By: Jesse Elmer
Impunity Watch News Staff Writer
SAN JOSÉ, Costa Rica – The Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled that the State of Nicaragua violated political rights, judicial guarantees and judicial protection of Mr. Fabio Gadea Mantilla in the 2011 presidential elections. The IACHR determined that the judicial system of Nicaragua lacked an effective judicial remedy to review decisions.
 |
Bolivian attorney Jaime Aparicio, one of Mr. Mantilla’s representatives, discussed the importance of the ruling. He commented, “this is one of the first times the court refers to the electoral issue, meaning that it incorporates the protection of the right to be elected in free and transparent elections into human rights violations.”
This holding follows a year where the Inter-American Court of Human Rights took action on multiple fronts to protect free and fair elections in the Americas. On 30 April 2024, the IACHR released a resolution recognizing election observers as human rights defenders. This resolution mirrored recent statements issued by the UN. The IACHR also issued an extensive report regarding human rights violations in Venezuela following the presidential election of July 2024. Following the election results, the State of Venezuela under President Nicolas Maduro arrested protestors en masse, generating reports of torture and extrajudicial killings.
The IACHR’s holding came the same week as the President of Nicaragua consolidated power. President Daniel Ortega proposed widespread reform to extend executive control over judicial and legislative duties. Under these reforms, the president would have the authority to order the army to intervene to support the police or take executive branch positions. International commentators from the UN have expressed concern about the appointment of Ortega’s wife as “co-president” and a newfound ability for either co-president to name “vice presidents.” This mechanism could be used to keep the presidency of Nicaragua within the family, strengthening the autocratic regime.
For further information, please see:
IACHR – Judgment Regarding Fabio Gadea Mantilla – 23 Jan. 2025
Reuters – Nicaragua’s Ortega Expands Power as Reforms Win Final Approval – 30 Jan. 2025
