

By Ali Al-Bassam
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

DOHA, Qatar — The Syrian National Coalition (SNC) opened the doors to its first “embassy” in Qatar last Wednesday, just a day after the Arab League granted it recognition by giving it Damascus’s seat in the league.

SNC leader al-Khatib was in Doha, Qatar for the ribbon cutting ceremony of the Syrian rebel’s embassy. (Photo Courtesy of Al Jazeera)

The head of the SNC, Ahmed Moaz al-Khatib, and Qatari State Minister for Foreign Affairs, Khaled Al-Attiya, were at the embassy in Doha for the inauguration of the representative office, dubbed the “Embassy of the Syrian National Coalition.”  “This is the first embassy of the Syrian people,” said al-Khatib.  Al-Khatib said that the SNC’s next goal is to assume Syria’s seat in the United Nations.  Al-Khatib also used the ribbon cutting ceremony as a platform to voice his frustration with global powers for failing to do more to assist the SNC with toppling Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s regime.  “There is an international willingness for the revolution not to triumph,” said al-Khatib.

NATO Chief Anders Fogh Rasmussen said last Wednesday that a political solution to the Syrian crisis must shapen, but ruled out Western military intervention despite Khatib’s plea.

The SNC named Nizar Haraki as its first ambassador to Qatar.  Haraki said that he will “soon” present his accreditation letter to the Emir of Qatar.  The SNC also named envoys in several countries including Britain, France, Libya, Turkey, and the United States, but has not yet proceeded with opening diplomatic missions in those countries.

Russia scolded the Arab League for taking “another anti-Syria step,” when the league recognized the SNC.  Russian Foreign Ministry Spokesman Aleksandr Lukashevich said, “In terms of international law, the decisions taken by the Arab League in respect of Syria are illegal and void because the government of the Syrian Arab Republic was and will remain the legitimate representative of the UN member state.”  Russia also said that the Arab League is supporting a “military solution” to the conflict instead of peace talks.

Iran also criticized the move, calling it illegitimate, and a “dangerous precedent” set by the Arab League.  “Handing Syria’s seat to the so-called provisional government is a danagerous precedent by the memberes of the Arab League,” said Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Salehi.

The original Syrian embassy’s doors were closed in November 2011, when diplomatic ties with the Gulf countries were severed after Syria rejected the Arab League’s peace proposal to end its campaign of violence against demonstrators, and instead resorted to a bloody crackdown on the rebellion.  The embassy continues to remain inactive.

For further information, please see:

Al Jazeera — Syria Opposition Opens Embassy in Qatar — 28 March 2013

Arab News — Syrian Opposition Opens ‘Embassy’ in Qatar — 28 March 2013

Global Times — Coalition Opens Syrian Embassy — 28 March 2013

Al Shorfa — Syrian Opposition Opens Office in Qatar — 27 March 2013

All Voices — Syrian Rebels Open new ‘Embassy’ in Qatar — 27 March 2013

Global Post — Syria Rebels Open ‘Embassy’ in Qatar — 27 March 2013

Ya Libnan — Syrian Opposition gets the Embassy in Qatar — 27 March 2013

Ahwazi Arabs Hunger Strike After Death Sentence

By Justin Dorman
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

TEHRAN, Iran – It is not easy to be an Ahwazi Arab in Iran. Negative treatment in the arenas of education, employment, and culture have led many angered Ahwazis to demonstrate and some to call for separation. Iranian authorities have not appreciated such protests and have sentenced to death and killed a handful like Abd al-Rahman Heidarian, Taha Heidarian, and Jamshid Heidarian after an allegedly unfair trial. Five more men, Mohammad Ali Amouri, Hashem Sha’bani Amouri, Hadi Rashidi, Sayed Jaber Alboshoka, and Sayed Mokhtar Alboshoka have recently been sentenced to death after another highly questionable trial.

