Uncategorized

Syrian Revolution Digest – Sunday 24 June 2012

THE COMMENTARY IN THIS PIECE DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE VIEWS OF IMPUNITY WATCH.  

*WARNING VIDEOS MAY CONTAIN GRAPHIC IMAGES*

Paper-Tigers & Wimps!

They talk tough but remain missing in action: Turkish and Western leaders better spare us their sympathy is it don’t come with an action plan that can stop Assad NOW.

Sunday June 24, 2012

The average daily death toll is now close to 150, and the worst is yet to come, with more pro-Assad militias perpetrating more and more massacres, selling more and more towns throughout the country.

News

The circumstances of the deaths were not immediately clear, with the state-run news agency saying at least 25 men were killed. In the video — which The Associated Press could not independently verify — the narrator said the victims were members of the “shabiha,” or pro-regime gunmen… It was not clear whether the men were killed execution-style or died in clashes. An activist in the area, Mohammed Saeed, said rebels regularly collect the bodies of the dead from the government side and dump them by the side of the road so troops can collect them later.

Op-Eds & Special Reports

More coverage of AEI Event on Syria, June 18, 2012

“The country is being partitioned.  Waiting will allow for the partitioning to actually take effect.  There will be repercussions that will be felt in Lebanon, in Iraq, in Jordan, in Turkey and perhaps even in Israel as well,” Syrian pro-democracy activist Ammar Abdulhamid said. (Video)

Turkey – A Paper Tiger on the Mediterranean

After making so many on promises on Syria, like vowing not to allow Hama, only to stand and watch the retaking of Hama, and the endless slaughter that followed and to watch on helplessly as Assad troops pursued refugees even inside Turkey’s borders, the downing of a Turkish fighter jet by Assad’s air defenses, mostly likely operated under guidance of Russian experts, and Erdogan’s confused reaction to the matter serve only to consolidate the emerging image of Turkey as nothing more than a paper tiger.

With its continued reliance on Iranian gas supplies, continued problems between the political and military leaderships, and continued inability to effectively address its Kurdish Question, not to mention its Alevi Question the mere enunciation of which remains a taboo, the image of a regional powerhouse that Turkey has been to project over the last few years seem highly exaggerated. Turkey is simply not ready, politically, economically, or militarily, to be a serious player on the regional scene, consideration of Turkish pride notwithstanding. Her leaders are advised to reflect this reality in their pronouncements to avoid having more egg on their faces, and to avoid the continued embarrassment of having to appear nothing more than mustachioed wimps even when confronted by the region’s lankiest and weakest link: Bashar Al-Assad.

U.S. Policy on Syria – another example of wimpishness in action

The interview below with Secretaries Clinton and Baker outline the current U.S. policy on Syria. At the heart of the policy is he continued preoccupation with Iran’s nuclear ambitions, and the belief that Russia can help find a solution for this, hence the unwillingness to anger Russians over Syria and the push for so-called political transition with Nicaragua rather than Yemen providing the model for that. But with no talk of serious enforcement mechanisms, any talk of political solutions risks going in the same direction of the Arab League and Annan plans, and will only buy Assad more time to keep killing and ensuring the de facto partition of the country.

Interview With Charlie Rose of “Conversations on Diplomacy”
Hillary Rodham Clinton Secretary of State, Former Secretary of State James A. Baker III 
Benjamin Franklin Room
Washington, DCJune 20, 2012

SECRETARY CLINTON: On Syria, so far they’ve taken Russia’s lead on Syria. But we’re working on that every single day as well.

MR. ROSE: Why did they do that? Why do they take Russia’s lead?

SECRETARY CLINTON: Well, I think both Russia and China have a very strong aversion to interference in internal affairs.

MR. ROSE: Sovereignty issue.

SECRETARY CLINTON: Yes.

SECRETARY BAKER: Yeah.

SECRETARY CLINTON: And so for the Russians, we – I was with President Obama in Mexico two days ago. We had a two-hour meeting with President Putin. They’re just – they don’t want anything to do with it. They find it quite threatening, and basically they reject it out of hand. So anything that smacks of interference for the Russians and for the Chinese, they presume against. There are other reasons, but that’s the principal objection that they make.

