Iran: International Outcry Prompts Stay of Woman’s Stoning Execution

hasha
Photo: Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani. Photo Courtesy of AP.

By Elizabeth A. Conger
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

TEHRAN, Iran – After an outpouring of international condemnation, Iranian authorities have announced that Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, an Iranian woman convicted of adultery, will not be executed by stoning. It is not yet clear whether her death sentence has been lifted entirely, and there is speculation that Ms. Ashtiani will be hanged instead.

Mohammed Mostafaei, Ms. Ashtiani’s attorney, told The Times: “This is a positive development but nothing is clear yet . . . “There have been cases in Iran of stonings being changed to hangings.”

Ahmad Fatemi of the International Committee against Stoning and Execution, an organization that has campagined for Ms. Ashtiani’s release, said: “It’s a tactical retreat . . . they never expected this kind of pressure, so they want to buy time.”

News of the stay of her execution comes after an international campaign to prevent her death received extensive international media coverage in the past week.

Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, a forty three-year-old mother of two, has been in prison in Tabriz since 2006. She was sentenced and received ninety-nine lashes in May of 2006 for an “illicit relationship” outside of marriage.

In September of 2o06 another court reopened her adultery case amid allegations that she was involved in the murder of her husband.  She was cleared of all charges implicating her in the murder, but the second judge sentenced her again on the adultery charges – this time to death by stoning. The penalty was handed down on the basis of “judge’s knowledge.” This is a legal loophole that allows for subjective judicial rulings where no conclusive evidence is present.

Although Ms. Ashtiani retracted a confession which she was forced to make under duress, she was still found guilty.

Under Iran’s version of sharia law, sex before marriage is punishable by 100 lashes, while adultery carries a penalty of death by stoning. Convicted persons, who are almost entirely women, are buried up to their necks and stoned. If the convicted person can pull free from the pit during the stoning, the sentence will be commuted.  Men, who are only buried to their waists, are more likely to escape.

Photo: An execution by stoning which occurred after the Iranian Revolution. Photo Courtesy of Amnesty International.
Photo: An execution by stoning which occurred after the Iranian Revolution. Photo Courtesy of Amnesty International.

UK Foreign Secretary William Hague told BBC that the sentence of stoning was a “medieval punishment.” He added: “If the punishment is carried out, it will disgust and appal the watching world.” 

For more information, please see:

BBC – Iran woman escapes stoning death for adultery – 9 July 2010

CNN – Iran denying woman will be executed by stoning – 9 July 2010

MailOnline –  Iran backs down: World fury forces Tehran to spare ‘adulterous’ mother from being stoned – but will they hang her instead? – 9 July 2010

 The Guardian – Iran halts woman’s death by stoning – 8 July 2010
 

Cuba Set To Release 52 Political Prisoners

By Erica Laster                                                                                                                        Impunity Watch Reporter, North America

Havana, Cuba – Amid growing international criticism, Cuba has agreed to free fifty two political prisoners of conscience. This would mark the most political prisoners released since Pope John Paul II’s visit in 1998 which freed 101 among a group of 300 Cuban prisoners. 22 of the prisoners being released were arrested and sentenced in the infamous Black Spring crackdown of 2003.

Cuban Opposition activist Guillermo Farinas stands with the help of his doctor in Cuba
Cuban Opposition activist Guillermo Farinas stands with the help of his doctor in Cuba

Despite acting in non-violent protests, 75 were arrested in the crackdown under Cuban legislation that criminalized political dissent.

The release comes at a time when Cuba may be seeking to reset strained relations with the United States and Europe. Both have publicly condemned Cuba’s track record on human rights violations over more than a decade. President Fidel Castro agreed to release the prisoners after discussions with Cubans Foreign Minister, Bruno Rodriguez, the Roman Catholic Archbishop, Cardinal Jaime Ortega and Spanish Foreign Minister Miguel Angel Moratinos.

The political prisoners are set to be exiled in Spain, an agreement reached with Foreign Minister Moratinos to ensure their acceptance of the exiles. The release comes with deep reservations in the international community as many view the exile of the prisoners to Spain as conditional freedom and a continued restriction of their rights. “Forcing them to leave the country would be yet another attempt to suppress freedom of expression and movement in Cuba,” says Susan Lee, Americas Programme Director at Amnesty International. She further indicated that “These men have been imprisoned since 2003 simply for peacefully expressing their political beliefs and should be released unconditionally now.”