The five Ahwazi men pictured above have been sentenced to death and are now in the midst of a dry hunger strike in efforts to get an appeal. (Photo Courtesy of Payvand Iran News)

The Amouris, Alboshokas, and Rashidi, a few of which are teachers, all co-founded the cultural institute known as Al-Hiwar. The group organized conferences, poetry recitals, and arts and education classes before being banned in 2005. Since its ban, many former Al-Hiwar members have been arrested.

The five men have been charged under the vague claims of “enmity against God and corruption on Earth”, “gathering and colluding against state security”, and “spreading propaganda against the system.” These charges arise as of an alleged linkage between the men and a terrorist group who was involved in a shooting around Ramshir. Currently, no evidence was ever made public which showed any support of the allegations these five men faced. Additionally, their trials were held completely behind closed doors.

In an effort to protest their hunger strike and previous mistreatment while being detained in Karoun prison, the five men began a hunger strike. While being held, despite their requests, the men were denied medical examination and treatment. The need for treatment is believed to be as a means to treat injuries resulting from torture.

The torture was believed to be used to coerce confessions, false or true, out of the detained. These confessions are also often broadcast on television before a trial even begins. Such actions violate Article 38 of the Iranian Constitution and Article 9 of the Law on Respect for Legitimate Freedoms and Safeguarding Citizen’s Rights. The broadcasts violate trial obligations under Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Iran is a party.

Hunger strikes often lead to negative publicity for the authoritarian regime which often has its hand forced to undo its previous action. To prevent that from happening, prison authorities banned the hunger striking Ahwazis from making or receiving phone calls. Eventually, families of the strikers were allowed to visit and were able to convince the detained men to begin drinking water again. Currently, they are still refusing to eat solid food.

For further information, please see:

Ahwaz News Agency – Profile of a Hero: Mohammad Ali Amouri – 28 March 2013

Guardian – Iranian Ahwazi Arabs on Hunger Strike Over Death Sentences -27 March 2013

Amnesty International – Urgent Action Dead row Ahwazi Arab men on Hunger Strike – 26 March 2013

Payvand Iran News – Iran: Death row Prisoners in Ahwaz Begin Hunger Strike – 9 March 2013

Jordan Charges ‘Devil Worship’ Students With Incitement

By Ali Al-Bassam
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

AMMAN, Jordan — Last Wednesday, Jordanian prosecutors charged five Al al-Bayt University students with incitement, for allegedly desecrating the Quran and engaging in acts of “devil worship.”  The students had been detained for fifteen days, since March 12, 2013, and were charged by prosecutors after Human Rights Watch (HRW) urged the Jordanian government to either charge or release them.  If convicted, the students could face up to three years in prison.  The students deny the accusation.

Five university students were detained, and eventually charged with incitement, after rumors claiming that they had ripped up a Quran in a bathroom had spread. (Photo Courtesy of Al Bawaba.)

They were accused of ripping and burning Quran manuscripts while performing a “religious ritual” in a campus bathroom in the city of Mafraq.  Prior to being detained, the students were assaulted by a crowd of other students when rumors had spread about their involvement in the act.  A sister of one of the students claimed that a mob of 200 other  students had attacked the accused, which is comprised of her sister and four male students.

HRW released a statement from the students’ families, which said that “no evidence of criminal activity had been presented to the accused.”  HRW said that Jordanian authorities should actively do their best to protect the students and arrest anyone who allegedly attacked and threatened them.  “Jordanian authorities should release the five students and take steps to protect them from further attack,” said Eric Goldstein, deputy Middle East Director at HRW.  “The authorities should hold to account anyone who joined in this witch hunt and committed acts of violence.  They should not be allowed to walk free while their victims are locked up.”

HRW also urged Jordanian authorities to investigate reported remarks that advocated the students’ deaths, such as those made by a well-known Salafi shaikh.  Salafists are an ultra-conservative group derived from the Sunni sect of Islam.  HRW believes that these remarks have sparked a chain reaction of Facebook messages by other university students calling for the death of their fellow students.  HRW says that such messages have “prompted fears for their safety and doubts about whether they will be able to complete their university studies in Jordan.”