MR. ROSE: Would coming – both different countries and different points, but they somehow come together on these issues – Syria and with respect to Russia and the role they are playing.

SECRETARY BAKER: Yeah, yeah.

MR. ROSE: And the role that the United States is playing and the role that the region can play. What should we be doing and what is the risk of not doing?

SECRETARY BAKER: Well, I’ll answer that in just a minute. But first let me say if we’re going to have differences with Russia – and we do have some differences with Russia – it seems to me the most important difference we might have is with respect to Iran. And we don’t have that now, and that’s really important. And I don’t think we ought to create a problem with Russia vis-a-vis what we want to do in Iran about their nuclear ambitions as a result of something we might do in Syria. I just think the Iranian issue there is far more important really than how we resolve the Syrian issue.

How should we resolve the Syrian issue? I think we should continue to support a political transition in the government in Syria. But I don’t – but I think we ought to support it diplomatically, politically, and economically in every way that we can, but we should be very leery, extremely leery, about being drawn in to any kind of a military confrontation or exercise.

MR. ROSE: Does that include supplying them with arms?

SECRETARY BAKER: That – well, that’s a slippery slope. The fact of the matter is a lot of our allies are already supplying them with arms. Okay? It’s not something –

MR. ROSE: And our friends in the region.

SECRETARY BAKER: Well, I say our allies in the region. Yeah, they’re doing it. And it’s not something we have to do. I look at Syria and I think why are we not calling for something that we – this is – it may not be the right comparison, but in 1989, when we came into office, the wars in Central America were the holy grail of the left, political left in this country, and the holy grail of the political right in this country. We said if we can take these wars out of domestic politics, we can cure the foreign policy problem, and we did.

How did we do it? We put it to both parties – Daniel Ortega, the hardline, authoritarian dictator, if you will, in Nicaragua, and to Violeta Chamorro, the opposition candidate. We said if you’ll hold an election and both agree to abide by the results, that’s the way we’ll get out of this conundrum. That’s what happened. And both of them did agree, finally, to abide by the results. Ortega lost. President Carter was very instrumental in getting him to leave office. Why don’t we try something like that in Syria, I mean, and say look, political transition is what we’re looking for. Everybody – even the Russians, I think – would have difficulty saying no, we’re not going to go for an election, particularly if you let Bashar run. Let him run. Make sure you have a lot of observers in there. Make sure they can’t fix the election. Why not try that?

MR. ROSE: Why not try that?

SECRETARY CLINTON: Well, actually, that is the path that we are trying. And I spoke with Kofi Annan again today. He is working on a political transition roadmap. We are somewhat disadvantaged by the fact that I think Assad still believes he can crush what he considers to be an illegitimate rebellion against his authority and characterizes everyone who opposes him as a terrorist who is supported by foreign interests. He’s not yet at the point where he understands his legitimacy is gone and he is on a downward slope.

The other problem we have is that the opposition has not yet congealed around a figure or even a group that can command the respect and attention internally within Syria as well as internationally. So what we’re doing is, number one, putting more economic pressure, because that is important, and the sanctions and trying to cut off the Syrian regime, and send a message to the Syrian business class, which so far has stuck with Assad.

We’re also working very hard to try to prop up and better organize the opposition. We’ve spent a lot of time on that. It still is a work in progress. We are also pushing hard on having Kofi Annan lay down a political transition roadmap and then getting a group of nations, that would include Russia, in a working group to try to sell that to both the Assad regime and to the opposition .

So, I mean, the path forward is exactly as Jim has described it. Getting the people and the interests on that path has been what we’ve been working on now for several months.

MR. ROSE: Who would be in that group other than the United States, Russia? Who else?

SECRETARY CLINTON: Well, you would have to have the Arab League because Kofi Annan is a joint envoy of both the UN and the Arab League. You would have to have the permanent members of the Security Council because that’s who he represents in his UN role. And you’d have to have the neighbors. You’ve got to have Turkey involved because of their long border and their very clear interests. But when I spoke with him today, he’s going to be making another proposal to the Russians, the Turks, and other interested groups to try to get them to agree on this roadmap and then a meeting, in effect to go public with it, so that we can increase the pressure not only on the Assad regime but on the opposition as well.