The deal follows protests by a number of the prisoners currently being held in Havana. One, Orlando Zapata recently died on February 22, 2010 after an 11 week hunger strike in which he attempted to gain the freedom of himself and his colleagues. Another, Guillermo Farinas went on a hunger strike after Mr. Zapata’s death, refusing to accept an offer of asylum from the Spanish government. Mr. Farinas strike has lasted a total of 134 days and doctors this week indicated that he was near death. His hunger strike in an attempt to force the release of 25 ill political prisoners will end he indicated, only with their release.

Cuban authorities continue to deny the existence of the repressionist regime, saying “nobody has ever been punished for merely expressing a difference of opinion or point of view, even when these have been contrary to those of the authorities.” While authorities consistently attempt to deflect pressure in the international spotlight, Amnesty International authorities have called for the prompt and fair trials of all remaining political prisoners. The 52 are scheduled to be released over the next 3 to 4 months.

Photo Courtesy of the Wall Street Journal

For More Information Please See:

Amnesty International Cuba urged to immediately release all prisoners of conscience   8 July 2010

English Pen Cuba: 52 prisoners to be freed  8 July 2010

Wall Street Journal Cuba to Free 52 Political Prisoners 8 July 2010

Ailing Tunisian TV Journalist Sentenced to Prison for Reporting Protests

By Alyxandra Stanczak
Impunity Watch Reporter, Middle East

Fahem Boukadous Reporting - Image courtesy of Dublin City University Journalism Society
Fahem Boukadous Reporting – Image courtesy of Dublin City University Journalism Society

TUNIS, Tunisia –Fahem Boukadous, a television journalist for the Tunisian station Al-Hiwar al-Tunisi, was sentenced to four years in jail for reporting information which the government claims threatened public order. He was also convicted on charges that he belonged to a criminal organization. These charges were brought against Boukadous after he reported on violent labor protests caused by high unemployment rates, high costs of living, and corruption in Tunisia’s Gafsa mining region in 2008.

Boukadous, who has been hospitalized with severe asthma, was tried in absentia. Tunisian authorities reportedly tried to pressure hospital staff to release him so that he could be present for his trial.

He is the third Tunisian journalist to be sentenced to prison in less than ten months. The two other journalists imprisoned, Zouhair Makhlouf and Taoufik Ben Brik, were sentenced to three and six months in jail respectively.

The Tunisian government is considered to be relatively progressive on a variety of other social issues, such as women’s rights. However, the government still retains strict control over the media and maintains a strong police presence in the nation.

The lobbying group, Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), has condemned the court’s decision, and has stated that Boukadous was being punished for “reporting the news.”  Additionally, CPJ’s Deputy Director Robert Mahoney called on “Tunisian authorities [to] halt their constant harassment of independent and critical journalists.”

Because of Boukadous’ health, he has been allowed to remain in the hospital pending the result of his appeal. The court, however, has refused to delay the appeal despite a doctor’s certificate explaining his respiratory problems and hospitalization.

Mohamed Abbou, his lawyer, said he feared that Boukadous could be arrested and taken from the hospital “at any moment.”

For more information, please see:

Associated Press – Court upholds sentence for Tunisian Journalist – 7 July 2010

BBC News – Tunisia to jail sick journalist Fahem Boukadous – 7 July 2010

CPJ – CPJ condemns prison term against Tunisian TV journalist – 6 July 2010

China Executes Senior Justice Official Wen Qiang

David L. Chaplin II
Impunity Watch Reporter, Asia

BEIJING, China – Wen Qiang, 55, former director of the Chongqing Justice Bureau in the Chongqing region and highest ranking official also an ex-deputy police chief, was sentenced to death in April on massive corruption charges, for sponsoring and protecting five gangs as well as rape and taking bribes.

Chinese Highest Ranking Official Executed on Massive Corruption Charges
Chinese Highest Ranking Official Executed on Massive Corruption Charges

He was executed in Chongqing, the state-run Xinhua news agency reported on Wednesday.

Wen’s case was part of a huge operation that exposed illegal activities in Chongqing, a city of more than 30 million people, as well as highlighting China’s problem of rampant official corruption.