International law, and Jordan’s treaty obligations as a member of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) requires Jordan to take reasonable steps in ensuring that the right to security for all people within Jordan is protected.  Jordan is also required to uphold the rights to freedom, expression and thought, conscience, and religion.  This establishes that it must not prosecute people who peacefully express their views, and must protect those who do from others who coercively try to curb their expressions of opinion and religious belief.

Al-Rai, a Jordanian newspaper, reported that the president of the university had established an investigative committee to determine the truth as to whether the students were involved in “throwing manuscripts of the Quran in the toilets.”  The head of the investigative committee informed a news website, Kharbani, that it could not find any evidence that the students had committed such acts, and also said that none of the statements against them were based on first-hand evidence.

For further information, please see:

Al Bawaba — Jordan Charges Students With Incitement After Claims of “Devil Worship” — 27 March 2013

The Raw Story — Jordan Charges Students With ‘Devil Worship’ — 27 March 2013

Al Jazeera — Jordan Urged to Free ‘Devil Worship’ Students — 26 March 2013

Human Rights Watch — Jordan: Students Accused of ‘Devil Worship’ — 26 March 2013

Human Rights Groups Condemn UAE Pretrial Conditions

By Dylan Takores
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

ABU DHABI, United Arab Emirates – A coalition of human rights groups condemned allegedly “unfair” pretrial conditions imposed upon ninety-four political activists set for trial in the UAE’s Supreme Court.

International observers and journalists barred from viewing trial proceedings. (Photo Courtesy of BBC)

Reportedly “credible” sources informed the trial judge, Falah Al Hajiri, that the detainees were subjected to torture while in detention.  The coalition of human rights groups issued a report arguing that the judge breached his obligation to prevent pretrial torturing by failing to investigate the allegations.

The activists were arrested in a series of raids last year by UAE authorities and are charged with planning a coup against the government.  The government further alleged that the activists possess ties to Al-Ishlah, a group associated with the Muslim Brotherhood.

The coalition consists primarily of four human rights groups: the Gulf Centre for Human Rights, the International Federation for Human Rights, the Arab Network for Human Rights Information, and the Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies.

The coalition issued an initial statement opposing the ongoing “crackdown” on citizens’ freedom of speech in January, 2013.  They issued a report yesterday exposing “flagrant disregard of fair trial guarantees.”  The report primarily contended that the judge should have investigated the possible incidences of pretrial torture.

Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East Director of Human Rights Watch, claimed the “shamelessly unfair judicial process . . . makes a mockery of justice.”  Whitson reported that the government targeted and arrested prominent human rights leaders including lawyers, judges, teachers, and students.

In addition, members of Reporters Without Borders voiced their concern regarding the lack of the trial’s media coverage.  The Emirati government imposed a news blackout, refusing to allow international reporters to observe any part of the trial.  The government did not permit family members of the detainees to witness the fifth and most recent trial proceeding.

UAE Attorney General Ali Salim al-Tenaji denied that the detainees were tortured.  He maintained that authorities treated the detainees in “accordance to the law.”

If convicted, the activists could receive up to fifteen years in jail.  The activists do not have the right to appeal the court’s decision.  The next proceeding will take place today at the Federal Supreme Court in the nation’s capital.

 

For further information, please see:

BBC News –Human rights groups: UAE trial ‘flagrantly unfair’  – 26 March 2013

Gulf News – UAE Human rights group attends trial of 94 accused of threatening national security – 25 March 2013

Reporters Without Borders – News blackout imposed on trial of 94 activists on national security charges – 25 March 2013

Al Jazeera – UAE coup plot trial begins in Abu Dhabi – 4 March 2013

Reporters Without Borders – Human rights groups call for an end to the crackdown on human rights defenders and political activists as UPR begins – 28 January 2013