MR. ROSE: Is there a role for Iran?

SECRETARY CLINTON: At this point, it would be very difficult for Iran to be initially involved. I mean, I’m a big believer in talking to people when you can and trying to solve problems when you can. But right now, we’re focused on dealing with Iran and the nuclear portfolio. That has to be our focus. Iran’s always trying to get us to talk about anything else except their nuclear program.

And then we also have the added problem that Iran is not just supporting Assad, they are helping him to devise and execute the very plans that he is following to suppress, oppress the opposition.

SECRETARY BAKER: If you get the – you’re going to get the attention of the Russians and the Chinese, in my view, in the Security Council if you come with some sort of a proposal for a political transition that might involve an election, if you’re willing to say anybody and everybody can run. That means, of course, you got to make sure that the election is not fixed. But that would put a lot of pressure – the only reason I mention this, it seems to be that would put a lot of pressure on the Russians to support this idea.

With respect to Iran, I agree with the Secretary. This is not the place to involve them. However, I would think there might be a place for them in a group with respect to Afghanistan. They helped us when we first went in there. We talked to them. They were helpful.

Chilean Protestors Clash Against Police at Violent Demonstration

By Heba Girgis
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

SANTIAGO, Chile — On June 10, 2012, Chilean police clashed with anti-Pinochet protesters in the streets of Chile’s capital city of Santiago. The demonstration took place outside of a theater that had released a documentary of the former dictator’s life and rule. The mayor of Santiago said that hundreds of anti-Pinochet demonstrators organized in the city and continued to launch what he called “coordinated attacks” in the city’s center hours after the screening at the Caupolican Theater.

Hundreds of Chileans Protest Screening of Documentary of Chile's Former Dictator. (Photo Courtesy of The New York Times).

In September 1973, Pinochet, a general at the time, led a coup against the current democratically elected president, Salvador Allende. Pinochet remained in power until 1990.

During his reign, the Chilean government estimated that more than 3,000 people were killed, including those whose bodies were never found. Also during his rule, many Chilean citizens were arrested, tortured or exiled from the country. Researches have also documented about 37,000 cases of torture and illegal detention under Pinochet’s regime.

Pinochet, who died in 2006, at the age of 91, was never sentenced for human rights abuses during his rule.

The film, honoring the former dictator, triggered a violent response. Five hundred police officers responded to the demonstrations dressed in full riot gear and equipped with tear gas and water cannons that were used against the civilians. The clash between police and anti-Pinochet protestors lasted about two hours, injuring twenty-two people and resulting in sixty-four arrests.

Regarding the law enforcement response, Mireya Garcia, vice president of the Association of Relatives of Detained and Disappeared (AFDD) said “the police are limiting our activity in order to allow activities in honor of the dictator. This is paying tribute to a criminal.” While, on the other side, supporters of Pinochet’s regime held posters with Pinochet’s photograph and the word “thanks” written underneath.

This controversial event, which brought out both supporters and protestors alike, caused one of the most violent demonstrations in Chile in recent years. Some find that this is a ceremony to honor history, while others bore signs that read “we cannot pay tribute to a murderer.”

Despite the controversial topic of the event and the documentary, the film named after the former ruler and directed by Ignacio Zegers received the prize “Hispana de Oro,” meaning “Hispanic Gold,” at the International Festival of Great Hispanoamerican Film last March.

 

For further information, please see:

France 24 – Chile Clashes Over Pinochet Tribute Documentary – 11 June 2012

BBC – Chilean Police Clash With Anti-Pinochet Demonstrators – 10 June 2012

The Star – Pinochet Documentary Heats up Chile’s Debate Over Dictator’s Legacy – 10 June 2012

Santiago Times – Chilean Government Will not Stop Screening of Pinochet Documentary – 6 June 2012

Syrian Revolution Digest – Friday 8 June 2012

THE COMMENTARY IN THIS PIECE DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE VIEWS OF IMPUNITY WATCH.  