The crackdown resulted in more than 3,300 detentions and hundreds of prosecutions, including the trials of nearly 100 officials.  Several people have already reportedly been executed or sentenced to death in the trials.

Wen allegedly raped a number of women including film and music personalities, as well as having affairs with subordinates.

He was also found guilty of taking more than 12 million yuan ($2 million U.S.) in bribes and engaging in a range of corrupt activities.

At his trial in February, Wen admitted he took money from others on numerous occasions but said that no corruption was involved and much of it was for “birthday and New Year” greetings, according to state media.

Wen was tried with his wife, Zhou Xiaoya, and three former Chongqing police associates, all of whom received jail sentences of up to 20 years.

Last November, Wen’s sister-in-law Xie Caiping was sentenced to 18 years in prison on charges of running illegal gambling venues and drug dealing.

The crackdown is widely seen as a bid by Bo Xilai – who was appointed Communist Party secretary in Chongqing in 2007 – to move up in the national hierarchy via political maneuvering.

The corruption trials, covered extensively by Chinese media, have transfixed the nation and rallied Chongqing residents, who claim they are fed up with being bullied by their own local officials.

“Only capital punishment will serve him right. He deserves to be killed a thousand times,” one person commented online about Wen in February.

“The Wen Qiang case is only the tip of the iceberg,” another wrote. “If China wants more rapid development, there should be a purge to wipe out all the corrupted officials in Communist Party.”  Analysts said a harsh crackdown on corruption was vital to maintaining public faith in the Communist leadership.

For more information, please see:

CNN World – Ex-Chinese official executed for corruption – 7 July 2010

BBC – China rejects police official Wen Qiang death appeal – 21 May 2010

Al Jazeera English – China ‘executes’ justice official -7 July 2010

Australia proposes new policy for asylum seekers

By Polly Johnson
Impunity Watch Reporter, Oceania

Australian PM Julia Gillard makes a policy announcement regarding asylum seekers. (Photo Courtesy of CBC News.)
Australian PM Julia Gillard makes a policy announcement regarding asylum seekers. (Photo Courtesy of CBC News.)

SYDNEY, Australia – In an effort to unveil a new refugee policy, Australia’s new leader has proposed a plan to develop a regional processing center in East Timor in order to curb public opposition to an influx of asylum seekers from Sri Lanka and Afghanistan.

“In recent days I have discussed with [President] Ramos Horta of East Timor the possibility of establishing a regional processing center for the purpose of receiving and processing irregular entrance to the region,” Julia Gillard announced in her first policy speech since assuming her role as prime minister.

“A boat ride to Australia would just be a ticket back to the regional processing center,” Gillard added.

A hotly debated topic in Australia, illegal immigration has been dealt with in different ways by past leaders. Prime Minister John Howard set up detention centers in Papua New Guinea and Nauru. In 2007, Kevin Rudd supported a processing center at Australian-run Christmas Island, which can no longer cope with the number of people.

Though Australia only receives a tiny fraction of the world’s asylum seekers, since 2007 more than four thousand asylum seekers, many of them Afghans and Sri Lankans, have made the dangerous voyage via Indonesia on rickety boats, fleeing war and persecution.

East Timor’s deputy prime minister, José Luis Guterres, says that the country’s government has told Australia that East Timor is not ready establish such a center, though the government will consider Gillard’s request and send an official response soon.

Added East Timor’s foreign minister Zacarias da Costa, “We are a new country. Of course our borders are not yet one hundred percent secure. We are still developing our policies and we’ve been working together with Australia to strengthen our own mechanisms.”

Australian opposition leader Tony Abbott has also announced measures to deal with asylum seekers, including prioritizing offshore refugee applicants and turning away incoming boats when possible.

Gillard also announced that the Australian government was lifting the suspension on processing claims for Sri Lankans after the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights issued a report that the Sri Lankan refugee situation was improving.

For more information, please see:

Sydney Morning Herald – Labor’s Indian Ocean Solution – 7 July 2010

ABC News – East Timor ‘not ready’ for asylum centre – 6 July 2010

Al Jazeera – Australia plans new refugee policy – 6 July 2010

CBC News – Australia proposes East Timor refugee hub – 6 July 2010

New York Times – Australia Proposes Refugee Hub in East Timor – 6 July 2010

Sky News – PM Gillard Attempts To Calm Immigration Storm – 6 July 2010