Guatemalan Soldiers Stand Trial For Human Rights Violations

By Samuel Miller
Impunity Watch Desk Reporter, North America and Oceania

GUATEMALA CITY, Guatemala — A trial has begun in Guatemala of two ex-military officers for human rights abuses against indigenous women during the country’s long armed civil conflict. The trial marks the first time in history that sexual slavery will be prosecuted as a war crime in the country where it is alleged to have taken place.

Victims Leave the Guatemalan Courtroom. (Photo Courtesy of BBC News)

The two former military officers are facing charges of murder, rape and sexual abuse, domestic servitude and kidnapping, according to the Guatemalan attorney general’s office.

Prosecutors accuse Esteelmer Reyes, a 59-year-old retired colonel, of authorizing and consenting for soldiers under his command to exercise sexual violence and inhuman, cruel and degrading treatment against Maya-Q’eqchi’ women. Reyes suggested the trial is a political show to make it appear as if Guatemala’s government is doing justice.

“Within the Guatemalan army, during the 36 years of the civil war that we fought, there was not a single murderer. This is all a farce,” the ex-military commander said.

Prosecutor Hilda Pineda, however, said the former military commanders, in an effort to submit the local population to their will, authorized and consented to systematic acts of sexual abuse and inhumane, cruel and humiliating treatment against the victims and other women.

Guatemala’s civil war lasted 36 years. According to the United Nations, five out of every six victims of human rights violations were Mayan. The surviving women, now in their seventies and eighties, testified that the soldiers raped them and burned their houses down after their husbands were killed.

The women said they were then forced to report to the military base in Sepur Zarco in rotating shifts every three days, to cook and clean for the soldiers. The shifts lasted 10 months between 1982 and 1983, a period during which the women say they were still being raped. Some women were reportedly held on bondage for six years until the military base closed in 1988.

María Domínguez, a government advocate for the protection of indigenous women’s rights, said the importance of this case goes beyond the 11 women in this case.

“When you speak about the rape of women during the armed conflict, you’re talking about Guatemala’s history. Their human rights were violated, and this is something that it’s still happening every day. This is a landmark trial for the Guatemalan justice system,” said Domínguez.

This week’s trial against the two former army officials will be the first time that a case involving sexual slavery committed during an armed conflict will be heard in a domestic court.

For more information, please see:

BBC News — Guatemala military sexual violence trial starts – 2 February 2016

CNN — Guatemala tries 2 ex-military officers in sexual abuse of women in civil war – 2 February 2016

Latin Correspondent — Two former Guatemalan army officials face trial for sexual slavery – 2 February 2016

Latin Dispatch — Landmark Sexual Slavery Trial Begins in Guatemala – 2 February 2016

Latin One — Guatemalan Soldiers to Stand Trial for Civil War Sexual Slavery Charges – 2 February 2016

Tico Times — Two ex-soldiers tried in Guatemala for sex slavery, murder – 2 February 2016

Colombia’s Top Human Rights Official Resigns

By Kaitlyn Degnan
Impunity Watch Reporter, South America

BOGOTA, Colombia — Colombian Ombudsman Jorge Armando Otálora is facing allegations of sexual harassment from his former private secretary. Astrid Helena Cristancho, an attorney, resigned from her position last November “in protest.” She made her story and allegations of abuse public in Daniel Coronell’s column published in Semana. Cristancho provided Coronell with explicit photos sent to her by Otálora, documents and screenshots of conversations detailing the harassment.

Colombian Ombudsman Jorge Armando Otálora (photo courtesy of Latin Correspondent)

Cristancho filed an official complaint with the Attorney General in January. She said she did not immediately report the abuse out of fear, calling Otálora a “powerful person who has lots of money.” She told journalists while filing the complaint: “I call on all women and men who have been victims of any type of harassment to speak up.” She was wearing a T-shirt bearing the slogan “No Means No.”

Otálora, in response defended himself by saying he was in love with Cristancho, calling the photographs “the result of trust in a relationship between couples who spent very nice moments.”

Human Rights groups had called for Otálora’s resignation, and several politicians and political parties have withdrawn their support. Although Otálora had initially said that he would not resign, he finally did so on January 28. Otálora attributed the “media-hyped scandal” to “political enemies wanting to damage the institution he represents.”

Additionally, Otálora allegedly called for the resignation of his Assistant Ombudsman, Esiquio Manuel Sanchez Herrera, due to “institutional adjustments” in the office. Sanchez, however, claims that he made the decision to resign voluntarily because of the scandal.  He told reporters that he “made this decision voluntarily,” and that it is “best for the country and for the institution.”

Otálora was also accused of being an “abusive boss” by his former deputy, Juan Manual Osoria, who resigned in August 2015. He claimed to endure insults and screaming from Otálora. Cristancho also reported similar abuse in her complaint, in additional to the sexual harassment.

 

For more information, please see:

Semana – El acoso no era solo laboral, tambien sexuel – 23 January 2016

Latin Correspondent – Colombia’s Ombudsman embroiled in ugly labor and sexual abuse allegations – 26 January 2016 

EFE – Colombian ombudsman accused of harassment asks for resignation of his No. 2 – 27 January 2016

Prensa Latina – Colombia Ombusman Could Resign after Sexual Harassment – 27 January 2016

Associated Press – Colombia’s human rights boss resigns amid harassment scandal – 28 January 2016

Latin Post – Human Rights Groups Call for Colombia’s Ombudsman Jorge Armando Otálora’s Resignation Amid Sexual Harassment Scandal – 28 January 2016

 

 

ICTJ | In Focus: Japan’s Apology to South Korea Shows What Public Apologies Should (Not) Do

In Focus

Japan’s Apology to South Korea Shows What Public Apologies Should (Not) Do

In this op-ed, ICTJ President David Tolbert argues that Japan’s recent, controversial apology to South Korean “comfort women” falls short of international standards.

Read More…

Other News

Lebanon: ICTJ Study Shows Viability of a National Commission to Uncover Fate of the Missing and Disappeared

Twenty-five years after the end of the Lebanese Civil War, the families of the missing and forcibly disappeared in Lebanon are still waiting for answers about the fate of their loved ones. A new report by the International Center for Transitional Justice says the country seems to be ready to address this issue through an independent national commission and lays out the features of a successful future commission.

Read More…

As ICC Holds Key Hearing in Ongwen Case, LRA Victims in Uganda Need More Than Prosecutions

Ugandan victims of the LRA have waited over a decade to see the group’s leadership held accountable for crimes committed during the armed conflict with Uganda’s government. They saw it happen last week, when former LRA commander Dominic Ongwen appeared in court for an important hearing at the International Criminal Court.

Read More…

Publications

More Than Words: Apologies as a Form of Reparation

This report explores many of the issues and challenges likely to be faced by those considering a public apology as a form of reparation for victims of serious human rights violations.

View Report

Opening Up Remedies in Myanmar

This briefing paper calls on the soon-to-be-established NLD-led Burmese government to seriously consider taking steps to deal with Myanmar’s troubled past as a way to help end the cycle of violence and human rights violations in the conflict-torn country.

View Report

More Publications