*WARNING VIDEOS MAY CONTAIN GRAPHIC IMAGES*

Genocide Foretold!

 

The killing will not stop unless it is stopped. We are now standing a breath away from full-blown genocide, because world leaders failed to act last year. By acting now they could still prevent genocide, but the wounds that have already been carved in our souls will take decades to heel. And if they failed to act still, then the blood is on their hands too.

 

Friday June 08, 2012 – This week is dedicated to the solidarity between the business communities and the revolutionaries.

 

Today’s death toll: 85. This is only a preliminary estimate, as the death toll from Daraa City is still unclear. The Breakdown: 18 in Idlib, 34 in Daraa, 12 in Homs, 11 in Damascus Suburbs, 6 in Damascus City, 3 in Hama and 1 in Deir Ezzor.

 

In Damascus City, clashes between the local resistance and Assad loyalists took place in the neighborhoods of Qaboun, Barzeh, Kafar Sousseh, Jobar and Mazzeh. Meanwhile, the pounding of old Sunni neighborhoods in Homs City continues unabated.

 

Muqtada Al-Sadr, leader of the Mahdi Army in Iraq conceded today the possibility that members of his group could indeed be taking part in the crackdown against the democracy movement in Syria. If such participation is indeed proven, Al-Sadr said, then these members must be considered as defectors used by external parties.

 

News

 

 

Syria conflict driving more to flee homes-ICRC * Access to food and medical services hampered * Infrastructure needing urgent repair * ICRC, Red Crescent supplied food, medicine to 400,000 Syrians

 

 

Syria massacre: UN observers greeted by smell of rotting flesh The sight that met the first United Nations observers to visit the Syrian hamlet of al-Qubeir yesterday was of homes gutted and burned. The smell in the air was rotting flesh.

 

Gun battles rage in streets of Damascus Syrian army and opposition fighters clash in capital’s Mezze neighbourhood, as monitors reach al-Qubeyr massacre site.

 

 

 

Op-Eds & Special Reports

 

Along Syria’s volatile border, rebels, rabbits, and ambushes A Lebanese gas smuggler was killed in a Syrian Army ambush this week, snapping the patience of locals in the Lebanese town of Arsal. Another ambush targeted rabbit hunters.

 

 

Editor’s note: Hind Aboud Kabawat is a Syrian attorney. She is also a conflict resolution specialist and senior research analyst at the Center for World Religions, Diplomacy and Conflict Resolution, which is based at George Mason University in Virginia. The views expressed in this article are solely those of Hind Aboud Kabawat: “I am a devout Christian, proud and respectful of the church’s teachings. But in the political realm, I am first and foremost a citizen, a citizen of the new free Syria. I believe that my fellow Christians will come to feel the same way. I also believe the same should be true for our Sunni, Alawite, Druze and Kurdish sisters and brothers.”

 

 

Beyond the humanitarian disaster that Syria has become, the strategic damage that could result from the nightmare scenarios that could transpire in Syria should concentrate the minds of U.S. strategists. If it takes American-led intervention to prevent them, then that is where discussion of U.S. policy should begin. Time is not an ally.

 

Over 750 rallies took place all across Syria today, with hundreds of thousands of protesters defying pro-Assad militias and risking their lives to reiterate their rejection of Assad rule. Meanwhile, Assad and his militias continue to wage war against the people.

 

Video Highlights

 

Daraa

 

Live Video showing the clashes currently taking place in Daraa City can be found herehttp://bambuser.com/v/2726290 Basically, Daraa is now the second Homs.

 

Daraa City: In what seems as retaliation for the assassination of Colonel Mohammad Aslan, one of the architects of the crackdown in Daraa province, loyalist troops today bombarded the downtown areas of Daraa City known as Daraa Al-Balad, killing close to 34 inhabitants, as of latest count – the dead and injured http://youtu.be/M_HfGhFh5_ghttp://youtu.be/2pzUcf6Agvc , http://youtu.be/LhYPNvSmsA4 ,http://youtu.be/Hzq9oZhlZZY , http://youtu.be/9QQIVk2ImjQ , http://youtu.be/-dvNHzBcApk , http://youtu.be/rcAZEAJczrQ , http://youtu.be/OB5qcNqIQ5c ,http://youtu.be/vULg3g6YHC0 A child among the martyrs http://youtu.be/WG5jfg3lCKg The city gets pounded again at night
 Pulling the body of a child from the streethttp://youtu.be/XYJW9u1da4M

 

Earlier in the day, protesters in Kashef neighborhood clash with security http://youtu.be/zKPVy8CJx4M

 

The town of Kafar Shams, Daraa Province, comes under fire http://youtu.be/YJ16pA8J3Hk Sanamein comes under fire http://youtu.be/SOb0nfBZBRU

 

Damascus

 

The neighborhood of Kafar Sousseh, Damascus City, gets pounded at dawn http://youtu.be/oFyFjGKkg0g And throughout the day http://youtu.be/ShTsFw5nqb8 ,http://youtu.be/1moFHhd4_nA , http://youtu.be/q4ITnG5o8JE

 

 

The neighborhood of Midan comes under fire during the day http://youtu.be/TEL59KftZTYAnd at night http://youtu.be/xQ1DeguyM7c Protesters remain defiant http://youtu.be/MQAvSVPpVAw in face of the crackdown http://youtu.be/vePJ2y1OUss

 

The neighborhood of al-Qadam comes under fire during the day http://youtu.be/Fb7KdFdIFWw Daytime protesters in Old Mazzeh come under fire http://youtu.be/sYg03ij4F9E The suburb of Tadamon comes under fire from snipers http://youtu.be/tBqvP8BW8mM

 

Heavy nighttime clashes take place in Barzeh neighborhood, Damascus City http://youtu.be/1DrZe92o988 , http://youtu.be/XSJm-fZsahY Same scenario is repeated inJobar http://youtu.be/VCeqjoSaanI

 

Nighttime clashes in Douma, Damascus Suburb, http://youtu.be/NpIiOz7bJ3Y Martyrs http://youtu.be/7AfBPg6neIs , http://youtu.be/AdjdvkOD1F8

 

Jdeidet Artouz: Martyrs http://youtu.be/gtcidXEbiU4

 

Lattakia

 

Lattakia City: Al-Ramel al-Janoubi, a majority-Sunni neighborhood, comes under fire at night http://youtu.be/N8yawCUb6wo The same scenario is repeated in Sleibeh Neighborhood http://youtu.be/3lqRpR89h7g , http://youtu.be/6sR6c1Sja40 Earlier, a peaceful daytime rally is fired at http://youtu.be/WMvo6NochlY

 

In the town of Hiffeh, activists show the impact of the continuing pounding http://youtu.be/ru7OOTIXPgI , http://youtu.be/ftjA08w3GLA ,http://youtu.be/SCumjotY39c

 

Homs

 

 

Pounding of the nearby town of Qusayr leaves several dead and many injured, including this child http://youtu.be/0xa9iZYY94A

 

Aleppo

 

Protesters in Al-Shaar Neighborhood, Aleppo City, come under fire http://youtu.be/H0mjm22obOE

 

Protesters in Salaheddine, Aleppo City, come under fire but remain defiant http://youtu.be/r9YSiK1ksy4 , http://youtu.be/yiQJKWNRGXU

 

Hama

 

A new video of Qubeir Massacre http://youtu.be/WqfcLTmwEmo

 

Idlib

 

The video of the massacre at Hammameh which I listed yesterday, has been translated by the Guardian and can be accessed here for clarity:http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/middle-east-live/2012/jun/08/syria-bashar-al-assad#block-27

 

Syrian Network for Human Rights: Massive Shelling and Violent Attacks at Al-Houla Leaves 107 Dead

Al-Houla Plains Flooded with Blood

On 25 May 2012, Al-Houla plains witnessed the most brutal massacre since the arrival of the international observers in Syria. Random shelling targeted the villages and lands of al-Houla particularly the town of Taldo which lies at the western entrance of al-Houla and is surrounded by pro-regime villages.

The shelling, which lasted for 14 hours, left 11 people dead and dozens injured. Subsequently, army and security forces along with shabiha from the villages of Fulla and al-Qabou stormed into many houses at the outskirts of Taldou.

Shabiha forces carried out raids and extra-judicial executions against all residents at the outskirts of the town. Children were handcuffed and gathered with many men and women who were all subsequently slaughtered with bayonets. Shabiha militias then opened fire on the slaughtered victims, acts reminiscent of the dark ages and the law of the jungle.

The preliminary death toll of al-Houla massacre currently stands at 107 victims whose full names and photos have been documented. There remain many bodies that could not be reached and documented as yet. Among the casualties are 49 children under the age of 10 and 32 women.

 

WARNING: SOME OF THE VIDEOS BELOW CONTAIN GRAPHIC IMAGES

 

A video showing some of the victims of the brutal shelling and massacre, including very young children.

 

A video showing some of those wounded from the attack.

 

International visitors arrive in Al-Houla following the massacre and are swarmed by residents relating what has occurred.

 

The mass burial for the victims of the massacre.

 

For further information, please see;

Syrian Network for Human Rights — Special Report on Al-Houla Massacre — 26 May 2012

 

Charles Taylor, Former Liberian President now War Criminal

By Vicki Turakhia
Impunity Watch Reporter, Africa

FREETOWN, Sierra Leone — After a five-year and  50 million dollar trial, Charles Ghankay Taylor, the 64-year old once president of Liberia, has been tried and found guilty of war crimes in Sierra Leone.

Then Liberian President Charles Taylor during the civil war. (Photo Courtesy of All Africa)

Taylor’s conduct in Sierra Leone has been cited as pivotal towards the harm caused to the citizens of Sierra Leone. His crimes included involvement in the murder, rape, sexual slavery, and recruitment of child soldiers. Charles Taylor was a rebel leader turned president of Liberia until his ultimate exile to Nigeria. During Charles Taylor’s time as president, he received blood diamonds for his participation in the killing of tens of thousands of people which he used to furnish weapons to the Revolutionary United Front (RUF).

Prosecutor Brenda Hollis, found the actions of Charles Taylor to be “purposely cruel.” Hollis has stated that Taylor was involved in the facilitation of public rapes of women and people being burned alive in their homes. Taylor’s involvement also extends to the amputation and execution of the citizens of Sierra Leone, using decapitated heads at checkpoints.

However, the defense calls Charles Taylor a scapegoat for Sierra Leone’s self-inflicted harm. Charles Taylor provided his own argument for his actions by stating that he was bringing peace to Sierra Leone and he did so with honor, he further claimed that his trial had been unjust because his witnesses had been paid to change or recant their testimony.

Taylor declared that his actions were comparable to President George W. Bush, stating that it is unfair that the United States did not prosecute President Bush for his conduct. Courtenay Griffiths, Charles Taylor’s defense barrister, argued that the International Criminal Court (ICC), is being manipulated behind the scenes, strung along by politics instead of the steadfast law. Mr. Griffiths insists that the trial, while necessary, was handled incorrectly.

Despite, the defenses’ arguments Charles Taylor was found guilty on 11 counts of aiding and abetting rebel forces. The judges of the ICC were unanimous in their decision.

The prosecution has recommended an 80-year sentence, while the defense asks for anything that would be less than a life sentence. The prosecution has found the 80-year prison sentence is justified based on the Charles Taylor’s conduct and involvement in the Sierra Leone Civil War. Taylor is to be sentenced on May 30th with a right to appeal the decision. The loss of the appeal may result in Taylor serving a sentence in a British prison as the Netherlands has only agreed to house the trial and not the prison sentence.

For more information, please see:

All Africa – Liberia:Charles Taylor Gets Sentence Tomorrow  – 29 May 2012

All Africa –  Liberia: Taylor Begs for Merciful Jail Sentence – 17 May 2012

CNN – In His Last Stand, Charles Taylor Defends Himself as a Peacemaker – 16 May 2012

BBC – Sierra Leone Trial: 80 Years Urged for Charles Taylor – 3 May 2012

BBC – Charles Taylor Guilty of Aiding Sierra Leone War Crimes – 26 April 2012